Is fah-based opposn to gay marriage a ‘protected characteristic’? | The Spectator

fraser nelson gay

Recent Posts

GAY STORIES ROMANCEDecember 15, 2024
LGBT RACIAL DIVERSITYDecember 15, 2024
OLDER GAY PERSONALSDecember 15, 2024
SNOOP DOGG GAY SONDecember 15, 2024
ROI CAMBODGE GAYDecember 15, 2024
GAY SEX DOMINATIONDecember 15, 2024
EDDIE COCAINE BEAR GAYDecember 15, 2024
FIRST OPENLY GAY MAN EVERDecember 15, 2024
FRANK WOLF GAY FROMDecember 15, 2024
GAY RELATIONSHIP WITH NO SEXDecember 15, 2024

Tags

Kate Forb’s n for First Mister may be short-lived but will certaly be tertg. Her challenge: she’s a member to the Free Church of Stland which oppos gay marriage, abortn and genr self-ID. For seven years as a parliamentarian she has avoid sayg what she thks about such issu and for obv reasons:

Contents:

SPECTATOR’S FRASER NELSON SAYS HE DIDN’T LL EUROVISN ‘TOO GAY’

The Seventi saw many women's rights, gay rights, and environmental movements.

Spectator edor Fraser Nelson, 41, has e unr fire after remarks he ma at the Eurovisn nference last week were terpreted as implyg the petn was “too gay”. “[In the UK Eurovisn is] rced to the level of a mil gay pri march.

”But Nelson, prevly a bs wrer for The Tim and polil mentator for the News of the World, told The Inpennt he didn’t say Eurovisn was “too gay” and said that he fds the ia of such a view “repugnant” Nelson is the edor of The Spectator (Getty)He said the “unfortunate phrase” was ed by the panel’s morator who later apologised for when an dience-member plaed about .

IS FAH-BASED OPPOSN TO GAY MARRIAGE A ‘PROTECTED CHARACTERISTIC’?

“I didn't say was ‘too gay’ - nor would I ever make such a daft remark, ” Fraser said. After years parliament she will have been aware of the reactn to an MSP who clared their opposn to gay marriage, let alone pre-maral sex.

” And on gay marriage: “I would have voted, as a matter of nscience, along the l of mastream teachg most major religns, that marriage is between a man and a woman. Her challenge: she’s a member to the Free Church of Stland which oppos gay marriage, abortn and genr self-ID.

But today she was asked directly and gave a straight answer: she would have voted agast gay marriage and would have ‘stggled’ to back Nila Sturgeon on genr self-ID.

THE HISTORY OF NELSON GAY – A REMARKABLE PROVENANCE

Sadiq Khan, for example, is unlikely to be asked if he backs gay marriage – not jt bee this isn’t really relevant to his duti as Mayor of London but bee this would be seen as a dig at his beg Mlim. You n be agast gay marriage your own church, mosque or synagogue – but through a belief liberty, vote to ensure that others n arrange their own affairs any way they like. Tim Farron voted for equal marriage but was asked a different qutn: did he regard gay sex as sful?

She offers the example of Angela Merkel, who personally opposed gay marriage but still believed that should be brought if via a mocratic procs. Yoaf has, meanwhile, been asked by Andrew Marr about gay marriage.

When to gay marriage, do Yoaf disagree wh his fah – or his party? Farron’s learship of the Lib Dems was, of urse, sunk by repeated qutns as to whether he thought gay sex is sful.

*BEAR-MAGAZINE.COM* FRASER NELSON GAY

</tle><path fill-le="evenodd" clip-le="evenodd" d="M12.1303 0.000379039C10.9833 -0.00959082 9.87819 0.431464 9.05309 1.22855L9.04556 1.23593L7.79145 2.48303C7.50587 2.767 7.50453 3.22877 7.78844 3.51441C8.07235 3.80004 8.53401 3.80139 8.81959 3.51741L10.0698 2.27423C10.6194 1.74503 11.3546 1.45229 12.1177 1.45892C12.8824 1.46556 13.6139 1.77236 14.1546 2.31323C14.6954 2.8541 15.0021 3.58577 15.0087 4.35065C15.0154 5.11353 14.7229 5.84857 14.1943 6.39829L12.0116 8.58145L12.0115 8.58155C11.7159 8.87739 11.36 9.10617 10.9682 9.25237C10.5764 9.39857 10.1577 9.45878 9.74051 9.42889C9.32337 9.39901 8.91752 9.27975 8.55051 9.07918C8.1835 8.87862 7.8639 8.60146 7.6134 8.26649C7.3722 7.94396 6.91526 7.87807 6.5928 8.11933C6.27034 8.36059 6.20447 8.81763 6.44567 9.14016C6.82142 9.64261 7.30082 10.0584 7.85134 10.3592C8.40186 10.66 9.01062 10.8389 9.63634 10.8838C10.2621 10.9286 10.8901 10.8383 11.4779 10.619C12.0656 10.3997 12.5994 10.0565 13.0429 9.61274L15.2302 7.42494L15.2391 7.4159C16.036 6.59062 16.4769 5.48529 16.467 4.33797C16.457 3.19066 15.9969 2.09316 15.1858 1.28185C14.3746 0.470545 13.2774 0.0103489 12.1303 0.000379039ZM7.29806 5.11625C6.67234 5.07142 6.0443 5.16173 5.45654 5.38103C4.86882 5.60031 4.33502 5.94355 3.89153 6.38727L1.70423 8.57506L1.69534 8.5841C0.898438 9.40939 0.457483 10.5147 0.467451 11.662C0.477418 12.8094 0.937512 13.9069 1.74864 14.7182C2.55976 15.5295 3.65701 15.9897 4.80407 15.9996C5.95113 16.0096 7.05622 15.5685 7.88132 14.7715L7.89035 14.7626L9.13717 13.5155C9.42192 13.2307 9.42192 12.7689 9.13717 12.4841C8.85243 12.1993 8.39077 12.1993 8.10602 12.4841L6.86392 13.7265C6.31432 14.2552 5.57945 14.5477 4.81675 14.5411C4.05204 14.5344 3.32054 14.2276 2.77979 13.6868C2.23904 13.1459 1.93231 12.4142 1.92566 11.6494C1.91904 10.8865 2.21146 10.1514 2.74011 9.60172L4.92287 7.41846C5.21854 7.12262 5.57437 6.89384 5.96621 6.74763C6.35805 6.60143 6.77674 6.54123 7.19389 6.57111C7.61104 6.601 8.01688 6.72026 8.38389 6.92082C8.75091 7.12138 9.0705 7.39855 9.32101 7.73352C9.56221 8.05605 10.0191 8.12194 10.3416 7.88068C10.6641 7.63942 10.7299 7.18238 10.4887 6.85985C10.113 6.3574 9.63359 5.94165 9.08307 5.64081C8.53255 5.33997 7.92378 5.16107 7.29806 5.11625Z"></path></g></svg></div><div translated class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__size-14--Ume6q ontend-pencraft-Text-module__le-height-20--p0dP8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__weight-normal--s54Wf ontend-pencraft-Text-module__font-text--QmNJR ontend-pencraft-Text-module__lor-sendary--WRADg ontend-pencraft-Text-module__ret--dW0zZ ontend-pencraft-Text-module__body4--Pl3xY">Copy lk</div></button><button tabInx="0" type="button" class="button share-actn"><div class="actn-in"><svg role="img" width="16" height="17" viewBox="0 0 16 17" fill="none" stroke-width="1.8" stroke="#000" xmlns="><g><tle></tle><path d="M10.6543 1.38723C10.3533 0.960814 9.95383 0.61341 9.48976 0.374567C9.02902 0.137956 8.51908 0.0130716 8.00115 0.0100098C7.86087 0.0101844 7.72354 0.0502687 7.60519 0.125581C7.48684 0.200893 7.39237 0.308324 7.3328 0.435326L5.00368 5.67077H3.029C2.72335 5.66964 2.42059 5.73003 2.13876 5.84833C1.85692 5.96663 1.60177 6.14043 1.38849 6.35938C1.16707 6.57502 0.991841 6.83346 0.873459 7.11897C0.755078 7.40447 0.696022 7.71108 0.699885 8.02014V13.691C0.699885 14.3087 0.945273 14.9012 1.38207 15.338C1.81886 15.7747 2.41128 16.0201 3.029 16.0201H13.348C13.8951 16.021 14.425 15.8283 14.8438 15.4762C15.2626 15.1241 15.5434 14.6352 15.6366 14.0961L16.6493 8.4252C16.7252 8.09192 16.7252 7.74582 16.6493 7.41254C16.566 7.08205 16.4104 6.7742 16.1936 6.51128C15.9746 6.25 15.7017 6.03926 15.3936 5.89355C15.0762 5.7467 14.7306 5.67068 14.3809 5.67077H10.5328L11.0391 4.37457C11.2397 3.88784 11.3162 3.35894 11.2619 2.83533C11.1853 2.30894 10.9763 1.81065 10.6543 1.38723ZM4.75052 14.5518H3.029C2.91049 14.5525 2.79303 14.5296 2.68349 14.4844C2.57394 14.4392 2.47452 14.3726 2.39102 14.2885C2.23609 14.1199 2.14945 13.8997 2.14799 13.6708V8.02014C2.14913 7.901 2.17389 7.78328 2.22082 7.67377C2.26775 7.56427 2.33592 7.46515 2.4214 7.38216C2.50369 7.29576 2.60267 7.22698 2.71233 7.17998C2.822 7.13298 2.94007 7.10874 3.05938 7.10874H4.7809L4.75052 14.5518ZM10.6746 7.05811H14.3809C14.5145 7.05821 14.6462 7.08942 14.7657 7.14925C14.8875 7.20532 14.9948 7.28845 15.0796 7.39229C15.1675 7.49052 15.2301 7.60871 15.2619 7.73659C15.2922 7.8665 15.2922 8.00162 15.2619 8.13153L14.2493 13.8024C14.2087 14.017 14.094 14.2106 13.9252 14.3492C13.7619 14.4812 13.558 14.5528 13.348 14.5518H6.19862V6.45052L8.43659 1.38723H8.52773C8.9042 1.50037 9.23304 1.73413 9.4636 2.05252C9.69416 2.37092 9.81365 2.75627 9.80368 3.14925C9.8181 3.39741 9.78015 3.64583 9.69229 3.87836L9.23659 5.04292C9.15397 5.273 9.12623 5.51921 9.15558 5.76191C9.1877 6.00427 9.27425 6.23623 9.40875 6.44039C9.5535 6.6376 9.74028 6.80017 9.95558 6.91634C10.1774 7.03206 10.4244 7.0912 10.6746 7.08849V7.05811Z"></path></g></svg></div><div translated class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__size-14--Ume6q ontend-pencraft-Text-module__le-height-20--p0dP8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__weight-normal--s54Wf ontend-pencraft-Text-module__font-text--QmNJR ontend-pencraft-Text-module__lor-sendary--WRADg ontend-pencraft-Text-module__ret--dW0zZ ontend-pencraft-Text-module__body4--Pl3xY">Facebook</div></button><button tabInx="0" type="button" class="button share-actn"><div class="actn-in"><svg role="img" width="21" height="16" viewBox="0 0 21 16" fill="none" stroke-width="1.8" stroke="#000" xmlns="><g><tle></tle><path fill-le="evenodd" clip-le="evenodd" d="M2.22192 2.20503C2.36754 1.77115 2.78269 1.45455 3.26639 1.45455H17.9332C18.4169 1.45455 18.8321 1.77118 18.9777 2.2051L10.5999 8.02107L2.22192 2.20503ZM2.16639 3.94198V13.4545C2.16639 14.0529 2.66307 14.5455 3.26639 14.5455H17.9332C18.5365 14.5455 19.0332 14.0529 19.0332 13.4545V3.94206L11.0204 9.50462C10.7679 9.67991 10.4318 9.67991 10.1793 9.50462L2.16639 3.94198ZM20.4999 2.55809V13.4545C20.4999 14.8562 19.3465 16 17.9332 16H3.26639C1.85304 16 0.699707 14.8562 0.699707 13.4545V2.54545C0.699707 1.14379 1.85304 0 3.26639 0H17.9332C19.3407 0 20.4904 1.13441 20.4998 2.52818C20.5 2.53816 20.5001 2.54813 20.4999 2.55809Z"></path></g></svg></div><div translated class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__size-14--Ume6q ontend-pencraft-Text-module__le-height-20--p0dP8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__weight-normal--s54Wf ontend-pencraft-Text-module__font-text--QmNJR ontend-pencraft-Text-module__lor-sendary--WRADg ontend-pencraft-Text-module__ret--dW0zZ ontend-pencraft-Text-module__body4--Pl3xY">Email</div></button><button tabInx="0" type="button" class="button share-actn"><div class="actn-in"><svg role="img" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke-width="1.8" stroke="#000" xmlns="><g><tle></tle><path d="M6.785 1.92766C5.45134 1.57031 4.08049 2.36176 3.72314 3.69543L0.444815 15.9303C0.0874636 17.264 0.878901 18.6348 2.21255 18.9922L5.37495 19.8396V7.66664C5.37495 6.40099 6.40096 5.37498 7.66661 5.37498H19.4723C19.3299 5.30548 19.1788 5.24858 19.0201 5.20604L6.785 1.92766Z" stroke="none"></path><path fill-le="evenodd" clip-le="evenodd" d="M8.44161 7.4C7.86632 7.4 7.39995 7.86637 7.39995 8.44167V22.1081C7.39995 22.6834 7.86631 23.1498 8.4416 23.1498L22.1083 23.15C22.6836 23.15 23.1499 22.6836 23.1499 22.1083V8.44167C23.1499 7.86637 22.6836 7.4 22.1083 7.4H8.44161ZM10.3999 9.65C9.84766 9.65 9.39995 10.0977 9.39995 10.65C9.39995 11.2023 9.84766 11.65 10.3999 11.65H18.3999C18.9522 11.65 19.3999 11.2023 19.3999 10.65C19.3999 10.0977 18.9522 9.65 18.3999 9.65H10.3999ZM10.3999 14.15C9.84766 14.15 9.39995 14.5977 9.39995 15.15C9.39995 15.7023 9.84766 16.15 10.3999 16.15H15.3999C15.9522 16.15 16.3999 15.7023 16.3999 15.15C16.3999 14.5977 15.9522 14.15 15.3999 14.15H10.3999Z" stroke="none"></path></g></svg></div><div class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__size-14--Ume6q ontend-pencraft-Text-module__le-height-20--p0dP8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__weight-normal--s54Wf ontend-pencraft-Text-module__font-text--QmNJR ontend-pencraft-Text-module__lor-sendary--WRADg ontend-pencraft-Text-module__ret--dW0zZ ontend-pencraft-Text-module__body4--Pl3xY">Not</div></button><button tabInx="0" id="trigger54805" aria-expand="false" aria-haspopup="dialog" aria-ntrols="dialog54806" ariaLabel="View more" type="button" class="button share-actn"><div class="actn-in"><svg role="img" width="100" height="100" viewBox="0 0 100 100" fill="none" stroke-width="1.8" stroke="#000" xmlns="><g><tle></tle><circle cx="23" cy="50" r="9"></circle><circle cx="50" cy="50" r="9"></circle><circle cx="77" cy="50" r="9"></circle></g></svg></div><div translated class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__size-14--Ume6q ontend-pencraft-Text-module__le-height-20--p0dP8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__weight-normal--s54Wf ontend-pencraft-Text-module__font-text--QmNJR ontend-pencraft-Text-module__lor-sendary--WRADg ontend-pencraft-Text-module__ret--dW0zZ ontend-pencraft-Text-module__body4--Pl3xY">Other</div></button></div></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="tw-bg-pub-wash tw-py-8 sm:tw-pb-16"><div class="ntaer"><div class="tw-ems-end tw-gap-8 sm:tw-flex"><div class="tw-mx-to tw-mb-6 tw-box-borr tw-h-32 tw-w-32 tw-shrk-0 tw-overflow-hidn tw-round-lg tw-borr-4 tw-borr-solid tw-borr-whe tw-bg-gray-400 tw-shadow-md sm:tw-mx-0 sm:tw-mb-0 sm:tw-h-56 sm:tw-w-56"><img src=" class="tw-h-full tw-w-full tw-object-ver" /></div><div class="tw-text-center sm:tw-text-left"><div class="tw-mb-1 tw-font-sans tw-text-sm tw-font-semibold tw-upperse tw-text-pub-sendary-text">Jul 22, 2022 • 1HR 26M</div><h1 class="tw-mt-0 tw-mb-2 tw-leadg-tight sm:tw-mb-1 tw-text-3xl sm:tw-text-4xl">Fraser Nelson On The PM Race And Tory Diversy</h1><h3 class="tw-my-0 tw-font-sans tw-font-normal tw-text-pub-sendary-text tw-text-lg">A one-stop shop for unrstandg ntemporary Brish polics.</h3></div></div><div class="post-subhear"><div class="left"><div class="label-stack"><div class="publish-ntext"><time dateTime="2022-07-22T15:54:51.106Z">Jul 22, 2022</time></div></div></div><div class="right"><div class="post-ufi style-button themed"><div class="like-button-ntaer post-ufi-button style-button"><a role="button" class="post-ufi-button style-button has-label wh-borr"><svg role="img" style="height: 20px; width: 20px;" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="#000000" stroke-width="2" stroke="#000" xmlns=" class="in"><g><tle></tle><svg xmlns=" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" stroke-width="2" stroke-lep="round" stroke-lejo="round" class="luci luci-heart"><path d="M19 14c1.49-1.46 3-3.21 3-5.5A5.5 5.5 0 0 0 16.5 3c-1.76 0-3 .5-4.5 2-1.5-1.5-2.74-2-4.5-2A5.5 5.5 0 0 0 2 8.5c0 2.3 1.5 4.05 3 5.5l7 7Z"></path></svg></g></svg><div class="label">36</div></a><div role="dialog" class="modal typography out gone share-dialog popup"><div class="modal-table"><div class="modal-row"><div class="modal-cell modal-ntent no-fullscreen"><div class="ntaer"><button tabInx="0" type="button" data-ttid="close-modal" class="pencraft modal-btn modal-ex-btn no-marg ontend-pencraft-Button-module__inButton--xpBoH ontend-pencraft-Button-module__buttonBase--T0hXz ontend-pencraft-Button-module__size_40--RASvV ontend-pencraft-Button-module__prry_sendary--UEXV6 ontend-pencraft-Button-module__fill_empty--OPYgN ontend-pencraft-Button-module__round--D6jfD"><svg xmlns=" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="sendary" stroke-width="2" stroke-lep="round" stroke-lejo="round" class="luci luci-x"><le x1="18" x2="6" y1="6" y2="18"></le><le x1="6" x2="18" y1="6" y2="18"></le></svg></button><div class="share-dialog-tle">Share this post</div><div class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__display-flex--ZqeZt ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-directn-lumn--Rq7pk ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-gap-32--uRr14 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__paddg-x-24--ViY5j ontend-pencraft-Box-module__paddg-top-32--hE9Ly ontend-pencraft-Box-module__paddg-bottom-48--OND"><div class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__display-flex--ZqeZt ontend-pencraft-Box-module__paddg-8--wF5Sz ontend-pencraft-Box-module__borr-tail--MiH57 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__borr-radi-12--AmQy9 social-preview-box post"><div class="social-image-box"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset=" /><img src=" siz="100vw" alt loadg="lazy" width="120" class="ontend-ponents-rponsive_img-module__img--Pgjj2 social-image" /></picture></div><div class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__display-flex--ZqeZt ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-directn-lumn--Rq7pk ontend-pencraft-Box-module__paddg-y-8--exiCC ontend-pencraft-Box-module__paddg-left-12--eE6bp"><h4 class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__size-16--fFowu ontend-pencraft-Text-module__le-height-20--p0dP8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__weight-bold--Ps9DB ontend-pencraft-Text-module__font-text--QmNJR ontend-pencraft-Text-module__lor-primary--ud4Z0 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__ret--dW0zZ ontend-pencraft-Text-module__hear4--hH3cg">Fraser Nelson On The PM Race And Tory Diversy</h4><div class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__size-14--Ume6q ontend-pencraft-Text-module__le-height-20--p0dP8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__weight-normal--s54Wf ontend-pencraft-Text-module__font-text--QmNJR ontend-pencraft-Text-module__lor-sendary--WRADg ontend-pencraft-Text-module__ret--dW0zZ ontend-pencraft-Text-module__body4--Pl3xY"></div></div></div><div class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__display-flex--ZqeZt ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-jtify-space-between--NvIcg ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-gap-8--HFpIK share-dialog-buttons-wrapper"><button tabInx="0" type="button" class="button share-actn"><div class="actn-in"><svg role="img" width="20" height="16" viewBox="0 0 20 16" fill="none" stroke-width="1.8" stroke="#000" xmlns="><g><tle></tle><path fill-le="evenodd" clip-le="evenodd" d="M12.1303 0.000379039C10.9833 -0.00959082 9.87819 0.431464 9.05309 1.22855L9.04556 1.23593L7.79145 2.48303C7.50587 2.767 7.50453 3.22877 7.78844 3.51441C8.07235 3.80004 8.53401 3.80139 8.81959 3.51741L10.0698 2.27423C10.6194 1.74503 11.3546 1.45229 12.1177 1.45892C12.8824 1.46556 13.6139 1.77236 14.1546 2.31323C14.6954 2.8541 15.0021 3.58577 15.0087 4.35065C15.0154 5.11353 14.7229 5.84857 14.1943 6.39829L12.0116 8.58145L12.0115 8.58155C11.7159 8.87739 11.36 9.10617 10.9682 9.25237C10.5764 9.39857 10.1577 9.45878 9.74051 9.42889C9.32337 9.39901 8.91752 9.27975 8.55051 9.07918C8.1835 8.87862 7.8639 8.60146 7.6134 8.26649C7.3722 7.94396 6.91526 7.87807 6.5928 8.11933C6.27034 8.36059 6.20447 8.81763 6.44567 9.14016C6.82142 9.64261 7.30082 10.0584 7.85134 10.3592C8.40186 10.66 9.01062 10.8389 9.63634 10.8838C10.2621 10.9286 10.8901 10.8383 11.4779 10.619C12.0656 10.3997 12.5994 10.0565 13.0429 9.61274L15.2302 7.42494L15.2391 7.4159C16.036 6.59062 16.4769 5.48529 16.467 4.33797C16.457 3.19066 15.9969 2.09316 15.1858 1.28185C14.3746 0.470545 13.2774 0.0103489 12.1303 0.000379039ZM7.29806 5.11625C6.67234 5.07142 6.0443 5.16173 5.45654 5.38103C4.86882 5.60031 4.33502 5.94355 3.89153 6.38727L1.70423 8.57506L1.69534 8.5841C0.898438 9.40939 0.457483 10.5147 0.467451 11.662C0.477418 12.8094 0.937512 13.9069 1.74864 14.7182C2.55976 15.5295 3.65701 15.9897 4.80407 15.9996C5.95113 16.0096 7.05622 15.5685 7.88132 14.7715L7.89035 14.7626L9.13717 13.5155C9.42192 13.2307 9.42192 12.7689 9.13717 12.4841C8.85243 12.1993 8.39077 12.1993 8.10602 12.4841L6.86392 13.7265C6.31432 14.2552 5.57945 14.5477 4.81675 14.5411C4.05204 14.5344 3.32054 14.2276 2.77979 13.6868C2.23904 13.1459 1.93231 12.4142 1.92566 11.6494C1.91904 10.8865 2.21146 10.1514 2.74011 9.60172L4.92287 7.41846C5.21854 7.12262 5.57437 6.89384 5.96621 6.74763C6.35805 6.60143 6.77674 6.54123 7.19389 6.57111C7.61104 6.601 8.01688 6.72026 8.38389 6.92082C8.75091 7.12138 9.0705 7.39855 9.32101 7.73352C9.56221 8.05605 10.0191 8.12194 10.3416 7.88068C10.6641 7.63942 10.7299 7.18238 10.4887 6.85985C10.113 6.3574 9.63359 5.94165 9.08307 5.64081C8.53255 5.33997 7.92378 5.16107 7.29806 5.11625Z"></path></g></svg></div><div translated class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__size-14--Ume6q ontend-pencraft-Text-module__le-height-20--p0dP8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__weight-normal--s54Wf ontend-pencraft-Text-module__font-text--QmNJR ontend-pencraft-Text-module__lor-sendary--WRADg ontend-pencraft-Text-module__ret--dW0zZ ontend-pencraft-Text-module__body4--Pl3xY">Copy lk</div></button><button tabInx="0" type="button" class="button share-actn"><div class="actn-in"><svg role="img" width="16" height="17" viewBox="0 0 16 17" fill="none" stroke-width="1.8" stroke="#000" xmlns="><g><tle></tle><path d="M10.6543 1.38723C10.3533 0.960814 9.95383 0.61341 9.48976 0.374567C9.02902 0.137956 8.51908 0.0130716 8.00115 0.0100098C7.86087 0.0101844 7.72354 0.0502687 7.60519 0.125581C7.48684 0.200893 7.39237 0.308324 7.3328 0.435326L5.00368 5.67077H3.029C2.72335 5.66964 2.42059 5.73003 2.13876 5.84833C1.85692 5.96663 1.60177 6.14043 1.38849 6.35938C1.16707 6.57502 0.991841 6.83346 0.873459 7.11897C0.755078 7.40447 0.696022 7.71108 0.699885 8.02014V13.691C0.699885 14.3087 0.945273 14.9012 1.38207 15.338C1.81886 15.7747 2.41128 16.0201 3.029 16.0201H13.348C13.8951 16.021 14.425 15.8283 14.8438 15.4762C15.2626 15.1241 15.5434 14.6352 15.6366 14.0961L16.6493 8.4252C16.7252 8.09192 16.7252 7.74582 16.6493 7.41254C16.566 7.08205 16.4104 6.7742 16.1936 6.51128C15.9746 6.25 15.7017 6.03926 15.3936 5.89355C15.0762 5.7467 14.7306 5.67068 14.3809 5.67077H10.5328L11.0391 4.37457C11.2397 3.88784 11.3162 3.35894 11.2619 2.83533C11.1853 2.30894 10.9763 1.81065 10.6543 1.38723ZM4.75052 14.5518H3.029C2.91049 14.5525 2.79303 14.5296 2.68349 14.4844C2.57394 14.4392 2.47452 14.3726 2.39102 14.2885C2.23609 14.1199 2.14945 13.8997 2.14799 13.6708V8.02014C2.14913 7.901 2.17389 7.78328 2.22082 7.67377C2.26775 7.56427 2.33592 7.46515 2.4214 7.38216C2.50369 7.29576 2.60267 7.22698 2.71233 7.17998C2.822 7.13298 2.94007 7.10874 3.05938 7.10874H4.7809L4.75052 14.5518ZM10.6746 7.05811H14.3809C14.5145 7.05821 14.6462 7.08942 14.7657 7.14925C14.8875 7.20532 14.9948 7.28845 15.0796 7.39229C15.1675 7.49052 15.2301 7.60871 15.2619 7.73659C15.2922 7.8665 15.2922 8.00162 15.2619 8.13153L14.2493 13.8024C14.2087 14.017 14.094 14.2106 13.9252 14.3492C13.7619 14.4812 13.558 14.5528 13.348 14.5518H6.19862V6.45052L8.43659 1.38723H8.52773C8.9042 1.50037 9.23304 1.73413 9.4636 2.05252C9.69416 2.37092 9.81365 2.75627 9.80368 3.14925C9.8181 3.39741 9.78015 3.64583 9.69229 3.87836L9.23659 5.04292C9.15397 5.273 9.12623 5.51921 9.15558 5.76191C9.1877 6.00427 9.27425 6.23623 9.40875 6.44039C9.5535 6.6376 9.74028 6.80017 9.95558 6.91634C10.1774 7.03206 10.4244 7.0912 10.6746 7.08849V7.05811Z"></path></g></svg></div><div translated class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__size-14--Ume6q ontend-pencraft-Text-module__le-height-20--p0dP8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__weight-normal--s54Wf ontend-pencraft-Text-module__font-text--QmNJR ontend-pencraft-Text-module__lor-sendary--WRADg ontend-pencraft-Text-module__ret--dW0zZ ontend-pencraft-Text-module__body4--Pl3xY">Facebook</div></button><button tabInx="0" type="button" class="button share-actn"><div class="actn-in"><svg role="img" width="21" height="16" viewBox="0 0 21 16" fill="none" stroke-width="1.8" stroke="#000" xmlns="><g><tle></tle><path fill-le="evenodd" clip-le="evenodd" d="M2.22192 2.20503C2.36754 1.77115 2.78269 1.45455 3.26639 1.45455H17.9332C18.4169 1.45455 18.8321 1.77118 18.9777 2.2051L10.5999 8.02107L2.22192 2.20503ZM2.16639 3.94198V13.4545C2.16639 14.0529 2.66307 14.5455 3.26639 14.5455H17.9332C18.5365 14.5455 19.0332 14.0529 19.0332 13.4545V3.94206L11.0204 9.50462C10.7679 9.67991 10.4318 9.67991 10.1793 9.50462L2.16639 3.94198ZM20.4999 2.55809V13.4545C20.4999 14.8562 19.3465 16 17.9332 16H3.26639C1.85304 16 0.699707 14.8562 0.699707 13.4545V2.54545C0.699707 1.14379 1.85304 0 3.26639 0H17.9332C19.3407 0 20.4904 1.13441 20.4998 2.52818C20.5 2.53816 20.5001 2.54813 20.4999 2.55809Z"></path></g></svg></div><div translated class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__size-14--Ume6q ontend-pencraft-Text-module__le-height-20--p0dP8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__weight-normal--s54Wf ontend-pencraft-Text-module__font-text--QmNJR ontend-pencraft-Text-module__lor-sendary--WRADg ontend-pencraft-Text-module__ret--dW0zZ ontend-pencraft-Text-module__body4--Pl3xY">Email</div></button><button tabInx="0" type="button" class="button share-actn"><div class="actn-in"><svg role="img" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke-width="1.8" stroke="#000" xmlns="><g><tle></tle><path d="M6.785 1.92766C5.45134 1.57031 4.08049 2.36176 3.72314 3.69543L0.444815 15.9303C0.0874636 17.264 0.878901 18.6348 2.21255 18.9922L5.37495 19.8396V7.66664C5.37495 6.40099 6.40096 5.37498 7.66661 5.37498H19.4723C19.3299 5.30548 19.1788 5.24858 19.0201 5.20604L6.785 1.92766Z" stroke="none"></path><path fill-le="evenodd" clip-le="evenodd" d="M8.44161 7.4C7.86632 7.4 7.39995 7.86637 7.39995 8.44167V22.1081C7.39995 22.6834 7.86631 23.1498 8.4416 23.1498L22.1083 23.15C22.6836 23.15 23.1499 22.6836 23.1499 22.1083V8.44167C23.1499 7.86637 22.6836 7.4 22.1083 7.4H8.44161ZM10.3999 9.65C9.84766 9.65 9.39995 10.0977 9.39995 10.65C9.39995 11.2023 9.84766 11.65 10.3999 11.65H18.3999C18.9522 11.65 19.3999 11.2023 19.3999 10.65C19.3999 10.0977 18.9522 9.65 18.3999 9.65H10.3999ZM10.3999 14.15C9.84766 14.15 9.39995 14.5977 9.39995 15.15C9.39995 15.7023 9.84766 16.15 10.3999 16.15H15.3999C15.9522 16.15 16.3999 15.7023 16.3999 15.15C16.3999 14.5977 15.9522 14.15 15.3999 14.15H10.3999Z" stroke="none"></path></g></svg></div><div class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__size-14--Ume6q ontend-pencraft-Text-module__le-height-20--p0dP8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__weight-normal--s54Wf ontend-pencraft-Text-module__font-text--QmNJR ontend-pencraft-Text-module__lor-sendary--WRADg ontend-pencraft-Text-module__ret--dW0zZ ontend-pencraft-Text-module__body4--Pl3xY">Not</div></button><button tabInx="0" id="trigger54807" aria-expand="false" aria-haspopup="dialog" aria-ntrols="dialog54808" ariaLabel="View more" type="button" class="button share-actn"><div class="actn-in"><svg role="img" width="100" height="100" viewBox="0 0 100 100" fill="none" stroke-width="1.8" stroke="#000" xmlns="><g><tle></tle><circle cx="23" cy="50" r="9"></circle><circle cx="50" cy="50" r="9"></circle><circle cx="77" cy="50" r="9"></circle></g></svg></div><div translated class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__size-14--Ume6q ontend-pencraft-Text-module__le-height-20--p0dP8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__weight-normal--s54Wf ontend-pencraft-Text-module__font-text--QmNJR ontend-pencraft-Text-module__lor-sendary--WRADg ontend-pencraft-Text-module__ret--dW0zZ ontend-pencraft-Text-module__body4--Pl3xY">Other</div></button></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div><a role="button" href="javascript:void(0)" class="post-ufi-button style-button no-label wh-borr"><svg xmlns=" width="24" height="20" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="2" stroke-lep="round" stroke-lejo="round" class="in"><path d="M4 12v8a2 2 0 0 0 2 2h12a2 2 0 0 0 2-2v-8"></path><polyle pots="16 6 12 2 8 6"></polyle><le x1="12" x2="12" y1="2" y2="15"></le></svg></a></div></div></div><div class="visibily-check"></div><div class="podst-embed tw-select-none tw-ems-center tw-space-y-4 tw-round tw-bg-pub-background tw-p-6 tw-font-sans tw-shadow sm:tw-flex sm:tw-gap-4 sm:tw-space-y-0"><div class="tw-flex tw-ems-center tw-jtify-between tw-gap-4"><div class="tw-w-16 sm:tw-hidn"> </div><div class="tw-flex tw-ems-center tw-jtify-center tw-gap-4"><div role="button" class="tw-cursor-poter"><svg role="img" width="20" height="22" viewBox="0 0 20 22" fill="whe" stroke-width="1.8" stroke="none" xmlns=" class="tw-block tw-fill-pub-primary-text tw-transn-opacy sm:tw-opacy-70 sm:hover:tw-opacy-100"><g><tle></tle><path d="M0 11.8557C0 13.2164 0.260417 14.4989 0.78125 15.7034C1.30208 16.9078 2.02148 17.969 2.93945 18.887C3.85742 19.7984 4.91536 20.5146 6.11328 21.0354C7.31771 21.5562 8.60026 21.8166 9.96094 21.8166C11.3216 21.8166 12.6009 21.5562 13.7988 21.0354C15.0033 20.5146 16.0645 19.7984 16.9824 18.887C17.9004 17.969 18.6198 16.9078 19.1406 15.7034C19.6615 14.4989 19.9219 13.2164 19.9219 11.8557C19.9219 10.6578 19.7168 9.51846 19.3066 8.43773C18.8965 7.357 18.3236 6.38044 17.5879 5.50805C16.8587 4.62914 16.0026 3.89672 15.0195 3.31078C14.043 2.71833 12.985 2.30818 11.8457 2.08031V0.693592C11.8457 0.342029 11.7448 0.12393 11.543 0.039295C11.3411 -0.0453404 11.1068 0.00674294 10.8398 0.195545L7.72461 2.37328C7.49674 2.52953 7.38281 2.71182 7.38281 2.92015C7.38281 3.12849 7.49674 3.31403 7.72461 3.47679L10.8301 5.6643C11.097 5.85961 11.3314 5.91495 11.5332 5.83031C11.7415 5.73916 11.8457 5.51781 11.8457 5.16625V3.77953C12.7702 3.98786 13.6198 4.33943 14.3945 4.83422C15.1758 5.32901 15.8529 5.93448 16.4258 6.65062C17.0052 7.36677 17.4544 8.16755 17.7734 9.05297C18.0924 9.93187 18.252 10.8661 18.252 11.8557C18.252 13.008 18.0371 14.0888 17.6074 15.0979C17.1842 16.1005 16.5918 16.9827 15.8301 17.7444C15.0749 18.4996 14.196 19.0888 13.1934 19.512C12.1908 19.9416 11.1133 20.1565 9.96094 20.1565C8.80859 20.1565 7.72786 19.9416 6.71875 19.512C5.71615 19.0888 4.83398 18.4996 4.07227 17.7444C3.31706 16.9827 2.72461 16.1005 2.29492 15.0979C1.87174 14.0888 1.66016 13.008 1.66016 11.8557C1.66016 10.9312 1.80339 10.0523 2.08984 9.21898C2.3763 8.37914 2.77669 7.61416 3.29102 6.92406C3.80534 6.23396 4.40755 5.64151 5.09766 5.14672C5.29948 4.99698 5.42643 4.81469 5.47852 4.59984C5.53711 4.385 5.50456 4.17666 5.38086 3.97484C5.25716 3.77953 5.07812 3.66234 4.84375 3.62328C4.60938 3.57771 4.38477 3.6363 4.16992 3.79906C3.33008 4.40453 2.59766 5.12719 1.97266 5.96703C1.34766 6.80036 0.86263 7.71833 0.517578 8.72094C0.172526 9.71703 0 10.762 0 11.8557ZM7.10938 15.8596C7.29818 15.8596 7.44792 15.801 7.55859 15.6838C7.66927 15.5601 7.72461 15.3941 7.72461 15.1858V9.02367C7.72461 8.76976 7.66602 8.58096 7.54883 8.45726C7.43164 8.32706 7.26237 8.26195 7.04102 8.26195C6.9043 8.26195 6.77734 8.28799 6.66016 8.34008C6.54297 8.38565 6.39648 8.46703 6.2207 8.58422L4.88281 9.49242C4.77214 9.57055 4.6875 9.65844 4.62891 9.75609C4.57682 9.84724 4.55078 9.94815 4.55078 10.0588C4.55078 10.2216 4.60612 10.3616 4.7168 10.4787C4.82747 10.5959 4.96094 10.6545 5.11719 10.6545C5.21484 10.6545 5.29622 10.6415 5.36133 10.6155C5.42643 10.5894 5.5013 10.5406 5.58594 10.469L6.52344 9.78539H6.50391V15.1858C6.50391 15.3876 6.55924 15.5504 6.66992 15.6741C6.7806 15.7978 6.92708 15.8596 7.10938 15.8596ZM12.0703 15.9768C12.8776 15.9768 13.5254 15.7392 14.0137 15.2639C14.5085 14.7821 14.7559 14.1474 14.7559 13.3596C14.7559 12.6435 14.5378 12.0543 14.1016 11.592C13.6654 11.1298 13.099 10.8987 12.4023 10.8987C12.0898 10.8987 11.7839 10.9703 11.4844 11.1135C11.1914 11.2567 10.9798 11.4521 10.8496 11.6995H10.8984L11.0742 9.49242H13.9941C14.1374 9.49242 14.2611 9.44034 14.3652 9.33617C14.4759 9.232 14.5312 9.09528 14.5312 8.92601C14.5312 8.76325 14.4759 8.63305 14.3652 8.53539C14.2611 8.43122 14.1374 8.37914 13.9941 8.37914H10.8789C10.3646 8.37914 10.0846 8.64932 10.0391 9.18969L9.82422 12.0022C9.80469 12.2431 9.85352 12.4254 9.9707 12.5491C10.0879 12.6662 10.2539 12.7248 10.4688 12.7248C10.625 12.7248 10.752 12.7053 10.8496 12.6662C10.9473 12.6272 11.0645 12.5556 11.2012 12.4514C11.39 12.2821 11.5658 12.1617 11.7285 12.0901C11.8913 12.012 12.0703 11.9729 12.2656 11.9729C12.6432 11.9729 12.9492 12.1031 13.1836 12.3635C13.418 12.6174 13.5352 12.956 13.5352 13.3791C13.5352 13.8088 13.4017 14.1636 13.1348 14.4436C12.8678 14.7235 12.5326 14.8635 12.1289 14.8635C11.8359 14.8635 11.5723 14.7886 11.3379 14.6389C11.1035 14.4827 10.9245 14.2776 10.8008 14.0237C10.7292 13.9 10.6478 13.8056 10.5566 13.7405C10.4655 13.6689 10.3581 13.633 10.2344 13.633C10.0716 13.633 9.93815 13.6851 9.83398 13.7893C9.73633 13.8935 9.6875 14.0302 9.6875 14.1995C9.6875 14.2646 9.69401 14.3297 9.70703 14.3948C9.72005 14.4599 9.73958 14.525 9.76562 14.5901C9.89583 14.9416 10.1628 15.2606 10.5664 15.5471C10.9766 15.8336 11.4779 15.9768 12.0703 15.9768Z"></path></g></svg></div><div role="button" class="tw-relative tw-flex tw-h-16 tw-w-16 tw-cursor-poter tw-ems-center tw-jtify-center tw-round-full tw-bg-pub-accent tw-transn-transform hover:tw-sle-105"><svg role="img" style="height: 24px; width: 22.5px;" width="22.5" height="24" viewBox="0 0 15 16" fill="none" stroke-width="1.8" stroke="none" xmlns=" class="tw-relative tw-left-0.5 tw-fill-pub-accent-verse"><g><tle></tle><path d="M14 7.13397C14.6667 7.51887 14.6667 8.48112 14 8.86602L2 15.7942C1.33333 16.1791 0.499999 15.698 0.499999 14.9282L0.5 1.0718C0.5 0.301996 1.33333 -0.17913 2 0.20577L14 7.13397Z"></path></g></svg></div><div role="button" class="tw-cursor-poter"><svg role="img" width="20" height="22" viewBox="0 0 20 22" fill="whe" stroke-width="1.8" stroke="none" xmlns=" class="tw-block tw-fill-pub-primary-text tw-transn-opacy sm:tw-opacy-70 sm:hover:tw-opacy-100"><g><tle></tle><path d="M13.1738 15.9615C13.7142 15.9615 14.1829 15.802 14.5801 15.483C14.9837 15.1574 15.2962 14.705 15.5176 14.1255C15.7454 13.5461 15.8594 12.8658 15.8594 12.0845C15.8594 11.2968 15.7454 10.6099 15.5176 10.024C15.2962 9.43803 14.9837 8.9823 14.5801 8.65678C14.1829 8.33126 13.7142 8.1685 13.1738 8.1685C12.6335 8.1685 12.1615 8.33126 11.7578 8.65678C11.3542 8.97579 11.0417 9.42827 10.8203 10.0142C10.599 10.6001 10.4883 11.2902 10.4883 12.0845C10.4883 12.8658 10.599 13.5461 10.8203 14.1255C11.0417 14.705 11.3542 15.1574 11.7578 15.483C12.1615 15.802 12.6335 15.9615 13.1738 15.9615ZM6.875 15.9615C7.64323 15.9615 8.27148 15.7531 8.75977 15.3365C9.25456 14.9133 9.50195 14.3729 9.50195 13.7154C9.50195 13.2401 9.35221 12.83 9.05273 12.4849C8.75326 12.1333 8.3724 11.9315 7.91016 11.8794V11.9283C8.28125 11.8632 8.59701 11.6613 8.85742 11.3228C9.12435 10.9843 9.25781 10.5969 9.25781 10.1607C9.25781 9.57475 9.03971 9.09624 8.60352 8.72514C8.17383 8.35405 7.61719 8.1685 6.93359 8.1685C6.34115 8.1685 5.82357 8.3215 5.38086 8.62749C4.93815 8.92697 4.66471 9.31108 4.56055 9.77983C4.54753 9.83842 4.53776 9.89376 4.53125 9.94585C4.52474 9.99793 4.52148 10.05 4.52148 10.1021C4.52148 10.2779 4.57031 10.4211 4.66797 10.5318C4.77214 10.6425 4.90885 10.6978 5.07812 10.6978C5.35156 10.6978 5.54036 10.5448 5.64453 10.2388C5.74219 9.93282 5.89518 9.7017 6.10352 9.54545C6.31185 9.38269 6.57878 9.30131 6.9043 9.30131C7.24935 9.30131 7.52604 9.39572 7.73438 9.58452C7.94922 9.76681 8.05664 10.0077 8.05664 10.3072C8.05664 10.6197 7.94922 10.8801 7.73438 11.0884C7.51953 11.2902 7.23958 11.3912 6.89453 11.3912H6.47461C6.31185 11.3912 6.18164 11.4432 6.08398 11.5474C5.98633 11.6451 5.9375 11.7818 5.9375 11.9576C5.9375 12.1203 5.98633 12.257 6.08398 12.3677C6.18815 12.4719 6.31836 12.524 6.47461 12.524H6.93359C7.35026 12.524 7.67904 12.6281 7.91992 12.8365C8.16081 13.0448 8.28125 13.3215 8.28125 13.6665C8.28125 13.9986 8.14779 14.2785 7.88086 14.5064C7.62044 14.7277 7.28841 14.8384 6.88477 14.8384C6.53971 14.8384 6.25 14.757 6.01562 14.5943C5.78125 14.4315 5.60872 14.1971 5.49805 13.8912C5.43945 13.7284 5.36458 13.6112 5.27344 13.5396C5.18229 13.468 5.07161 13.4322 4.94141 13.4322C4.77865 13.4322 4.64193 13.4875 4.53125 13.5982C4.42708 13.7089 4.375 13.8521 4.375 14.0279C4.375 14.08 4.37826 14.1353 4.38477 14.1939C4.39128 14.246 4.40104 14.2981 4.41406 14.3501C4.51823 14.8059 4.80469 15.19 5.27344 15.5025C5.74219 15.8085 6.27604 15.9615 6.875 15.9615ZM13.1738 14.7798C12.7441 14.7798 12.3991 14.5389 12.1387 14.0572C11.8848 13.5754 11.7578 12.9179 11.7578 12.0845C11.7578 11.2317 11.8848 10.5643 12.1387 10.0826C12.3926 9.59428 12.7376 9.35014 13.1738 9.35014C13.61 9.35014 13.9518 9.59103 14.1992 10.0728C14.4531 10.5546 14.5801 11.2251 14.5801 12.0845C14.5801 12.9179 14.4531 13.5754 14.1992 14.0572C13.9453 14.5389 13.6035 14.7798 13.1738 14.7798ZM9.96094 21.8111C11.3216 21.8111 12.6009 21.5507 13.7988 21.0298C15.0033 20.509 16.0645 19.7928 16.9824 18.8814C17.9004 17.9634 18.6198 16.9022 19.1406 15.6978C19.6615 14.4934 19.9219 13.2108 19.9219 11.8501C19.9219 10.7564 19.7493 9.71147 19.4043 8.71538C19.0592 7.71277 18.5742 6.7948 17.9492 5.96147C17.3242 5.12163 16.5918 4.39897 15.752 3.7935C15.5371 3.63074 15.3125 3.57215 15.0781 3.61772C14.8438 3.65678 14.6647 3.77397 14.541 3.96928C14.4173 4.17111 14.3815 4.37944 14.4336 4.59428C14.4922 4.80913 14.6224 4.99142 14.8242 5.14116C15.5143 5.63595 16.1165 6.2284 16.6309 6.9185C17.1452 7.60861 17.5456 8.37358 17.832 9.21342C18.1185 10.0468 18.2617 10.9257 18.2617 11.8501C18.2617 13.0025 18.0469 14.0832 17.6172 15.0923C17.194 16.0949 16.6016 16.9771 15.8398 17.7388C15.0846 18.494 14.2025 19.0832 13.1934 19.5064C12.1908 19.9361 11.1133 20.1509 9.96094 20.1509C8.80859 20.1509 7.73112 19.9361 6.72852 19.5064C5.72591 19.0832 4.84375 18.494 4.08203 17.7388C3.32682 16.9771 2.73438 16.0949 2.30469 15.0923C1.88151 14.0832 1.66992 13.0025 1.66992 11.8501C1.66992 10.7043 1.88151 9.63009 2.30469 8.62749C2.73438 7.61837 3.32682 6.73621 4.08203 5.981C4.83724 5.21928 5.71615 4.62358 6.71875 4.19389C7.72135 3.7642 8.79883 3.54936 9.95117 3.54936V1.8892C8.59049 1.8892 7.30794 2.14962 6.10352 2.67045C4.9056 3.19129 3.84766 3.91069 2.92969 4.82866C2.01823 5.74663 1.30208 6.80782 0.78125 8.01225C0.260417 9.21017 0 10.4895 0 11.8501C0 13.2108 0.260417 14.4934 0.78125 15.6978C1.30208 16.9022 2.02148 17.9634 2.93945 18.8814C3.85742 19.7928 4.91536 20.509 6.11328 21.0298C7.31771 21.5507 8.60026 21.8111 9.96094 21.8111ZM8.07617 0.697798V5.17045C8.07617 5.51551 8.17708 5.73361 8.37891 5.82475C8.58724 5.90939 8.82487 5.8573 9.0918 5.6685L12.207 3.481C12.4284 3.33126 12.5391 3.15223 12.5391 2.94389C12.5456 2.72905 12.4349 2.5435 12.207 2.38725L9.10156 0.199751C8.82812 0.00443892 8.58724 -0.0476444 8.37891 0.0435014C8.17708 0.128137 8.07617 0.346236 8.07617 0.697798Z"></path></g></svg></div></div><div class="tw-flex tw-w-16 tw-jtify-end sm:tw-w-to"><div class="d-button tw-w-12 tw-cursor-poter tw-round-full tw-borr-0 tw-borr-solid tw-borr-pub-tail-light tw-py-1 tw-text-center tw-font-meta tw-text-sm tw-font-semibold tw-leadg-none tw-text-pub-primary-text hover:tw-borr-pub-tail sm:tw-borr sm:tw-text-pub-sendary-text">1×</div></div></div><div class="tw-flex tw-grow tw-ems-center tw-gap-3 tw-font-meta tw-text-sm tw-text-pub-sendary-text sm:tw-gap-3"><div class="tw-m-w-[40px] tw-text-right">0:00</div><div class="tw-relative tw-h-5 tw-grow "><div class="d-progrs-bar tw-absolute tw-top-2 tw-right-0 tw-left-0 tw-h-1 tw-round tw-bg-pub-tail"></div><div style="width: 0%;" class="tw-absolute tw-top-2 tw-left-0 tw-h-1 tw-round-l-full tw-bg-pub-accent"></div><div style="left: 0%;" class="d-playhead tw-absolute tw-ml-[-10px] tw-h-4 tw-w-4 tw-round-full tw-borr-2 tw-borr-solid tw-borr-pub-background tw-bg-pub-accent"></div></div><div class="tw-m-w-[40px]">-1:25:49</div></div><div class="tw-relative"><div role="button" class="d-button tw-flex tw-cursor-poter tw-ems-center tw-jtify-center tw-gap-3 tw-round tw-borr tw-borr-solid tw-px-5 tw-py-3 tw-text-sm tw-font-semibold tw-text-pub-sendary-text tw-transn-lors sm:tw-py-2 tw-borr-pub-tail-light hover:tw-borr-pub-tail"><span class="sm:tw-hidn">Open player</span><span class="tw-hidn sm:tw-block">Listen on</span><svg role="img" style="height: 4px; width: 6.666666666666667px;" width="6.666666666666667" height="4" viewBox="0 0 10 6" fill="#1C110B" stroke-width="1.8" stroke="#000" xmlns=" class="tw-hidn tw-fill-pub-sendary-text tw-stroke-pub-sendary-text sm:tw-block"><g><tle></tle><path d="M4.61589 5.53907L0.68341 0.820092C0.412024 0.494429 0.643602 0 1.06752 0H8.93248C9.3564 0 9.58798 0.494428 9.31659 0.820091L5.38411 5.53907C5.18421 5.77894 4.81579 5.77894 4.61589 5.53907Z"></path>);</g></svg></div><ul class="dropdown-menu tw-right-0 tw-borr-pub-wash tw-bg-pub-background tw-p-0 tw-font-sans tw-transn sm:tw-max-w-none tooltip no-place"><div class="dropdown-menu-wrapper tw-max-h-[90vh]"><div class="tw-m-w-[280px] tw-px-2 tw-py-2"><div class="tw-borr-0 tw-borr-b tw-borr-solid tw-borr-pub-tail-light tw-pb-2"><div role="button" class="tw-cursor-poter tw-box-borr tw-flex tw-ems-center tw-gap-3 tw-whpace-nowrap tw-round tw-py-3 tw-px-2 tw-text-base tw-font-bold tw-text-pub-primary-text tw-transn-lors hover:tw-bg-pub-wash sm:tw-gap-2 sm:tw-py-2 sm:tw-text-sm sm:tw-font-medium"><div class="tw-flex tw-w-6 tw-jtify-center"><svg role="img" width="16" height="18" viewBox="0 0 16 18" fill="#ff6719" stroke-width="1.8" stroke="none" xmlns="><g><tle></tle><path d="M16 4H0V6H16V4Z"></path><path d="M0 8V18L7.9993 13.534L16 18V8H0Z"></path><path d="M16 0H0V2H16V0Z"></path></g></svg></div><span>Substack App</span></div><div role="button" class="tw-cursor-poter tw-box-borr tw-flex tw-ems-center tw-gap-3 tw-whpace-nowrap tw-round tw-py-3 tw-px-2 tw-text-base tw-font-bold tw-text-pub-primary-text tw-transn-lors hover:tw-bg-pub-wash sm:tw-gap-2 sm:tw-py-2 sm:tw-text-sm sm:tw-font-medium"><div class="tw-flex tw-w-6 tw-jtify-center"><svg xmlns=" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="2" stroke-lep="round" stroke-lejo="round" class="luci luci-download"><path d="M21 15v4a2 2 0 0 1-2 2H5a2 2 0 0 1-2-2v-4"></path><polyle pots="7 10 12 15 17 10"></polyle><le x1="12" x2="12" y1="15" y2="3"></le></svg></div><span>Download MP3</span></div></div><div class="tw-p-2 tw-pt-4 tw-text-sm"><div class="tw-mb-2 tw-font-bold">Get a private RSS lk for listeng</div><div class="tw-mb-6 tw-text-pub-sendary-text">Subscribe to The Dishst wh Andrew Sullivan to get a private lk for listeng your favore podst player. <a href=" target="_blank" rel="noopener" class="tw-text-pub-accent">Learn about RSS.</a></div><button tabInx="0" type="button" class="button primary tw-text-sm tw-font-semibold">Subscribe</button></div></div></div></ul></div></div><d src=">Aud playback is not supported on your browser. Please upgra.</d><div class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__display-flex--ZqeZt ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-directn-lumn--Rq7pk ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-gap-24--bAb43 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__paddg-top-24--hC6Qh"><h4 class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__size-16--fFowu ontend-pencraft-Text-module__le-height-20--p0dP8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__weight-bold--Ps9DB ontend-pencraft-Text-module__font-text--QmNJR ontend-pencraft-Text-module__lor-pub-primary-text--RzL7j ontend-pencraft-Text-module__ret--dW0zZ ontend-pencraft-Text-module__hear4--hH3cg">Appears this episo</h4><div class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__display-flex--ZqeZt ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-directn-lumn--Rq7pk ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-gap-24--bAb43"><div class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__display-flex--ZqeZt ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-directn-row--s2PZ1 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-align-center--rSd6h ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-gap-16--TpblU"><div class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__display-flex--ZqeZt"><div class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flexGrow--mx4xz ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__display-flex--ZqeZt ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-align-center--rSd6h ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-gap-8--HFpIK facepile ontend-podst_post_page-PodstPostHear-module__facepile--_7Aou"><div class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__display-flex--ZqeZt ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-align-center--rSd6h"><div class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__display-flex--ZqeZt ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-align-center--rSd6h ontend-ponents-Facepile-module__fac--FVkdk ontend-ponents-Facepile-module__size-40--pH6IT ontend-podst_post_page-PodstPostHear-module__facepile--_7Aou"><div class="profile-hover-rd-target ontend-rear2-ProfileAndPublitnHoverCard-module__profileHoverCardTarget--Od_YL"><a href=" target="_blank" rel="noopener" class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flexAuto--CnX9I ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__display-flex--ZqeZt"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset=" /><img src=" siz="100vw" alt width="80" class="ontend-ponents-rponsive_img-module__img--Pgjj2 facepile-face ontend-ponents-Facepile-module__face--uAQkp ontend-ponents-Facepile-module__size-40--pH6IT ontend-ponents-Facepile-module__first--TZamh ontend-ponents-Facepile-module__last--DT3p3 ontend-ponents-Facepile-module__elevated--Cn7L9" /></picture></a></div></div></div></div></div><div class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__display-flex--ZqeZt ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-directn-lumn--Rq7pk"><div class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__display-flex--ZqeZt ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-align-center--rSd6h ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-gap-4--zeW5_"><div class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__size-14--Ume6q ontend-pencraft-Text-module__le-height-20--p0dP8 ontend-pencraft-Text-module__weight-bold--Ps9DB ontend-pencraft-Text-module__font-text--QmNJR ontend-pencraft-Text-module__lor-pub-primary-text--RzL7j ontend-pencraft-Text-module__ret--dW0zZ ontend-pencraft-Text-module__body4--Pl3xY">Andrew Sullivan</div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="tw-mt-6 tw-text-center"><div class="podst-scriptn tw-mb-6 tw-font-sans tw-text-base tw-text-pub-sendary-text"><span data-ttid="podst-scriptn" class="podst-scriptn--clamped">Unaaid nversatns about anythg</span></div><div class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__display-flex--ZqeZt ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-jtify-center--SQPji"><div class="le-ee-email-form"><div class="ontend-ponents-ee_email_form-module__ntaer--OfBh4"><form actn="/api/v1/ee?nojs=te" method="post" noValidate class="form ontend-ponents-ee_email_form-module__form--LDIzl"><put type="hidn" name="first_url" /><put type="hidn" name="first_referrer" /><put type="hidn" name="current_url" /><put type="hidn" name="current_referrer" /><put type="hidn" name="referral_" /><put type="hidn" name="source" value="podst_post_hear" /><put type="hidn" name="referrg_pub_id" /><put type="hidn" name="addnal_referrg_pub_ids" /><div class="ontend-ponents-ee_email_form-module__siBySiWrap--yhsgv"><put type="email" name="email" placeholr="Type your email..." class="pencraft ontend-ponents-ee_email_form-module__emailInput--BLQGf" /><button tabInx="0" type="subm" class="button rightButton primary subscribe-btn ontend-ponents-ee_email_form-module__button--WcLG9"><span class="button-text ">Subscribe</span></button></div><div id="error-ntaer"></div><div class="subtle-help-text below-put ontend-ponents-ee_email_form-module__lks--G_QlQ"></div></form><div class="ontend-log-typo_handler-EmailTypoHandler-module__animatnWrapper--UT0du"></div></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="ntaer ntaer--podst-post ntaer--podst-post-wh-ufi"><div class="available-ntent"><div dir="to" class="body markup"><div class="ptned-image-ntaer"><figure><a class="image-lk is-viewable-img image2" target="_blank" href=" data-ponent-name="Image2ToDOM" rel><div class="image2-set"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset=" 424w, 848w, 1272w, 1456w" siz="100vw" /><img src=" width="1033" height="334" data-attrs="{"src":"" class="sizg-normal" alt srcset=" 424w, 848w, 1272w, 1456w" siz="100vw" fetchprry="high" /></picture><div class="image-lk-expand"><svg xmlns=" width="16" height="16" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="#FFFFFF" stroke-width="2" stroke-lep="round" stroke-lejo="round" class="luci luci-maximize2"><polyle pots="15 3 21 3 21 9"></polyle><polyle pots="9 21 3 21 3 15"></polyle><le x1="21" x2="14" y1="3" y2="10"></le><le x1="3" x2="10" y1="21" y2="14"></le></svg></div></div></a></figure></div><p>Fraser is a Sttish Catholic highlanr who now eds (brilliantly) the Spectator London. Deeply versed Tory polics, and sympathetic to Boris, he seemed the ial person to ask to expla what’s been gog on Wtmster, what went so wrong unr PM Johnson, and who is likely to replace him. It’s a one-stop gui to ntemporary Brish polics a d Sttish accent.</p><p><span>You n listen to the episo right away the d player above (or on the right si of the player, click “Listen On” to add the Dishst feed to your favore podst app). For two clips of our nvo — on how Rishi Sunak and Liz Tss pare to one another, and what Fraser lls the “absolutely electrifyg” effect of Kemi Banoch — pop over to </span><a href=" rel>our YouTube page</a><span>.</span></p><p><span>A good plement to this episo is the one I had last year wh Domic Cummgs, the brilliant strategist behd Brex and the rise of Boris. </span><a href=" rel>Here’s the transcript</a><span>. Here’s a clip about Domic’s break om Boris:</span></p><div id="youtube2-GFTMM_M9wYg" class="youtube-wrap" data-attrs="{"vioId":"GFTMM_M9wYg","startTime":null,"endTime":null}" data-ponent-name="Youtube2ToDOM"><div class="youtube-ner"><iame src=" ameborr="0" loadg="lazy" gture="media" allow="toplay; fullscreen" allowtoplay="te" allowfullscreen="te" width="728" height="409"></iame></div></div><p><span>To ntue the bate over </span><a href=" rel>my recent lumn on Tmp and Boris</a><span>, a rear wr:</span></p><blockquote><p>Here’s a dissent: You are right about Tmp. You are wrong about Johnson.</p><p>Lyg naturally to Johnson. It’s not jt to get out of trouble. He li about everythg. Max Hastgs knew this and prciently forest would all blow up.  It has.</p><p>Let’s turn to Brex. First take the term “el.” This glib, trash term is ovesed, over-hackneyed and should have no place your lexin. Unls very refully fed, is pletely meangls. I know as many lawyers and cy typ who voted for Brex as did Rema, and likewise for garners, rpenters, plumbers etc. The Brish public was nned, lied to and persuad there was a problem of the EU’s dog. </p><p>To be fair, there were problems, some of which n be laid at the EU’s door, but for too many years, blame flectn was the name of the game. Most of the problems the untry faced were homegrown. Now look at what has happened: we have a stutterg enomy, low growth and haven’t yet troduced the checks at our borrs we are supposed to, as will e even more chaos — Jab Re-Mogg has admted as much. That’s what happens when you erect major tra barriers wh your neighbours and largt market. We n bate immigratn as much as you like, but the problem has got worse, and as you rrectly poted out, the numbers have creased.</p><p>Now let’s look at the so-lled Conservative Party. Unr Johnson, one-natn nservatism died. He killed . It was replaced, liberately, by a populist, divisive style of le, not dissiar to Tmp’s, que happy to bend or break laws and nventns orr to further s agenda. Its leadg persona was Boris Johnson, and to the eternal shame of the Conservative Party, prec few murred. </p><p>The problems the untry now face stem directly om Brex: a plethora of unfulfillable promis built on li. There are still many who thk Brex was a good thg, but there is a growg and signifint majory that now regnis isn’t workg and was a mistake. It’s happened, and Keir Starmer is right to say that the next step should be to improve relatns wh the EU and to see what n be ma to work, startg wh the Northern Ireland Protol (puttg a borr down the Irish Sea was, you’ll remember, a promise Johnson swore he would never do.  And then promptly did “to get Brex done”). All the ce volved driv me mad, but the Labour Party, by electg a no-hoper and no-braer Jeremy Corbyn, ma wng a majory evable (and remember FPTP didn’t require a signifintly higher number of vot to achieve this).</p><p>It might be too early to wre off the Conservative Party, much as I would like to, spe havg voted for them most of my adult life. But they are tated, out of ias, and spe the diversy you appld, not imprsive. I fear the next few months may prove as entertag as the last few years.</p><p>One aspect that you haven’t touched on is the role of the media. It is staggerg to see the gree of partisanship on display. The Telegraph, Mail and Exprs appear to be livg an alternative universe where tth and fantasy mgle whout differentiatn. And why did the Tim, which I read along wh the Guardian, pull the blow-job report? This, along wh the Londongrad money saga, is for another day.  </p><p>By the way, I am pleased you quoted Mara Hy. Her sasss, razor-sharp tellect and acerbic w are spot-on.</p></blockquote><p>We will have her on the Dishst soon enough. Here’s a rear London:</p><blockquote><p>Sure, there was mountg tratn about Boris Johnson’s lyg — not jt the lyg, but the fact that he variably had to follow wh “oh y, e to thk of …” But voters, as opposed to MPs, thk policians lie all the time anyway, so I don’t thk the cut-through is as great as might be supposed. </p><p>I thk the great pot lost all this is that Boris got his landsli bee of Brex and the creasg tratn wh his abily to grasp the potential benefs beme a hugely creasg sore, exacerbated by the daily shots of illegal immigrants turng up on our shor bber dghi, often helped by the lifeboat service. This and his abily to grasp until too late how badly the enomy was gog to h Mr & Mrs Average was what st him public support as much as, if not more so, than his enomy of tth. </p><p>Another pot not ma enough is that Boris seemed to be a prisoner of foc groups and vol groups of MPs, which meant he was nstantly veerg om one view to another. He ma a strg of supposedly excg announcements that remaed jt that, never gettg anywhere. You n only do that for so long before the public wis up.</p><p>Y, was the MPs who knifed him, but the were MPs gettg the neck om their nstuents for what was (or more often was not) gog on. My neighbour tore up his Tory membership rd sheer tratn and told our MP about . </p><p>Boris uld offer no clear guidg prcipl we uld clg to that would help bat asi the machatns of Cummgs, the BBC et al, who were maniftly on a missn to fentrate him. In the end, even those who fear for Brex the wake of his parture uld see there was no other urse.</p></blockquote><p><span>Lookg back to </span><a href=" rel>last week’s episo wh Peter Staley</a><span>, here’s a key moment where he lls the feral petence over monkeypox “Covid 2.0”:</span></p><div id="youtube2-MrcKXYtTAuI" class="youtube-wrap" data-attrs="{"vioId":"MrcKXYtTAuI","startTime":null,"endTime":null}" data-ponent-name="Youtube2ToDOM"><div class="youtube-ner"><iame src=" ameborr="0" loadg="lazy" gture="media" allow="toplay; fullscreen" allowtoplay="te" allowfullscreen="te" width="728" height="409"></iame></div></div><p><span>The whole 20-mute segment on monkeypox is </span><a href=" rel>here</a><span>. Another listener “enjoyed the episo”:</span></p><blockquote><p>I share Mr. Staley’s ncerns about the ernment’s handlg of the monkeypox outbreak. I agree wh him that the US did a disturbgly poor job of handlg the Covid panmic at the start. However, I have two important qualifiers:</p><ol><li><p>The US was hardly the primary “bad actor” Covid; stupidy and misnduct other untri was more flagrant and more nsequential.</p></li><li><p>I don’t know the tails of the burecratic manglg of the monkeypox vacce, but everythg Staley reports sounds sadly accurate. However, seems to me that the re problem early the AIDS panmic, and the past two months wh monkeypox, was the unwillgns of many the gay muny to modify their behavr nsistent wh obv public health ncerns. I was stck that neher you nor Staley mentn this, beyond your effort to provi some ratnal current health advice, which is however strongly tilted toward vaccatn over behavr modifitn.</p></li></ol></blockquote><p>We did urge gay men to “ol ” for a while. Maybe we should have been more adamant. It’s also beg clearer how this versn of monkeypox is spread: primarily through sexual ntact. If mere sk-touchg were spreadg , then seems to me the epimic would be much, much larger, given the crowds durg Pri. That means, of urse, that we have the abily to help stop , by not havg sex until vaccated. That’s not sex-phobic or homophobic. It’s jt sensible health advice.</p><p>Another dissenter expands on the rear’s send pot:</p><blockquote><p>Your discsn of monkeypox really bugged me, for a reason I hope you take to heart. The vast majory of was foced on the failur of the FDA and CDC, which I don’t take issue wh. But the assumptns of the world you live , particularly when Provcetown, were alarmgly siar to the assumptns you make (rightfully) about the progrsive left — that tak for granted people not havg agency their own liv.</p><p>The US ernment has (probably) failed wh monkeypox, as has wh other diseas. Given that, what should people do? You and Staley both took for granted that you seemed to have a right — almost an obligatn — to party hard P-Town, which the ernment’s failure was terferg wh. It wasn’t until more than halfway through this part of the nversatn that Staley and then you mentned offhand that “some” people were suggtg people “ol ” for a month or so.</p><p>But listen aga to the rt of your nversatn about monkeypox. Time and aga, you blamed the ernment for s failur and never said anythg about maybe the party boys uld do somethg bis bemoan the abily to get vaccated — maybe party ls or (trigger warng) not go to Provcetown one summer. Self-rtrat the face of a still small but loomg epimic was only on the margs of your assumptns.</p><p>At this early stage, rtrat now among the mostly gay-male monkeypox sprears would have exponential benefs gog forward. Isn’t that a msage about social good that is worth the tellg?</p><p>I’m olr and was never much of a partier, so I gus ’s easier for me to say this. But the pretty nfed groups of A-Gays ought to take some agency their own liv at this cril time, and maybe give somethg up temporarily for the benef of both themselv and a very real group of future A-Gays and B-Gays and whatever letter the rt of get. Not to mentn heterosexuals.</p></blockquote><p>As you n see, I take your pot. Another listener mov to a different part of the discsn:</p><blockquote><p>Your terview wh Peter Staley was fairly tertg regardg his participatn durg the cril years of AIDS. But the nversatn beme electric when the subject turned to cril queer theory, the doctratn of children, and the discsn of sex inty prchool. You kept askg Staley if he thought was ok to teach children this curriculum and he kept nervoly lghg and avoidg to answer and said that you’re nfed and bangg your ltle dm. </p><p>I agree wh you: cril theory has hijacked the gay muny, gay rights, etc. and there very well uld be an anti-gay backlash. Please ntue to voice your si and fight for mon sense. Your observatns of cril theory’s dangero impact are not anecdotal — they’re unfortunately everywhere.</p></blockquote><p>To ci for yourself, here’s a clip of that heated exchange:</p><div id="youtube2-FhGPiPPHWeM" class="youtube-wrap" data-attrs="{"vioId":"FhGPiPPHWeM","startTime":null,"endTime":null}" data-ponent-name="Youtube2ToDOM"><div class="youtube-ner"><iame src=" ameborr="0" loadg="lazy" gture="media" allow="toplay; fullscreen" allowtoplay="te" allowfullscreen="te" width="728" height="409"></iame></div></div><p>From a listener San Francis:</p><blockquote><p>I had never heard of Peter Staley before (I’m a 49-year-old gay man SF). ACT-UP and Queer Natn had already fallen apart when I land there 1993 as a young punk rock guy. So I was terted hearg his retellg of that perd the late ‘80s. But then the nvo moved to gay activism today — and wow. I thought, “Well this is . This is the nial that so many gay men have about the genr iology cult.” They are fuckg terrified of speakg out agast this. And of urse ’s bee they know would mean expulsn om pole Democrat society.</p><p>I was recently discsg the mass ln perd we’re livg through around Genr ID extremism. Someone said we should get ready for a massive gaslightg om people who will tell that they never believed this cult.</p></blockquote><p>For what ’s worth, I keep hearg om gay men Provcetown how alienated they are om this iology, but also how sred they are to voice their ncerns — pecially about what this doctratn is dog to gay children. Peter is emblematic of the majory, however, who prefer dismissg the ncerns as overblown, and stickg to their own polil tribe, which they have now ternalized as “LGBTQIA+”. It’s madng, but a functn of real homophob latchg onto the “groomer” disurse, and tribal gays closg ranks opposn. </p><p>The real trouble is that the non-prof stutns allegedly reprentg are packed wh cril theory zealots who experience no phback, and if they do, purge the dissenters. My view is that gay men should stop fundg groups that are dited to the aboln of homosexualy. </p><p>From a parent:</p><blockquote><p>It was so hard for me to listen to Peter Staley downplay the genr stuff for kids. My five-year-old stayed up an hour past her bedtime last night bee she was worried she uld sudnly bee male, or that my breasts might disappear. She is extremely nfed. At a time her life when she is only begng to unrstand what will mean for her to grow up and bee a physil woman, she thks her “pronouns” might sudnly change and she might bee genrls. Teenaged mp unselors wh clear and obv feme featur are tellg her that they are neher male nor female. </p><p>The worst part of that, is that my dghter is begng to believe that her sex is termed by her terts and behavr. For example, she thks that if I swear too much, I may bee male. The rult is her belief that womanhood is some sort of rtoonish stereotype of old-fashned genr rol. </p><p>It’s all so regrsive. As a lifelong liberal, I am repulsed by the mastream ph to rerce genr stereotyp and sentialism. What might be an even bigger crime for a wrer like myself is that my dghter — who hasn’t even started krgarten yet — thks pronouns are a personal tra, not a part of speech. As horrified as I am at the regrsive and sexist genr rol beg phed on my child, I am equally grimacg at the grammatil nfn this creatg. Can’t the school teach my kid what a pronoun even is before scramblg her bra? </p></blockquote><p>Happy to air your personal experience. It’s horrifyg. Another worried parent:</p><blockquote><p>I jt had the most trigug nversatn wh my 17-year-old dghter. She said that if she ever had a child who was trans, she would totally support that. Cur, I asked why. She said, “Bee ’s all about who you love, and ’s ok to love different people.”</p><p>I said, “Hold up, you’re talkg about beg gay. Trans don’t have anythg do wh who you love.”</p><p>She sisted that did. </p><p>I said aga, “No, you’re talkg about beg gay.” </p><p>She said, “They're the same thg. Whenever a guy wants to be a girl, ’s bee he wants to be able to date other guys. And when a girl wants to be a guy, ’s so that she n date other girls.”</p><p>I said, “Now you're jt nfirmg — you are lerally talkg about beg gay. There is no nnectn. Sometim a guy transns to beg a woman, but still wants to date women — and will say that he has bee a lbian.”</p><p>She jt didn’t believe me! She shook her head and said somethg like, “It’s all over TikTok, and 99 percent of the time, when someone wants to be trans, ’s bee they’re jt tryg to be gay.”</p><p>We changed the subject, but even though this is jt one data pot (my dghter), I do wonr how prevalent her pot of view is among other teenagers who watch TikTok.</p></blockquote><p>God only knows. But the attempt to nflate very different gay, lbian and trans experienc is part of an iologil project, rooted postmornism. It is signed to stroy anyone’s herent unrstandg of stable human nature. </p><p>This next listener is on Staley’s si, not wantg to spegoat queer theorists:</p><blockquote><p><span>I have to agree wh Peter Staley that mass doctratn of cril trans/queer/genr theory school children is not the e of any rise genr nfn and trans inty. Somethg else is gog on. My theory: the blogil anism of </span><em>homo sapiens</em><span> is unrgog evolutnary reproductive change due to mountg environmental strs.</span></p><p><span>Let’s start wh the simple observatn that schools are only one small part of the cultural, polil, environmental, faial and technologil waters children swim . One lson om the story book </span><em>How To Raise A Trans Inclive Child</em><span> is not gog to make much of a sexual inty nt the ocean of rmatn, strs and nfn children are growg up the days.</span></p><p>There are so many other strs that are gog to have far greater blogil impacts. Overpopulatn is of urse the big one that nnot be discsed. There are too many rats the ge. Humans now live on a pla which they are nstantly bathed low dos of dtrial and agricultural chemils of every kd. It is our food, air and water. Developg embryos are all bathed the chemils to some gree.</p><p>Throw all the current enomic and polil chaos. Add the bugaboo of social media and the cultural worship of money and fame. Body modifitn wh tattoos, piercg and plastic surgery is a norm. You n create yourself to be anythg.</p><p>A big change, of urse, is the risg equaly of women. Enomilly, that is gog to give women a better hand to play reproductive choice. Hoe hbands are beg more and more mon. Stereotypil genr expectatns are pretty much kaput. Let’s not fet the #MeToo movement — that certaly threw a wrench to heterosexual relatns.</p><p>So what are the kids supposed to thk about sex and genr? </p><p>The are jt some of the dots that Staley suggted may need a b more nnectg. So ’s a b of a stretch to p any risg genr nfn and dysphoria on doctratn wh cril genr/queer/trans theory school children. That would be about as effective as nversn therapy for gay men. It’s not that simple to nvert.</p></blockquote><p>But ’s very easy to nfe a third-grar. One more rear keeps another bate gog:</p><blockquote><p><span>I wanted to rpond to </span><a href=" rel>your rponse</a><span> to the theory that another rear “wanted to float by you” about the nature/nurture bate over trans inty and sexual orientatn. First, I thk you dismiss this person’s ia a b too readily. The possibily that sexual orientatn isn’t born (even though I agree wh you that ’s voluntary) is actually relevant to this discsn. </span></p><p>Much of the morn trans movement rrectly attempts to hch s claims to the claims ma by the gay rights movement, and “born this way” is no exceptn to this trend. If people are born trans, as this movement claims, then ’s theoretilly possible to intify trans children wh perfect accuracy and medilize them before they go through puberty. But if stead, maturg to a trans adult is a stochastic procs, then ’s impossible to predict perfectly which kids will persist their trans inty after puberty. And such a se, nvcg the public to support youth medil transn is a much harr sell.</p><p><span>Addnally, I disagree wh you on whether trans people choose to be trans. </span><a href=" rel>Dysphoric dividuals like Lren Black</a><span>, who choose to al wh their genr dysphoria whout transng, plite the claim that transng is the only possible oute for someone wh genr dysphoria. I thk there are some people wh dysphoria severe enough that medil transn is the bt choice for them. But the cisn of whether to transn or handle dysphoria other ways is still ultimately a choice.</span></p></blockquote><p><span>As always, send your dissents, as well as other ments and personal stori, to </span><strong></strong><span>.</span></p><p></p></div></div><div class="visibily-check"></div><div class="post-footer"><div class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flexGrow--mx4xz ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__display-flex--ZqeZt ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-jtify-space-between--NvIcg ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-align-center--rSd6h ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-gap-16--TpblU ontend-pencraft-Box-module__paddg-y-16--ohCEm ontend-pencraft-Box-module__borr-top-tail-themed--e17yZ ontend-pencraft-Box-module__borr-bottom-tail-themed--eVwFY post-ufi"><div class="pencraft ontend-pencraft-Box-module__ret--VfQY8 ontend-pencraft-Box-module__display-flex--ZqeZt ontend-pencraft-Box-module__flex-gap-8--HFpIK"><div class="like-button-ntaer post-ufi-button style-button"><a role="button" class="post-ufi-button style-button has-label wh-borr"><svg role="img" style="height: 20px; width: 20px;" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="#000000" stroke-width="2" stroke="#000" xmlns=" class="in"><g><tle> .

TOP