LOS ANGELES (AP) — "Blurred L" was a breezy, upbeat h that beme the biggt song of 2013. Nearly two years later, the urt se spawned has once aga changed the fortun of s creators, Rob Thicke and Pharrell Williams, who were brand as pyright gers by a jury on Tuday. Marv Gaye's fay was award nearly $7.4 ln a cisn that will be on the mds of mic executiv and lawyers for years to e. The trial provid an si look at how today's mic is crafted, marketed and sold — and n be picked apart a feral urtroom. As jurors heard before startg liberatns last week, "Blurred L" was a bright spot a year when overall mic sal dropped four percent. Tuday's verdict clouds s legacy and s future, and prents new challeng for the beleaguered mic dtry. Ttimony and trial exhibs helped re-wre the story of "Blurred L." ___ THE NIGHT "BLURRED LINES" WAS BORN It was a by mid-June night for Pharrell at Glenwood Studs Burbank. In one stud, the h-makg producer was workg wh Miley Cys, and another, he was llaboratg wh rapper Earl's Sweatshirt. A third stud had been booked to rerd a song wh Thicke. Pharrell's memory of the events by his own admissn isn't perfect, but he rells gog to a stud and begng a procs he lls "surfg around" — lookg for chords that will form his latt h. He sat down at a dm set and started playg. Bluegrass was on his md bee of his work that day wh Cys. In an hour or ls, Pharrell said he had the mic to "Blurred L." When Thicke arrived, the pair pretend to be old men yellg at women, and those tlls beme a major element of the song. They started rerdg. "We were boppg and dancg," Pharrell said last week urt. "It was a ol night." ___ SELLING "BLURRED LINES" "We have to show the world why the mic is good," marketg executive Nile Bilzerian told jurors recently while explag how "Blurred L" was sold after was released March 2013. For "Blurred L," the song's mic vio drove s populary. Two versns were rerd, one featurg nu mols dancg wh the sgers. That unrated vio got banned by YouTube, which Bilzerian said "ed more of a buzz." The two versns have been viewed hundreds of lns of tim. The song's populary led to endorsements, wh both Beats and RadShack g ad mpaigns. Not surprisgly, viewers of the "Blurred L" vio were overwhelmgly male — 88 percent for the unrated versn acrdg to an analysis prented to jurors by an expert. The more people that watched and discsed the vio, the more the song sold. By May, Thicke and Pharrell were dog equent terviews about the song. Many had already drawn a nnectn between "Blurred L" and Gaye's 1977 h, "Got to Give It Up." ___ PROBLEMATIC WORDS Thicke repeatedly mentned terviews that "Got to Give It Up," one of his favore songs, was an spiratn for "Blurred L." He told terviewers he liked the song so much, he told Pharrell he wanted to rerd somethg siar. Stg on many of the terviews was an Interspe Rerds reprentative. Bilzerian said the label, which arranged hundreds of promotnal events for the song cludg appearanc on "The Ellen DeGener Show," the "Today" show and Howard Stern's show, didn't tell Thicke what to do or say. That exposure helped propel "Blurred L" to the top of the charts 80 untri, sellg more than 14 ln pi worldwi and 7.3 ln pi the Uned Stat alone. Marketg efforts st around $3 ln. Everyone volved, except Gaye's fay, ma money. Pharrell and Thicke pocketed more than $7 ln apiece profs om the song. Thicke's quot would e back to hnt him after Gaye's fay filed su. Thicke's fense of himself was unflatterg — he ttified he was dnk and high on dgs durg many of the terviews and misspoke about nversatns wh Pharrell. ___ THE TRIAL On Feb. 24, the sgers and Gaye's fay assembled for a trial that would terme whether "Blurred L" pied Gaye's mic. Eight jurors were picked, and the trial rumed the next day wh Thicke ttifyg and g a keyboard to play parts of songs om The Beatl, U2 and other artists to monstrate how siar not appear different mic. Williams ttified the followg week, and sat stone-faced the next day as Gaye fay attorney Richard Bch lled him and Thicke liars durg closg arguments. Thicke sed as Bch lled him nam. "Keep md at all tim," Bch told the jury, "the people are profsnal performers." Howard Kg, lead attorney for Pharrell and Thicke, played a versn of "Got to Give It Up" rerd om his sheet mic, then played "Blurred L." "If my clients were nng this se, I would thank you and s down. The songs are not the same," Kg said. He did not perform the proverbial "mic drop" but ntued speakg for several more mut, attackg the Gay' mic experts and tellg the panel he wouldn't discs damag bee he didn't thk they would be an issue. Damag did e up liberatns, and quickly, as revealed by a qutn the panel posed to a judge. On Tuday, the verdict was . Gaye's fay sat nervoly the igid urtroom. Thicke and Pharrell weren't prent. As a urt clerk read damage figur that would total nearly $7.4 ln, Gaye's dghter Nona wept. ___ AFTERMATH Gaye's fay will seek an junctn agast "Blurred L," which will give them negotiatg clout to get a bigger slice of future profs and possibly a songwrg cred for the late sger. The verdict will likely have a lastg impact on the mic dtry, wh many predictg that rerd labels will bee more nservative about releasg songs that sound siar to other works. The se uld be subject to years of motns and appeals, leavg the issue of mil homag murky legal waters for the near future. Dpe all, "Blurred L" isn't gog away, said Joe Levy, edor-at-large at Billboard. "People aren't gog to stop playg ," he said. "It's not jt gog to disappear." ___ Anthony McCartney n be reached at
Contents:
- MARV GAYE FAY CLAIMS ROB THICKE STOLE SONGS, HAS 'FIXATN' ON LATE SGER
- ROB THICKE, PHARRELL WILLIAMS TO PAY $5 LN TO MARV GAYE TATE FOR 'BLURRED L'
- JURY FDS ROB THICKE AND PHARRELL PIED A MARV GAYE SONG FOR BLURRED LJURY FDS ROB THICKE AND PHARRELL PIED A MARV GAYE SONG FOR BLURRED L
- MARV GAYE TATE VS ROB THICKE AND PHARRELL WILLIAMS
- ROB THICKE & PHARRELL WILLIAMS -- GOT TO GIVE IT UP TO MARV GAYE'S FAY ... JURY RUL 'BLURRED L' WAS A RIP-OFF
- ROB THICKE LAWSU: MARV GAYE’S FAY CLAIMS HE STOLE TWO SONGS
- ‘BLURRED L’ INGED ON MARV GAYE COPYRIGHT, JURY RUL
- PHARRELL WILLIAMS AND ROB THICKE TO PAY $7.4M TO MARV GAYE'S FAY OVER BLURRED L
MARV GAYE FAY CLAIMS ROB THICKE STOLE SONGS, HAS 'FIXATN' ON LATE SGER
Marv Gaye fay's pyright gement lawsu agast Rob Thicke and Pharrell Williams ends $5 ln judgment. * alan thicke marvin gaye song *
Legal saga wh Marv Gaye's fay nclus wh fal judgment.
ROB THICKE, PHARRELL WILLIAMS TO PAY $5 LN TO MARV GAYE TATE FOR 'BLURRED L'
Rob Thicke and Pharrell Williams were orred to pay $5 ln to Marv Gaye's tate, the fal verdict of the 'Blurred L' lawsu. * alan thicke marvin gaye song *
Marv Gaye fay's pyright gement lawsu agast Rob Thicke and Pharrell Williams ends $5 ln judgment. A judge has entered a nearly $5 ln judgment agast Rob Thicke and Pharrell Williams favor of Marv Gaye’s fay the long-nng lawsu volvg pyright gement surroundg Thicke and Williams’ song “Blurred L” and Gaye’s 1977 h “Got to Give It Up, ” Billboard reports. Are jotly required to pay Gaye’s fay.
JURY FDS ROB THICKE AND PHARRELL PIED A MARV GAYE SONG FOR BLURRED LJURY FDS ROB THICKE AND PHARRELL PIED A MARV GAYE SONG FOR BLURRED L
Gaye fay award $7.3 ln * alan thicke marvin gaye song *
97 to the Gaye fay. Addnally, The Gaye fay is entled to receive prejudgment tert on the damag award and rpective profs agast each of them, which totals to $9097. The Gaye fay is also entled to royalti gog forward for 50 percent of the songwrer and publishg revenue g om “Blurred L.
The tate of Marv Gaye is firg back at Rob Thicke over more than "Blurred L, " the tle track of his latt rerd. The fay ially claimed that Thicke's h plagiarized the soul in's 1977 track "Got to Give It Up" — and now, they're sistg that the sger stole om two of Gaye's Augt, the wrers of "Blurred L" — Thicke, Pharrell Williams and Clifford Harris, Jr. — preemptively sued Gaye's tate after plats (as well as the group Funkalic), claimg that "Blurred L" was "starkly different" om "Got to Give It Up.
MARV GAYE TATE VS ROB THICKE AND PHARRELL WILLIAMS
The fay of ceased “What’s Gog On” sger Marv Gaye has gone on the legal attack agast sger Rob Thicke, filg a lawsu claimg that Thicke pilfered two of Gaye’s songs for his own work. The Gaye fay filed su on Wednday, allegg that Thicke not only stole Gaye’s “Got to Give It Up” for his mega-h “Blurred L,” but also lifted Gaye’s “After the Dance” for his track “Love After War.” * alan thicke marvin gaye song *
" Now Gaye's fay have filed a untersu agast Thicke that claims he not only ripped off "Got to Give It Up" but that he also ged on the pyright to Gaye's song "After the Dance" for the tle track of his 2011 album "Love After War. " Legal papers also suggt that they're eyeg other songs Thicke's talog over the sger's alleged "Marv Gaye fixatn, " acrdg to The Hollywood Gaye llaborator David Rz: Rob Thicke, you're no Marv GayeIn their su, the Gay acce Thicke of wrg a siar chos, melody and more his song "Love After War, " wh regard to Gaye's "After the Dance. " They also acce Thicke of "cludg the siar bridge and intil lyrics om Marv Gaye's 'I Want You' (his) siarly-themed work, 'Make U Love Me.
'" They have not yet filed any claims over that song lawsu also go after Gaye's mic publisher, EMI April, which now operat unr the pany that manag Thicke's mic, Sony/ATV. Acrdg to THR, Gaye's fay acc the mic publisher of not protectg the sger's songs, attemptg to sre them away om takg legal reurse, givg up ntraly when the nflict of tert arose and tryg to draw public support away om the fay.
The fay's goal is for EMI to lose the rights to Gaye's talog, as well as all profs accumulated om "Blurred L. It claims they acced the Gay of "g an credible song, " "killg the goose that laid the goln egg" and sullyg the opportuny for "Blurred L" to w an MTV Vio Mic Award, as well as stiflg s chanc for wng a Grammy.
ROB THICKE & PHARRELL WILLIAMS -- GOT TO GIVE IT UP TO MARV GAYE'S FAY ... JURY RUL 'BLURRED L' WAS A RIP-OFF
The jury found that Rob Thicke and Pharrell Williams, who share a songwrg cred on the song, had mted pyright gement, and award more than $7.3 ln to Mr. Gaye’s fay. * alan thicke marvin gaye song *
"The Gaye fay's lawsu claims that Thicke admted that he stole mic om Marv pre-release terviews.
ROB THICKE LAWSU: MARV GAYE’S FAY CLAIMS HE STOLE TWO SONGS
* alan thicke marvin gaye song *
" Thicke has sce nied any associatn wh the Gaye 's fay quote crics who have claimed to hear a remblance between the songs reviews for Rollg Stone and The New York Tim.
Rob Thicke, Pharrell Williams to pay $5 ln to Marv Gaye tate for 'Blurred L'The five-year legal battle has end wh a verdict favor of Mart Gaye's tate, who sued claimg "Blurred L" pied Gaye's "Got To Give It Up"Sger Pharrell Williams and sger Rob Thicke perform together Fayetteville, Arkansas, on June 6, Wilkg / Rters fileDec.
13, 2018, 8:24 PM UTCThe long drawn-out pyright battle over Rob Thicke’s 2013 song “Blurred L” has end after a judge orred Thicke and Pharrell Williams to pay almost $5 ln to Marv Gaye’s tate the se’s fal lg.
‘BLURRED L’ INGED ON MARV GAYE COPYRIGHT, JURY RUL
Members of Gaye’s fay sued Thicke and Williams, along wh rapper and featured artist on the song, T. I., 2013 for pyright gement of Gaye’s 1977 h song “Got to Give It Up. ”In 2015, the Gaye fay won their se.
The urt orred Thicke and Williams to pay Gaye’s tate more than $7 ln dollars, an amount that was later rced to $5. 6 lg, a judge the Central District of California reaffirmed the March lg, clarg Thicke, Williams, and More Water From Nazareth Publishg mt pay Gaye’s tate $2. 76 ln dollars, while Williams and his publishg pany mt each pay Gaye’s tat separate rewards of $357, 630.
PHARRELL WILLIAMS AND ROB THICKE TO PAY $7.4M TO MARV GAYE'S FAY OVER BLURRED L
Was cleared of any liabily March, a cisn upheld this last and fal Gaye tate was also reward half of the song’s nng royalti om after the urt’s origal judgment date, and tert of 0. In 2016, more than 200 micians, cludg Jennifer Hudson and Hans Zimmer, filed an amic brief support of Thicke and Williams appeal, claimg the verdict would be “very dangero” to the mic the Gaye fay first filed their lawsu, other high-profile artists like Lana Del Rey and Mark Ronson have been siarly KslenBen Kslen is a reporter for NBC News. Jury fds Rob Thicke and Pharrell pied a Marv Gaye song for Blurred L / Gaye fay award $7.