For Red Dead Remptn 2 on the PlayStatn 4, a GameFAQs msage board topic tled "Is Arthur Man Gay or LGBTQ+? wont accept fun om female prostute?" - Page 5.
Contents:
IS ARTHUR MAN GAY OR LGBTQ+? WONT ACCEPT FUN OM FEMALE PROSTUTE?
There mt have been gay people, of urse, but they were closet gays, cuz if anyone knew that you were to that s*** back then, you would have end wh your cranm cracked and a bottle up your ass.
I know you'll thk this has nothg to do wh the topic but i jt thk that this answers your qutn cuz this is fely what would've happened if people found out that you're gay the 19th century wild wt.