tolkiens legendarium - When were Frodo and Sam first nceptualized as gay? - Science Fictn & Fantasy Stack Exchange

Contents:

• WAS FRODO BAGGS GAY AND IS SAM LOVE WH HIM?
• WHEN WERE FRODO AND SAM FIRST NCEPTUALIZED AS GAY?
• HOW FRODO AND SAM WERE “MOSTLY GAY”
• JAGUARS ASSOCIATE STRENGTH ACH KEV MAXEN OUT AS GAY A FIRST FOR US-BASED PRO LEAGU
• A GAY GIRL’S GUI TO THE 2023 WOMEN’S WORLD CUP

WAS FRODO BAGGS GAY AND IS SAM LOVE WH HIM?

Outsi of the safe darkns of the theater, the Mordor-like wasteland of middle school, the movi were synonymo wh the favored sult of the time — “gay. Early-2000s preteen Ameri was a time of gay jok, of “no homo, ” of mockg voic and slurs, and secret, punive vlence enacted the locker room agast anyone who had a whiff of otherns. He faced a urt-martial 1918 after one of his letters scribed “homosexual relatns wh men his pany.

Two years before The Lord of the Rgs was published, war-wng breaker and geni mathematician Alan Turg stood trial for “homosexual acts and gross cency” — that is, beg ught his own home wh another man.

Lewis wrote a letter to Sheldon Vanken (later reprted Vanken’s tobgraphy) that Lewis had received a letter om a “p male homosexual [... The only mentn is a bland reference his bgraphy by Humphrey Carpenter: “As to homosexualy, Tolkien claimed that at neteen he did not even know the word. As scribed by thor Reynolds Price, at least one member of Tolkien’s iend group, the Inklgs, “separated om his wife and lived a quietly homosexual life.

WHEN WERE FRODO AND SAM FIRST NCEPTUALIZED AS GAY?

She beme an in the gay male muny for wrg sympathetilly about same-sex relatnships ancient Greece. Bilbo and Frodo’s home of Bag End is scribed by other hobbs as “a queer place, and s folk are queerer” — an adjective which had a strong nnotatn of homosexualy by the late 1800s. It’s tricky to apply morn labels to people that they did not claim life — but morn labels clu “straight” and “cisgenr” jt as much as “gay” or “transgenr.

One of them was Geofey Bache Smh, a poet whose work is nsired homoromantic by morn rears. In The Lord of the Rgs: The Fellowship of the Rg's st mentary, Ian McKellen, a gay in his own right who played Gandalf the Grey, revealed that he was rponsible for the cln of a small but ccial moment between Sam (Sean Ast) and Frodo (Elijah Wood) that featured the books but might not have ma to the films whout his suggtn.

"When I suggted to Sean that he take Elijah's hand, ” McKellen explas, “ was bee I thought that [] might be missed by two rolutely heterosexual actors who might not appreciate that gay people, like myself, saw a touch somethg, perhaps, more meangful than others might.

HOW FRODO AND SAM WERE “MOSTLY GAY”

McKellen’s suggtn exemplifi how The Lord of the Rgs so succsfully rved a niche for self as a part of queer fandom, and why LGBTQ+ fans are so drawn to the Sam/Frodo relatnship the books: Though Tolkien himself likely didn’t tend to the relatnship as gay, the sheer tenrns of the language and the nstant affectn between the two speaks to a kd of timacy that queer fans are able to regnize and ronate wh. There is an obv bond between the two ma Hobb characters Lord of the Rgs books and movi, so people are wh reason wonrg, was Frodo Baggs gay, and is Sam love wh him?

Neher was said that Frodo Baggs was gay nor that Sam was love wh him. Frodo and Sam fely have some nnectn that rarely any other characters the books have (there are few), but is their relatnship gay, and is Sam love wh Frodo is really hard to tell. LOTR/The Hobb rrect quot for the is also probably really gay bee I say try before you ny.

It's clear that Tolkien would have read The Iliad, The Odyssey, etc and would have no doubt unrstood the homosexualy folk stori and legends. While Merry and Pipp seem to have a much more normal iendship whout a lot of homoeroticism. Bradley don't seem to agree that the Frodo and Sam relatnship should be classified as homosexual, but she fely floats the ia.

JAGUARS ASSOCIATE STRENGTH ACH KEV MAXEN OUT AS GAY A FIRST FOR US-BASED PRO LEAGU

And some wrers --Judh Merril a book whose name I have fotten--glanced on the possibily that future spachip crews or loni on the moon, all-male, would have to pensate for possible reprsed homosexual sir themselv. But mt we now have a rash of stori whose thors feel nsciently obligated to al wh the evable problem of homosexualy 'rearg s ugly head' every spachip story om now on, jt bee that problem is well and tly alt wh one or two such stori? I emphasize this pot bee was forcibly lled to my attentn when a iend suggted that I should clu the last two of the Tolkien seri on my annual listg of fictn alg wh homosexual and variant them.

A GAY GIRL’S GUI TO THE 2023 WOMEN’S WORLD CUP

All -- to my d surprise, beg ed to hearg some of the biased crics mand that David and Jonathan mt be openly claimed among the homosexual aristocracy -- were absolute agreement that Tolkien's "real" meang uld safely be left to a psychoanalyst and that the books should NOT be clud on such a listg! Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rgs seri ntu as cultural vandals attempt to repeat their lie ad nsm that Samwise Gamgee and Frodo Baggs are gay. The latt effort to spread the li after Twter er WargarW theorized that if Hollywood was makg The Lord of the Rgs today “Aragorn would have been a woman (but Arwen still a she-Elf), Frodo & Sam would have been gay, Gandalf black & the only whe male actors the entire st would have been Dehor, Gríma & Saman.

Twter er MadzBtal tweeted, “Everythg else asi, image watchg Lord of the Rgs and not thkg Sam and Frodo are gay. RELATED: The Lord Of The Rgs Fan Se Embarrass Itself By Promotg Easily Disprovable Gay Elv Theory. Even if you haven’t read the books, and have only seen Peter Jackson’s adaptatn of them, ’s abundantly clear that Sam and Frodo are not homosexuals.

It’s crystal clear that Sam and Frodo are not homosexuals, and if you try to project that onto them, you are eher lnal, or sisterly phg a disorred agenda.