Tulsi Gabbard, 2020 Democratic ndidate, apologiz for past anti-gay ments | Fox News

tulsi gabbard gay marriage

22 Dec 2024

Hawaii Democratic Rep. Tulsi Gabbard on Thursday released a lengthy apology for her past activism and ments agast gay marriage, sayg her views have “changed signifintly” sce her outspoken protts of the early 2000s.

TULSI GABBARD ONCE TOUTED WORKG FOR ANTI-GAY GROUP THAT BACKED NVERSN THERAPY

Rep. Tulsi Gabbard the early 2000s touted workg for her father’s anti-gay anizatn, which mobilized to pass a measure agast same-sex marriage Hawaii and promoted ntroversial nversn therapy. * tulsi gabbard gay marriage *

Article ntu below advertisementIn 2022, Gabbard was a featured speaker at the Conservative Polil Actn Conference, and she also has e out favor of Florida's Parental Rights Edutn Act, which is known by s cric as the "Don't Say Gay Law. " The issu are obvly eply divisive, but Gabbard's posn on gay marriage has been fairly longstandg.

A big part of her early strategy: Walkg back earlier opposn to gay nng for the state legislature 2002, Gabbard, then 21, bragged to the Honolulu Star-Bullet about her work to oppose gay marriage. ”Mike Gabbard, a Hawaii state senator, has been a longtime opponent of gay rights.

TULSI GABBARD, 2020 DEMOCRATIC NDIDATE, APOLOGIZ FOR PAST ANTI-GAY MENTS

“My views have changed signifintly sce then,” the Hawaii Democrat add. In the early 2000s, Gabbard touted her work for her father’s anizatn, the Alliance for Tradnal Marriage, when she was nng for a seat the Hawaii state legislature. Gabbard prevly apologized 2012 for her past opposn to gay marriage, but her ments recently surfaced aga, promptg her latt apology. * tulsi gabbard gay marriage *

He led the Alliance for Tradnal Marriage, a polil actn mtee that opposed same-sex marriage, and has lled homosexualy “unhealthy, abnormal behavr that should not be promoted or accepted society. More recently, she backed multiple piec of legislatn to make discrimatg agast gay rights illegal. He was an activist who was fightg agast gay rights and marriage equaly Hawaii — and at that time, I forcefully fend him, ” Gabbard explaed a tweet.

”Not so long ago, Gabbard’s opposn to gay marriage would not have been so unual om a Democratic printial was Bill Clton, after all, who enacted “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell. Print Barack Obama exprsed his support for gay marriage 2012, cg his fah as part of the reason for the swch.

Several red state Democrats who opposed gay marriage 2012 me out favor durg the 2018 midterms.

TULSI GABBARD, DEMOCRATIC PRINTIAL CANDIDATE, APOLOGIZ FOR ANTI-GAY PAST

The Hawaii Democrat and 2020 printial hopeful released a vio on Thursday sayg her “past posns” on gay rights are “at odds” wh her current valu. * tulsi gabbard gay marriage *

And every Democrat currently nng the printial primary has affirmed that they would appot liberal judg and ph anti-gay discrimatn legislatn if elected. “This will be a robt primary wh many champns of equaly the race, " JoDee Wterhof, senr vice print for policy and polil affairs for the Human Rights Campaign, one of the largt gay rights anizatns the untry, told the Fix.

Gabbard takg heat over past anti-gay ments.

GAY LAWMAKER SUMS UP WHAT EVERYONE IS THKG ABOUT TULSI GABBARD JT 6 WORDS

Printial hopeful Democratic Rep. Tulsi Gabbard sought to expla her shift away om advotg anti-gay polici the early 2000s on Sunday, sayg her time the ary ed her to “go through some soul-searchg.” * tulsi gabbard gay marriage *

Tulsi Gabbard the early 2000s touted workg for her father’s anti-gay anizatn, which mobilized to pass a measure agast same-sex marriage Hawaii and promoted ntroversial nversn therapy. Although Gabbard’s posns on LGBT rights have shifted dramatilly more recent years (she signed a 2013 amic brief supportg Edh Wdsor’s challenge to the Defense of Marriage Act), the extent of Gabbard’s past anti-gay activism has already drawn cricism om proment Democrats and will likely be a major issue for her as she seeks the party’s nomatn.

Gabbard’s father ran The Alliance for Tradnal Marriage, a polil actn mtee aimed at opposg pro-gay lawmakers and legislatn that anized and spent more than $100, 000 to pass an amendment 1998 that gave the Hawaii state legislature power to “rerve marriage to oppose-sex upl.

Gabbard’s father Mike was a proment anti-gay activist Hawaii. He was also the director of Stop Promotg Homosexualy and also served on the steerg mte of the Natnal Campaign to Protect Marriage and the Hawaii-based aln, Save Tradnal Marriage.

* tulsi gabbard gay marriage *

He also once hosted an anti-gay rad show, Let’s Talk Straight Hawaii. The Alliance for Tradnal Marriage lled homosexualy “unhealthy, abnormal behavr that should not be promoted or accepted society. A CNN KFile review of the anizatn’s webse, which is archived on the Inter Archive’s Wayback Mache, unvers the anizatn supported ntroversial gay nversn therapy, which treats homosexualy as a mental illns that n be fixed.

“Our w Hawaii, along wh Alaska’s victory, sends a very clear msage to the homosexual movement-we do not want homosexual marriage advot forcg their valu on our muni, ” Tulsi’s father Mike wrote a msage on the webse of the group shortly after the passage of the nstutnal amendment 1998. “While we mt ntue to monor and rpond to homosexual activists whose ultimate goal is societal acceptance of homosexualy on an equal basis as heterosexualy, we mt also renew our efforts to reach out wh love and passn to those who are addicted to homosexual behavr, and enurage them to seek help through the Natnal Associatn of Rearch and Therapy of Homosexualy (NARTH), ‘ex-gay’ mistri such as Exod Internatnal, Courage, Homosexuals Anonymo and Parents and Friends of Ex-Gays (P-FOX). In , she attacks gay rights activists who were opposed to her mother Carol’s bid for the state’s board of tn.

BEAR-MAGAZINE.COM TULSI GABBARD GAY MARRIAGE

Story Saved</tle><path class="in-bookmark-fill in-bookmark--activated-outle" d="M20 24L12.5 19.7804L5 24V3H20V24ZM12.5 18.6028L19 22.2336V3.98131H6V22.2336L12.5 18.6028Z" fill="black"></path><path class="in-bookmark-fill in-bookmark--activated-checkmark" d="M11.5541 13.7033L9 11.2033L9.66216 10.5552L11.5541 12.407L15.3378 8.70331L16 9.35146L11.5541 13.7033Z" fill="black"></path></svg></div><div class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ AlertMsage-jgAjgo bVCFRm ifgabc fksqMR alert-msage"><p>To revis this article, select My Acunt, then <a href="/acunt/saved">View saved stori</a></p></div><button class="BaseButton-bLlsy ButtonWrapper-xCepQ bqVKKv dZjwET button button--utily close-alert-button" data-event-click="{"element":"Button"}" data-ttid="Button" role="button" type="button"><span class="ButtonLabel-cjAuJN bBWXSg button__label">Close Alert</span><div class="ButtonInWrapper-gFdzAL bPDyTT button__in-ntaer"><svg class="ButtonIn-YqaGo iwlhuX button-in in in-close" focable="false" viewBox="0 0 32 32" width="32" height="32" xmlns="><path d="M16 14.586l6.364-6.364 1.414 1.414L17.414 16l6.364 6.364-1.414 1.414L16 17.414l-6.364 6.364-1.414-1.414L14.586 16 8.222 9.636l1.414-1.414z" fill-le="nonzero"></path></svg></div></button></div><a href="/th/iate?redirectURL=%2Fmagaze%2F2017%2F11%2F06%2Fwhat-do-tulsi-gabbard-believe&source=VERSO_NAVIGATION" rel="nofollow" data-ttid="signIn" class="StandardNavigatnAcuntLabel-pyqL jVPHWr">Sign In</a></div><div class="StackedNavigatnConsumerMarketgUnWrapper-epSkjf eqsNVO"><div class="ConsumerMarketgUnThemedWrapper-iUTMTf jssHut nsumer-marketg-un nsumer-marketg-un--nav-cta" role="prentatn" aria-hidn="te"><div class="nsumer-marketg-un__slot nsumer-marketg-un__slot--nav-cta"></div><div class="journey-un"></div></div><div class="ConsumerMarketgUnThemedWrapper-iUTMTf jssHut nsumer-marketg-un nsumer-marketg-un--nav-rollover" role="prentatn"><div class="nsumer-marketg-un__slot nsumer-marketg-un__slot--nav-rollover"></div><div class="journey-un"></div></div><div class="ConsumerMarketgUnThemedWrapper-iUTMTf jssHut nsumer-marketg-un nsumer-marketg-un--nav-dialog" role="prentatn" aria-hidn="te"><div class="nsumer-marketg-un__slot nsumer-marketg-un__slot--nav-dialog"></div><div class="journey-un"></div></div></div><a href="/search" class="BaseButton-bLlsy ButtonWrapper-xCepQ bqVKKv gVJotL button button--utily StackedNavigatnSearch-lFFwq ckLQNp" data-event-click="{"element":"Button","outgogURL":"/search"}" data-ttid="Button" type=""><span class="ButtonLabel-cjAuJN bBWXSg button__label">Search</span><div class="ButtonInWrapper-gFdzAL bPDyTT button__in-ntaer"><svg class="ButtonIn-YqaGo iwlhuX button-in in in-search" focable="false" viewBox="0 0 32 32" width="32" height="32" xmlns=" data-ttid="inSearch"><tle>Search</tle><path d="M14.5 10a4.5 4.5 0 1 0 0 9 4.5 4.5 0 0 0 0-9zm5.249 8.335l4.458 4.458-1.414 1.414-4.458-4.458a6.5 6.5 0 1 1 1.414-1.414z" fill-le="nonzero"></path></svg></div></a></div></div><div data-ttid="StackedNavigatnSectnPrimaryLks" class="StackedNavigatnSectnPrimaryLks-foRfJu jOZVNi"><nav aria-label="Primary" class="NavigatnWrapper-bFftAs fKSZRK StackedNavigatnNavigatnPrimaryLk-hGPvKW junrbk" data-ttid="navigatn"><ul class="NavigatnListWrapper-gWXLVS dnLcIy navigatn__list" data-ttid="navigatn__list"><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD dsgTQs navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/news" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">News</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD dsgTQs navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/culture" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Books & Culture</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD dsgTQs navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/fictn-and-poetry" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Fictn & Poetry</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD dsgTQs navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/humor" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Humor & Cartoons</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD dsgTQs navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/magaze" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Magaze</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD dsgTQs navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/crossword-puzzl-and-gam" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Puzzl & Gam</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD dsgTQs navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href=" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Vio</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD dsgTQs navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/podsts" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Podsts</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD dsgTQs navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/archive" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Archive</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD dsgTQs navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href=" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Ftival</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD dsgTQs navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="external-lk NavigatnExternalLk-hktPkS jLQUSr navigatn__lk" data-event-click="{"element":"ExternalLk","outgogURL":"" href=" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">Shop</a></li></ul></nav><span class="NavigatnDivir-fEDnwq ixXXMs navigatn__divir"></span></div><div class="StackedNavigatnBottom-dpkX bIeNbx"><div class="StackedNavigatnDrawer-jtJcEj edsvEF"><button class="BaseButton-bLlsy ButtonWrapper-xCepQ bqVKKv dZjwET button button--utily StackedNavigatnDrawerToggle-cycUFN eZCXFW" data-event-click="{"element":"Button"}" data-ttid="Button" role="button" type="button"><span class="ButtonLabel-cjAuJN bBWXSg button__label">Open Navigatn Menu</span><div class="ButtonInWrapper-gFdzAL bPDyTT button__in-ntaer"><svg class="ButtonIn-YqaGo iwlhuX button-in in in-menu" focable="false" viewBox="0 0 32 32" width="32" height="32" xmlns="><tle>Menu</tle><path d="M8 10h16v2H8v-2zm0 5h16v2H8v-2zm0 5h16v2H8v-2z" fill-le="evenodd"></path></svg></div></button><div class="AlertWrapper-gvFATk ePjLtR" data-ttid="BookmarkAlertMobile" role="tooltip"><div aria-hidn="te" role="prentatn" class="AlertArrow-daOgye dJBuXq alert-arrow"></div><div aria-hidn="te" role="prentatn" class="AlertInWrapper-iHNVmf iGkvlr"><svg class="in in-bookmark in-bookmark--activated" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" xmlns="><tle>Story Saved</tle><path class="in-bookmark-fill in-bookmark--activated-outle" d="M20 24L12.5 19.7804L5 24V3H20V24ZM12.5 18.6028L19 22.2336V3.98131H6V22.2336L12.5 18.6028Z" fill="black"></path><path class="in-bookmark-fill in-bookmark--activated-checkmark" d="M11.5541 13.7033L9 11.2033L9.66216 10.5552L11.5541 12.407L15.3378 8.70331L16 9.35146L11.5541 13.7033Z" fill="black"></path></svg></div><div class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ AlertMsage-jgAjgo bVCFRm ifgabc fksqMR alert-msage"><p>To revis this article, vis My Profile, then <a href="/acunt/saved">View saved stori</a></p></div><button class="BaseButton-bLlsy ButtonWrapper-xCepQ bqVKKv dZjwET button button--utily close-alert-button" data-event-click="{"element":"Button"}" data-ttid="Button" role="button" type="button"><span class="ButtonLabel-cjAuJN bBWXSg button__label">Close Alert</span><div class="ButtonInWrapper-gFdzAL bPDyTT button__in-ntaer"><svg class="ButtonIn-YqaGo iwlhuX button-in in in-close" focable="false" viewBox="0 0 32 32" width="32" height="32" xmlns="><path d="M16 14.586l6.364-6.364 1.414 1.414L17.414 16l6.364 6.364-1.414 1.414L16 17.414l-6.364 6.364-1.414-1.414L14.586 16 8.222 9.636l1.414-1.414z" fill-le="nonzero"></path></svg></div></button></div></div><div class="StackedNavigatnSectnLogo-gMsxSu kUeORh"><a href="/" class="StackedNavigatnLogoLk-byNqXP dmvHfj"><picture class="RponsiveImagePicture-cWuUZO dUOtEa rponsive-image"><img alt="The New Yorker" class="RponsiveImageContaer-eybHBd fptoWY rponsive-image__image" src="/verso/static/the-new-yorker/assets/" srcSet="" siz="100vw"/></picture></a></div><div class="StackedNavigatnSectnMobileOptn-iaaAJG bHHPuB"><div class="ConsumerMarketgUnThemedWrapper-iUTMTf jssHut nsumer-marketg-un nsumer-marketg-un--mob-nav-cta" role="prentatn" aria-hidn="te"><div class="nsumer-marketg-un__slot nsumer-marketg-un__slot--mob-nav-cta"></div><div class="journey-un"></div></div></div></div></div></hear></div><div class="PersistentBottomWrapper-eddooY bIieWF persistent-bottom" data-journey-hook="persistent-bottom"><asi class="PaywallBarWrapper-hbEokK kqItQt paywall-bar"><div class="ConsumerMarketgUnThemedWrapper-iUTMTf jssHut paywall-bar__nsumer-marketg-un nsumer-marketg-un nsumer-marketg-un--paywall-bar-ll-to-actn" role="prentatn" aria-live="pole" aria-hidn="te"><div class="nsumer-marketg-un__slot nsumer-marketg-un__slot--paywall-bar-ll-to-actn"></div><div class="journey-un"></div></div></asi></div><ma id="ma-ntent" tabx="-1" class="BasePageMaContent-kFvAuh ewPCZH page__ma-ntent"><article class="article ma-ntent" lang="en-US"><div class="ArticlePageLeBackground-EufvU tFsh"><hear class="ContentHearWrapper-clujbs ugnAo ntent-hear article__ntent-hear"><div data-ttid="ContentHearContaer" class="ContentHearContaer-cGKRbE knDxNq"><div class="ContentHearHedAccredatnWrapper-GFiQf cDNVlV"><div data-ttid="ContentHearTleBlockWrapper" class="ContentHearTleBlockWrapper-cjmSKp jbzVNV"><div data-ttid="ContentHearRubric" class="ContentHearRubricBlock-LmpbT kkDiIx"><div data-ttid="ContentHearRubricDateBlock" class="ContentHearRubricDateBlock-kAQcZP fTFWxD"><div class="RubricWrapper-dKmCNX dZhWBL bric ContentHearRubricContaer-eTudtt iRsSlw"><a class="RubricLk-gRWSOU fgWnkQ bric__lk" href="/magaze/profil"><span class="RubricName-fVtemz cLxcNi">Profil</span></a></div></div></div><h1 data-ttid="ContentHearHed" class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ ContentHearHed-NCyCC iUEiRd NbxED hpJvIc">What Do Tulsi Gabbard Believe?</h1></div><div class="ContentHearAccredatn-lfctVB etVsnJ ntent-hear__accredatn" data-ttid="ContentHearAccredatn"><div class="ContentHearDek-bIqFFZ Mtme">The makg of a charismatic, unorthodox Democrat.</div><div class="ContentHearByle-kmPyCa gvUmxJ"><div class="ContentHearByleContent-dpPmNn DRFq"><div data-ttid="BylWrapper" class="BylWrapper-KIudk irTIfE byl ContentHearByl-cZqgyJ bHLeKI"><p class="ByleWrapper-jWHrLH ivtvgj byle byl__byle" data-ttid="ByleWrapper" emProp="thor" emType="><span emProp="name" class="ByleNamWrapper-jbHncj fuDQVo"><span data-ttid="ByleName" class="ByleName-kwmrLn cYaBaU byle__name"><span class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ BylePreamble-iJolpQ iUEiRd jslZfG gnILss byle__preamble">By </span><a class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ BaseLk-eNWuiM ByleLk-gEnFiw iUEiRd ggMZaT cXqSTL eErqIx byle__name-lk button" href="/ntributors/kelefa-sanneh">Kelefa Sanneh</a></span></span></p></div><time data-ttid="ContentHearPublishDate" dateTime="2017-10-30T05:00:00-04:00" class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ ContentHearPublishDate-eIBicG iUEiRd kYZrFA iINaCX">October 30, 2017</time></div></div></div></div><div class="ContentHearLeadAsset-hGbumP fEknXh lead-asset ContentHearLeadAssetWrapper-hfXHEc Grck lead-asset--width-fullbleed" data-ttid="ContentHearLeadAsset"><figure class="ContentHearLeadAssetContent-kOfYSG dRGWbI"><div class="ContentHearLeadAssetContentMedia-bLEIpi jjhWdS lead-asset__ntent__photo"><span class="SpanWrapper-umhxW jvZaPI rponsive-asset ContentHearRponsiveAsset-bREgIb hONbnm"><div data-tt="aspect-rat-ntaer" class="AspectRatContaer-bJHpJz dwNtZQ"><div class="aspect-rat--overlay-ntaer"><picture class="RponsiveImagePicture-cWuUZO dUOtEa ContentHearRponsiveAsset-bREgIb hONbnm rponsive-image"><source media="(max-width: 767px)" srcSet=" 120w, 240w, 320w, 640w, 960w" siz="100vw"/><source media="(m-width: 768px)" srcSet=" 120w, 240w, 320w, 640w, 960w, 1280w, 1600w, 1920w, 2240w" siz="100vw"/><img alt="Woman on a surfboard on the water" class="RponsiveImageContaer-eybHBd fptoWY rponsive-image__image" src="></picture></div></div></span></div></figure></div><div class="ContentHearLeadContentFullWidth-cvJzX hHaBOT"><figure class="ContentHearLeadContentCaptnCred-hSIIqJ kQVfzg"><div class="CaptnWrapper-jSZdqE iTuhkZ ptn ContentHearLeadAssetCaptn-hPWmSN kuCzGS"><span class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ CaptnText-bHjzlu iUEiRd hWyo iXWezO ptn__text">An Iraq veteran and the first Hdu Congrs, Gabbard is a pellg figure. When she was elected, Rachel Maddow said, “She is on the fast track to beg very famo.”</span><span class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ CaptnCred-ejegDm iUEiRd iicloT jbIJNS ptn__cred">Photograph by Peter Bohler for The New Yorker</span></div></figure></div></div></hear></div><div data-attribute-verso-pattern="article-body" class="ArticlePageContentBackGround-cNiFNN kbAoLA article-body__ntent"><div class="ActnBarWrapperContent-lasBkU cAHp"><div class="ActnBarWrapperComponent-cjwxLS bEeSLb"><div data-attr-viewport-monor="" class="ActnBarWrapper-dhxmQh kNjTbQ viewport-monor-anchor"><button id="bookmark" aria-label="Save this story" class="ActnBarButton-dyFOZU hQrwCF bookmark large-screen"><span class="ActnBarSendaryButtonPrimaryIn-isbvyN cAwccV bookmark-button-in"><svg class="in in-bookmark" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" xmlns="><tle>Save this story</tle><path class="in-bookmark-fill" d="M20 23.9508L12.5 19.7312L5 23.9508V2.95081H14V3.93211H6V22.1845L12.5 18.5536L19 22.1845V8.83866H20V23.9508Z"></path><path class="in-bookmark-fill" d="M23 3H20V0H19V3H16V4H19V7H20V4H23V3Z"></path></svg></span><span class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ ActnBarButtonText-bYXYuh iUEiRd bkefvo gkccfO">Save this story</span></button></div><div data-attr-viewport-monor="" class="ActnBarWrapper-dhxmQh kAEsuD viewport-monor-anchor"><button id="bookmark" aria-label="Save this story" class="ActnBarButton-dyFOZU cjjxgx bookmark mobile"><span class="ActnBarSendaryButtonPrimaryIn-isbvyN cAwccV bookmark-button-in"><svg class="in in-bookmark" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" xmlns="><tle>Save this story</tle><path class="in-bookmark-fill" d="M20 23.9508L12.5 19.7312L5 23.9508V2.95081H14V3.93211H6V22.1845L12.5 18.5536L19 22.1845V8.83866H20V23.9508Z"></path><path class="in-bookmark-fill" d="M23 3H20V0H19V3H16V4H19V7H20V4H23V3Z"></path></svg></span><span class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ ActnBarButtonText-bYXYuh iUEiRd bkefvo gkccfO">Save this story</span></button></div></div></div><div class="LightboxWrapper-dxsWBV hhylRt"><div class="ArticlePageChunksContent-etcMtP bwyLBj"><div data-ttid="ArticlePageChunks" class="ArticlePageChunks-fLyCVG Uozmo"><div class="GridWrapper-cAzTTK kHBDeH grid grid-margs grid-ems-2 ArticlePageChunksGrid-hfxa bjczjj grid-layout--adrail narrow wi-adrail"><div class="GridItem-buujkM stRKV grid--em grid-layout__ntent"><div class="BodyWrapper-kufPGa EOneK body body__ntaer article__body" data-journey-hook="client-ntent" data-ttid="BodyWrapper"><div class="body__ner-ntaer"><p class="has-dropp has-dropp__lead-standard-headg">When Tulsi Gabbard arrived at Lihue Airport, on the Hawaiian island of Kai, she was greeted wh a lei ma of vibrant plumeria flowers, a small bottle of nut water, a bagful of mango, and a profn of alerts on her phone. It was Memorial Day, and Gabbard had agreed to speak at a ceremony honorg veterans at a lol ary cemetery. Many of the people there would be her brothers and sisters arms: Gabbard has served, sce 2003, the Army Natnal Guard, which pacy she pleted a tour of duty Iraq. And almost all the people there would be her nstuents— 2012, Gabbard was elected to the Uned Stat Congrs, reprentg Hawaii’s Send District, which clus all of the Hawaiian archipelago outsi Honolulu, the pal. Gabbard found her lol field reprentative, Klana Fn, gave her a hug, and climbed to her r. “As soon as I land here, I get text msag om people sayg, ‘I heard you’re on Kai—what are you dog?’ ” Gabbard said, grng. “I don’t thk ’s possible to do anythg here whout everybody knowg about .”</p><p class="paywall">All policians mt act as if they enjoy patrtic ceremoni, but Gabbard is one of the few who seem as if they were not actg. She is thirty-six, and has a knack for projectg both youthful joy and grownup gravas. Her polil profile is siarly hybrid. She is a fervent Bernie Sanrs supporter wh equally fervent bipartisan tennci—known, roughly equally, for her ncern for the treatment of veterans and her opposn to U.S. terventn abroad. She is also a vegetarian and a practicg Hdu—the first Hdu ever elected to Congrs—as well as a lifelong surfer and an acplished athlete. On Capol Hill, she is often regard as a glamoro anomaly: a Hawaiian actn figure, fabuloly out of place among her bued lleagu. “She’s almost straight om central stg, if you need a heroe,” Van Jon, the progrsive activist, says. Trey Gowdy, the South Carola Republin, is one of her clost iends Congrs. He first spied her on the Hoe floor, stg on the Republin si of the aisle. “This sounds terrible to say, but ’s also te—you know, she’s cute,” he says. “So if you’re stg on that si, and ’s a borg speech, you’re gog to notice.” The night after Gabbard was elected, Rachel Maddow ma a predictn on MSNBC: “She is on the fast track to beg very famo.”</p><p class="paywall">On the way to the ceremony, Fn stopped at her hoe so that Gabbard uld change to her ary uniform, which she had brought along, a dry cleaner’s bag, as rry-on luggage. Fn gave her a motherly appraisal. “Do you have your headpiece?” she asked, then rrected herself. “Pardon me. I don’t know the proper termology for ary gear.”</p><p class="paywall">Gabbard chuckled and offered the right word: “Cover.” She had hers, and soon she was standg at solemn attentn at the Kai Veterans Cemetery, where the grav were sprigged wh Amerin flags and a lol Junr R.O.T.C. troop was lg the entrance. It was a hot but breezy day, wh birds chirpg and a few wild chickens stttg among the tombston. There was a podium flanked by wreaths ont of a tiled mural pictg a mournful beach scene: a le of battlefield cross, two empty boots, an upright rifle, pastel clouds the distance.</p><p class="paywall">Gabbard began wh a personal tribute to those whose service had st them their liv. “Like so many of you, I woke up this morng wh a heavy heart,” she said. “Rememberg that time trag, or downrange, when thgs were so crappy that all you uld do was lgh, know that we had each other, and embrace the suck. We remember that last roll ll, when their name was lled wh no rponse.” She talked about how she had never seen her father cry until the day she me home, unharmed, om Iraq. Anyone stg close enough might have noticed that her ey were gleamg. But she also sound a note of polil prott. “Too often we have found, throughout our untry’s history, we have people posns of power who make offhand ments about sendg a few thoand troops here, fifty thoand there, a hundred thoand there, terveng arily here, or startg a war there—whout seemg to unrstand or appreciate the st of war,” she said. “If our troops are sent to fight a war, mt be the last optn. Not the first.”</p><figure class="AssetEmbedWrapper-eVDQiB byBkf asset-embed"><div class="AssetEmbedAssetContaer-eJxoAx dBHGoQ asset-embed__asset-ntaer"><span class="SpanWrapper-umhxW kKwZhx rponsive-asset AssetEmbedRponsiveAsset-cXBNxi eCxVQK asset-embed__rponsive-asset"><div data-attr-viewport-monor="" class="RponsiveCartoonWrapper-iTMMjI eXTYsS rponsive-rtoon AssetEmbedRponsiveAsset-cXBNxi eCxVQK asset-embed__rponsive-asset viewport-monor-anchor"><a class="external-lk rponsive-rtoon__image-lk" data-event-click="{"element":"ExternalLk","outgogURL":"" href=" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank"><picture class="RponsiveImagePicture-cWuUZO dUOtEa RponsiveCartoonImage-hzNqyc ikeCcH rponsive-rtoon__image rponsive-image"><noscript><img alt="What Do Tulsi Gabbard Believe" class="RponsiveImageContaer-eybHBd fptoWY rponsive-image__image" src=" srcSet=" 120w, 240w, 320w, 640w, 960w, 1280w, 1600w" siz="100vw"/></noscript></picture></a><div class="RponsiveCartoonCTA-eiqqMB iDCQRs"><div class="RponsiveCartoonCTAWrapper-CYIqa iTbFtf"><div class="RponsiveCartoonLkButtonWrapper-hqDAJK eSEhbj"><button aria-label="Copy lk to rtoon" class="BaseButton-bLlsy ButtonWrapper-xCepQ bqVKKv YsOBB button button--primary-pair RponsiveCartoonInButton-hBCBMq lpsjql" data-event-click="{"element":"Button"}" data-ttid="Button" type="button"><span class="ButtonLabel-cjAuJN bBWXSg button__label">Copy lk to rtoon</span><div class="ButtonInWrapper-gFdzAL bPDyTT button__in-ntaer"><svg class="in in-pylk" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" xmlns="><tle>Copy lk to rtoon</tle><g clip-path="url(#clip0_3732_178637)"><path fill-le="evenodd" clip-le="evenodd" d="M16.3488 10.5017C16.2107 10.7357 16.2926 11.035 16.5318 11.17C16.7709 11.3052 17.0767 11.225 17.2148 10.991L18.4648 8.87225C19.5694 7.00002 18.9139 4.60601 17.0007 3.52508C15.0875 2.44415 12.6412 3.08562 11.5366 4.95785L9.53657 8.34782C8.432 10.22 9.08751 12.6141 11.0007 13.6949C11.1888 13.8012 11.382 13.8908 11.5785 13.9642C11.7819 14.0403 12.0058 13.9485 12.1147 13.764C12.2794 13.4849 12.1103 13.1276 11.8083 12.9992C11.7041 12.9549 11.6014 12.9044 11.5007 12.8475C10.0658 12.0368 9.57417 10.2413 10.4026 8.83712L12.4026 5.44715C13.2311 4.04298 15.0658 3.56187 16.5007 4.37257C17.9356 5.18327 18.4272 6.97878 17.5988 8.38295L16.3488 10.5017ZM7.6526 13.4983C7.79067 13.2643 7.70873 12.965 7.46959 12.8299C7.23044 12.6948 6.92464 12.775 6.78657 13.009L5.53657 15.1278C4.432 17 5.0875 19.394 7.00068 20.475C8.91385 21.5558 11.3602 20.9144 12.4648 19.0422L14.4648 15.6521C15.5694 13.78 14.9139 11.3859 13.0007 10.305C12.8127 10.1988 12.6195 10.1091 12.4229 10.0357C12.2195 9.95975 11.9956 10.0515 11.8867 10.236C11.7221 10.5151 11.8911 10.8724 12.1932 11.0008C12.2973 11.0451 12.4 11.0956 12.5007 11.1525C13.9356 11.9632 14.4272 13.7587 13.5988 15.1628L11.5988 18.5529C10.7704 19.957 8.93555 20.4382 7.50068 19.6274C6.0658 18.8167 5.57417 17.0212 6.4026 15.6171L7.6526 13.4983Z" fill="black"></path></g><fs><clipPath id="clip0_3732_178637"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath><clipPath id="clip1_3732_178637"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath></fs></svg></div></button><div class="AlertWrapper-gvFATk MdjE RponsiveCartoonLkAlertPopup-BPAXn kdMXRM shoppg-alert" role="dialog"><div aria-hidn="te" role="prentatn" class="AlertArrow-daOgye AlLda alert-arrow"></div><div class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ AlertMsage-jgAjgo bVCFRm ifgabc iOlxjf alert-msage"><p aria-hidn="te">Lk pied</p></div></div></div><button aria-label="Shop" class="BaseButton-bLlsy ButtonWrapper-xCepQ bqVKKv YsOBB button button--primary-pair RponsiveCartoonInButton-hBCBMq lpsjql" data-event-click="{"element":"Button"}" data-ttid="Button" type="button"><span class="ButtonLabel-cjAuJN bBWXSg button__label">Shop</span><div class="ButtonInWrapper-gFdzAL bPDyTT button__in-ntaer"><svg class="in in-rt" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" xmlns="><tle>Shop</tle><g clip-path="url(#clip0_3732_178638)"><path fill-le="evenodd" clip-le="evenodd" d="M4 3H2V4H4.23828L6.99617 15.2631C7.11483 15.6982 7.50998 16 7.96094 16H18.0365C18.4875 16 18.8826 15.6982 19.0013 15.2631L20.9648 7.26312C21.1383 6.62698 20.6594 6 20 6H10V7H20L18.0365 15H7.96094L5.03652 3H4.58055H4ZM10.0365 19C10.0365 19.5523 9.58881 20 9.03652 20C8.48424 20 8.03652 19.5523 8.03652 19C8.03652 18.4477 8.48424 18 9.03652 18C9.58881 18 10.0365 18.4477 10.0365 19ZM11.0365 19C11.0365 20.1046 10.1411 21 9.03652 21C7.93195 21 7.03652 20.1046 7.03652 19C7.03652 17.8954 7.93195 17 9.03652 17C10.1411 17 11.0365 17.8954 11.0365 19ZM18.0365 19C18.0365 19.5523 17.5888 20 17.0365 20C16.4842 20 16.0365 19.5523 16.0365 19C16.0365 18.4477 16.4842 18 17.0365 18C17.5888 18 18.0365 18.4477 18.0365 19ZM19.0365 19C19.0365 20.1046 18.1411 21 17.0365 21C15.932 21 15.0365 20.1046 15.0365 19C15.0365 17.8954 15.932 17 17.0365 17C18.1411 17 19.0365 17.8954 19.0365 19Z" fill="black"></path></g><fs><clipPath id="clip0_3732_178638"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath><clipPath id="clip1_3732_178638"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath></fs></svg></div></button></div></div></div></span></div></figure><p class="paywall">Friends and supporters sometim scribe Gabbard as “poised,” which may also be a way of acknowledgg that she is not particularly spontaneo. She engag dienc wh a voice that is slow, reassurg, and fatly hypnotic. Her rtg exprsn is a sympathetic se, and she has perfected an effective double-hug technique: a warm, long embrace when she meets someone, and an even longer one when sayg goodbye, as if to signal that somethg meangful has transpired. “We love you, Tulsi,” someone lled out when she fished.</p><div data-attr-viewport-monor="le-recirc" class="le-recirc-wrapper le-recirc-observer-target-1 viewport-monor-anchor"></div><p class="paywall">“I love you, too,” she lled back.</p><div><div class="ConsumerMarketgUnThemedWrapper-iUTMTf jssHut nsumer-marketg-un nsumer-marketg-un--article-mid-ntent" role="prentatn" aria-hidn="te"><div class="nsumer-marketg-un__slot nsumer-marketg-un__slot--article-mid-ntent nsumer-marketg-un__slot---ntent"></div><div class="journey-un"></div></div></div><p class="paywall">In Gabbard’s tellg, her fort wh crowds is the rult of hard work, and a philosophil breakthrough. She was unually shy as a girl, but eventually she realized that her anxiety was not jt nvenient but fensible. She remembers thkg, “If all of my fears are g om selfish thoughts, then that kd of feats the whole pot of what I want to do.” So she traed herself to talk to strangers, to “share that aloha wh them.” In the Hawaiian language, “aloha” n be a salutatn or a valedictn, but also refers to a spir fed state law as “the ordatn of md and heart wh each person.” (Hawaiian officials are directed to “give nsiratn to the ‘Aloha spir’ ” as they discharge their duti.)</p><p class="paywall">When Gabbard entered polics, she was only twenty-one, and those early years she was a social nservative, pro-life and active the fight agast same-sex marriage. She is now pro-choice and pro-same-sex-marriage: on the and other issu, she has evolved enough to be almost—but not que—at home the ntemporary Democratic Party, which is creasgly progrsive, particularly on issu of genr and sexual orientatn. The exact nature and extent of Gabbard’s polil evolutn is not easy to apprehend, pecially sce Hawaii is not known for polil centrism. It is, by some measur, the blut state the untry: last year’s electn, Hillary Clton beat Donald Tmp there, sixty-two per cent to thirty per cent, her biggt victory anywhere bis the District of Columbia. Many of those Clton voters were unhappily surprised when, ls than two weeks after the electn, Gabbard agreed to meet wh Tmp to make her se for a nonterventnist foreign policy. A few months later, she flew to Syria and met wh Bashar al-Assad, who is pridg over a btal civil war; she and he seemed to agree that the Uned Stat should not tervene to stop .</p><p class="paywall">Earlier this year, a handful of impassned progrsiv gathered downtown Honolulu for an event known as Rist Tmp Tuday, which they vised their senators and Congrs members—all Democrats—and urged them to fight harr. They got a iendly receptn at the office of Senator Brian Schatz, and one participant prented some red flowers at the office of Senator Mazie Hirono, who has been battlg kidney ncer. But at Gabbard’s office the staffer who met them was warier: he read a list of her recent legislative posns, cludg her support for a fifteen-dollar mimum wage, then listened polely as they exprsed their ncerns. (They wanted a more vigoro ngrsnal vtigatn to Rsian lln wh Tmp’s mpaign, legalizatn of sex work, actn on climate change, fundg for the arts.) As they spilled back out to the hallway, they were, for the first time all afternoon, exprsg ambivalence.</p><p class="paywall">“Tulsi is great,” one man said. “She’s really good on the posns.”</p><p class="paywall">“<em>Most</em> of them,” a woman replied. “She’s a riddle to me.”</p><p class="has-dropp has-dropp__lead-standard-headg paywall">On a steamy summer day Washgton, Gabbard was shuttlg between her office, the Longworth Buildg, and the Hoe floor, where her prence was urgently but irregularly required, for vot. In keepg wh ngrsnal tradn, she has filled her office wh mementos of her home state, cludg a plaque, at the receptnist’s sk, bearg a iendly but blunt msage: “<em class="small">ALOHA SPIRIT REQUIRED HERE. IF YOU CAN’T SHARE IT TODAY, PLEASE VISIT US SOME OTHER TIME</em>.” Gabbard fli back to Hawaii whenever she gets a long enough weekend, but she has e to enjoy her circumscribed and eic existence Washgton. She liv across the Anastia River, on the cy’s southeastern edge, wh her sister, Vrdavan, who is a U.S. marshal, and Vrdavan’s hband, whose rponsibili clu the preparatn of vegetarian meals. When Gabbard is town, she fds that she n spend days nstant motn, meetg and votg and meetg some more, while hardly ever leavg the warren of feral buildgs. Even her daily recreatn is there: she is a member of the famoly tough bipartisan workout group led by Markwayne Mull, Republin of Oklahoma, who happens to be a former profsnal mixed-martial-arts fighter.</p><figure class="AssetEmbedWrapper-eVDQiB byBkf asset-embed"><div class="AssetEmbedAssetContaer-eJxoAx dBHGoQ asset-embed__asset-ntaer"><span class="SpanWrapper-umhxW kKwZhx rponsive-asset AssetEmbedRponsiveAsset-cXBNxi eCxVQK asset-embed__rponsive-asset"><div data-attr-viewport-monor="" class="RponsiveCartoonWrapper-iTMMjI eXTYsS rponsive-rtoon AssetEmbedRponsiveAsset-cXBNxi eCxVQK asset-embed__rponsive-asset viewport-monor-anchor"><a class="external-lk rponsive-rtoon__image-lk" data-event-click="{"element":"ExternalLk","outgogURL":"" href=" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank"><picture class="RponsiveImagePicture-cWuUZO dUOtEa RponsiveCartoonImage-hzNqyc ikeCcH rponsive-rtoon__image rponsive-image"><noscript><img alt="“You lose your phone aga Rty”" class="RponsiveImageContaer-eybHBd fptoWY rponsive-image__image" src=" srcSet=" 120w, 240w, 320w, 640w, 960w, 1280w, 1600w" siz="100vw"/></noscript></picture></a><div class="CaptnWrapper-jSZdqE gdZTpI ptn RponsiveCartoonCaptn-dokfdF hJgaLQ rponsive-rtoon__ptn"><span class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ CaptnText-bHjzlu iUEiRd hWyo bsWloa ptn__text">“You lose your phone aga, Rty?”</span></div><div class="RponsiveCartoonCTA-eiqqMB iDCQRs"><div class="RponsiveCartoonCTAWrapper-CYIqa iTbFtf"><div class="RponsiveCartoonLkButtonWrapper-hqDAJK eSEhbj"><button aria-label="Copy lk to rtoon" class="BaseButton-bLlsy ButtonWrapper-xCepQ bqVKKv YsOBB button button--primary-pair RponsiveCartoonInButton-hBCBMq lpsjql" data-event-click="{"element":"Button"}" data-ttid="Button" type="button"><span class="ButtonLabel-cjAuJN bBWXSg button__label">Copy lk to rtoon</span><div class="ButtonInWrapper-gFdzAL bPDyTT button__in-ntaer"><svg class="in in-pylk" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" xmlns="><tle>Copy lk to rtoon</tle><g clip-path="url(#clip0_3732_178637)"><path fill-le="evenodd" clip-le="evenodd" d="M16.3488 10.5017C16.2107 10.7357 16.2926 11.035 16.5318 11.17C16.7709 11.3052 17.0767 11.225 17.2148 10.991L18.4648 8.87225C19.5694 7.00002 18.9139 4.60601 17.0007 3.52508C15.0875 2.44415 12.6412 3.08562 11.5366 4.95785L9.53657 8.34782C8.432 10.22 9.08751 12.6141 11.0007 13.6949C11.1888 13.8012 11.382 13.8908 11.5785 13.9642C11.7819 14.0403 12.0058 13.9485 12.1147 13.764C12.2794 13.4849 12.1103 13.1276 11.8083 12.9992C11.7041 12.9549 11.6014 12.9044 11.5007 12.8475C10.0658 12.0368 9.57417 10.2413 10.4026 8.83712L12.4026 5.44715C13.2311 4.04298 15.0658 3.56187 16.5007 4.37257C17.9356 5.18327 18.4272 6.97878 17.5988 8.38295L16.3488 10.5017ZM7.6526 13.4983C7.79067 13.2643 7.70873 12.965 7.46959 12.8299C7.23044 12.6948 6.92464 12.775 6.78657 13.009L5.53657 15.1278C4.432 17 5.0875 19.394 7.00068 20.475C8.91385 21.5558 11.3602 20.9144 12.4648 19.0422L14.4648 15.6521C15.5694 13.78 14.9139 11.3859 13.0007 10.305C12.8127 10.1988 12.6195 10.1091 12.4229 10.0357C12.2195 9.95975 11.9956 10.0515 11.8867 10.236C11.7221 10.5151 11.8911 10.8724 12.1932 11.0008C12.2973 11.0451 12.4 11.0956 12.5007 11.1525C13.9356 11.9632 14.4272 13.7587 13.5988 15.1628L11.5988 18.5529C10.7704 19.957 8.93555 20.4382 7.50068 19.6274C6.0658 18.8167 5.57417 17.0212 6.4026 15.6171L7.6526 13.4983Z" fill="black"></path></g><fs><clipPath id="clip0_3732_178637"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath><clipPath id="clip1_3732_178637"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath></fs></svg></div></button><div class="AlertWrapper-gvFATk MdjE RponsiveCartoonLkAlertPopup-BPAXn kdMXRM shoppg-alert" role="dialog"><div aria-hidn="te" role="prentatn" class="AlertArrow-daOgye AlLda alert-arrow"></div><div class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ AlertMsage-jgAjgo bVCFRm ifgabc iOlxjf alert-msage"><p aria-hidn="te">Lk pied</p></div></div></div><button aria-label="Shop" class="BaseButton-bLlsy ButtonWrapper-xCepQ bqVKKv YsOBB button button--primary-pair RponsiveCartoonInButton-hBCBMq lpsjql" data-event-click="{"element":"Button"}" data-ttid="Button" type="button"><span class="ButtonLabel-cjAuJN bBWXSg button__label">Shop</span><div class="ButtonInWrapper-gFdzAL bPDyTT button__in-ntaer"><svg class="in in-rt" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" xmlns="><tle>Shop</tle><g clip-path="url(#clip0_3732_178638)"><path fill-le="evenodd" clip-le="evenodd" d="M4 3H2V4H4.23828L6.99617 15.2631C7.11483 15.6982 7.50998 16 7.96094 16H18.0365C18.4875 16 18.8826 15.6982 19.0013 15.2631L20.9648 7.26312C21.1383 6.62698 20.6594 6 20 6H10V7H20L18.0365 15H7.96094L5.03652 3H4.58055H4ZM10.0365 19C10.0365 19.5523 9.58881 20 9.03652 20C8.48424 20 8.03652 19.5523 8.03652 19C8.03652 18.4477 8.48424 18 9.03652 18C9.58881 18 10.0365 18.4477 10.0365 19ZM11.0365 19C11.0365 20.1046 10.1411 21 9.03652 21C7.93195 21 7.03652 20.1046 7.03652 19C7.03652 17.8954 7.93195 17 9.03652 17C10.1411 17 11.0365 17.8954 11.0365 19ZM18.0365 19C18.0365 19.5523 17.5888 20 17.0365 20C16.4842 20 16.0365 19.5523 16.0365 19C16.0365 18.4477 16.4842 18 17.0365 18C17.5888 18 18.0365 18.4477 18.0365 19ZM19.0365 19C19.0365 20.1046 18.1411 21 17.0365 21C15.932 21 15.0365 20.1046 15.0365 19C15.0365 17.8954 15.932 17 17.0365 17C18.1411 17 19.0365 17.8954 19.0365 19Z" fill="black"></path></g><fs><clipPath id="clip0_3732_178638"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath><clipPath id="clip1_3732_178638"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath></fs></svg></div></button></div></div></div></span></div></figure><p class="paywall">Like all ngrsnal offic, Gabbard’s receiv a steady and variegated stream of guts: cur visors, hopeful advot, aggrieved nstuents, old iends. On this morng, she had a brief discsn wh a uple of missile-fense experts and then shed over to the Capol for a seri of unntroversial vot on sex traffickg. The chamber was maly serted, except for the tourist galleri, which were full of fai, none of whom, seemed, had been warned about the day’s agenda. “The vot are separated by two mut,” Gabbard said. “So, if you’re not payg attentn, you n end up votg wrong on a bunch of thgs.”</p><div class="Contaer-bkChBi byNLHx"></div><p class="paywall">Gabbard do not nsir herself to be pecially loyal to any lear or factn. “No one om the D-triple-C”—the Democratic Congrsnal Campaign Commtee—“me and reced me to n for Congrs,” she says. “So my suatn may be different om others, who have relied heavily on Party support om the begng.” Gabbard was a long shot when, 2012, she cid to pete the Democratic primary agast Mufi Hannemann, the popular former mayor of Honolulu. So she sent a small army of volunteers across the islands, plantg lawn signs and lg the roads wh plards, nng a mpaign based ls on policy than on personaly. People who supported Gabbard then have a hard time rememberg now what the issu were. One lol Democratic activist was drawn to her maly bee she seemed like “a bright, h voice.” Gabbard won the primary by twenty percentage pots, and then ran all but unntted the general electn, agast a token Republin opponent.</p><div data-attr-viewport-monor="le-recirc" class="le-recirc-wrapper le-recirc-observer-target-2 viewport-monor-anchor"></div><p class="paywall">At the 2012 Democratic Natnal Conventn, Gabbard praised Print Obama, a fellow-Hawaiian, and Vice-Print Joe Bin, along wh their wiv, as “the strongt advot our ary fai uld ever have.” But, once office, she cled to play the role of reliable ally. Not long after she was sworn , she joed wh Republins to vote for a short-term spendg bill that most of her Democratic lleagu opposed. (She said that she wanted to sure unterpted fundg for the ary.) And 2015 she went on Fox News and acced the Obama Admistratn of not regnizg that “Islamic extremists are our enemy.” By then, she was buildg a natnwi profile: 2013, the Democratic Natnal Commtee had appoted her vice-chair, a role that marked her as a risg star. But, later 2015, as the Printial primari drew near, she lled for addnal Democratic bat, a posn that seemed to put her at odds wh the Hillary Clton mpaign and, not cintally, wh Debbie Wasserman Schultz, the D.N.C. chair. Acrdg to Gabbard, the mtee retaliated by disvg her om the first bate; Wasserman Schultz ntend that Gabbard “was not unved,” but that she had been asked to foc on the ndidat, not on the procs.</p><p class="paywall">A few months later, Gabbard rigned her D.N.C. posn so that she uld endorse Clton’s opponent Bernie Sanrs; she argued that Clton was a mted ary terventnist, and that Sanrs was more tstworthy on “issu of war and peace.” The endorsement unnerved some of Gabbard’s alli, who assumed that Clton would be the nomee. “Some of my iends and lleagu were lookg at me as though I had jt—they were preparg for my ath, sentially,” Gabbard remembers. They told her, “When she”—Clton—“ws, you’re gog to suffer for many, many years.” (At least two potential fund-raisers abandoned Gabbard; an e-mail, which was forward to John Posta and subsequently ma public by WikiLeaks, they acced her of beg “disrpectful to Hillary Clton.” )</p></div></div></div><div class="GridItem-buujkM fVLMby grid--em grid-layout__asi"><asi class="PersistentAsiWrapper-VGrR daRVRt persistent-asi" style="posn:absolute;top:to;height:to" data-ttid="PersistentAsiWrapper"><div class="StickyBoxWrapper-jfYB jxBcTH sticky-box"><div class="StickyBoxPrimary-dzWDWL cdhYoN sticky-box__primary"><div class="AdWrapper-dQtivb fZrssQ ad ad--rail"><div class="ad__slot ad__slot--rail" data-no-id="lb6vdj"></div></div><div class="ConsumerMarketgUnThemedWrapper-iUTMTf jssHut nsumer-marketg-un nsumer-marketg-un--display-rail" role="prentatn" aria-hidn="te"><div class="nsumer-marketg-un__slot nsumer-marketg-un__slot--display-rail"></div><div class="journey-un"></div></div></div><div class="StickyBoxPlaceholr-grPmrg dxAvXx"></div></div></asi></div></div><div class="RowWrapper-UmqTg HEhan full-bleed-ad row-mid-ntent-ad"><div class="StickyMidContentAdWrapper-fSBzwl drzyIa ad-stickymidntent"><div class="AdWrapper-dQtivb fZrssQ ad ad--mid-ntent should-hold-space"><div class="ad__slot ad__slot--mid-ntent" data-no-id="umyck"></div></div></div></div><div class="GridWrapper-cAzTTK kHBDeH grid grid-margs grid-ems-2 ArticlePageChunksGrid-hfxa bjczjj grid-layout--adrail narrow wi-adrail"><div class="GridItem-buujkM stRKV grid--em grid-layout__ntent"><div class="BodyWrapper-kufPGa EOneK body body__ntaer article__body" data-journey-hook="client-ntent" data-ttid="BodyWrapper"><div class="body__ner-ntaer"><p class="paywall">When Clton won the nomatn, posed a problem for Gabbard, until someone me along to solve : Donald Tmp, whose victory sured that Sanrs supporters would pay no substantial price for havg abandoned Clton. Gabbard says that she was “shocked” when Tmp won, and “ncerned, so many ways.” But, while some of her iends spent weeks fightg prsn, she had a more levelhead reactn. “I’m a pretty pragmatic person,” she says. “It was, like, ‘O.K., there’s a lot at stake. We are where we are—let’s figure out how we move forward.’ ” And so, when Steve Bannon lled and asked her to meet wh Tmp, at Tmp Tower, she accepted. (The Hill <a href=">reported</a> that Bannon “lov Tulsi Gabbard,” and that he viewed her as someone who “gets the foreign policy stuff, the Islamic terrorism stuff.”) Gabbard sists that she never nsired the possibily—which seemed plsible, those unpredictable days—that Tmp would offer her a posn his Cabet. Her claim is not entirely believable, but spar her om havg to answer the qutn of whether she would have accepted such an offer.</p><p class="paywall">Gabbard says that she and Tmp talked maly about foreign policy; as a ndidate, he had suggted, however nsistently, that he would curb ary terventns. Gabbard rells that she found the meetg enuragg. “I walked out thkg that there may be some opportuny to work wh this Admistratn to shift our foreign policy a more posive, ls stctive directn,” she said, and then psed. “Ls hopeful, now.” In April, after Tmp orred an attack on a Syrian airfield, Gabbard acced him of behavg “recklsly,” and suggted that he had fallen unr the fluence of “war hawks.” More often, though, she has seemed reluctant to antagonize Tmp. Given the overwhelmgly Democratic makp of her district, this approach nnot be explaed by electoral lculatn, and has plited her relatnship wh some of the grassroots activists who might otherwise be cled to support her.</p><p class="paywall">When Gabbard appeared Syria, last January, many wonred whether she was rryg a msage to Assad om Tmp. She says that she was not, and that she didn’t even tell the g Admistratn that she was gog there. She met twice wh Assad, who wanted to nvce her of the threat posed by groups like <em class="small">ISIS</em> and Al Nra. She travelled wh her hband, Abraham Williams, a cematographer, who ma a uple of stark but stylish vios of the trip: Gabbard talkg to universy stunts Damasc, assurg them that she wants to stop the Uned Stat om supportg “terrorist groups”; Gabbard tourg the bble of a stroyed church wh a lol pastor, who said that Christians were beg targeted by “rebels” loyal to the Islamic State. The vios nveyed the imprsn that the outsirs had brought chaos to Syria, and that the only path to peace was to put down the surgency. Upon her return, Gabbard gave an terview which she timated that she and Assad—who is known to vicly punish dissent—had negotiated an agreement to brg mocracy to Syria. “I challenged him, and talked to him about havg fair and open electns, objective ternatnal observers, and makg so that the Syrian people n terme the future of Syria for themselv,” she told a reporter. “And the are thgs that he agreed to.”</p><p class="paywall">Gabbard’s trip was wily regard as a polil disaster; Adam Kzger, a Republin ngrsman om Illois, lled Assad a “mass murrer,” and acced Gabbard of havg “legimized his genoci agast the Syrian people.” After reporters revealed that the trip had been fund by a pair of Lebane-Amerin bsmen wh ti to a pro-Assad polil party, Gabbard agreed to repay her travel sts. And yet, stead of distancg herself om this episo, she has embraced . In April, after a sar-gas attack Syria, Gabbard said that she was “skeptil” of claims that Assad’s ernment was to blame. Howard Dean, the former D.N.C. chair, rpond on Twter, “This is a disgrace. Gabbard should not be Congrs.”</p><figure class="AssetEmbedWrapper-eVDQiB byBkf asset-embed"><div class="AssetEmbedAssetContaer-eJxoAx dBHGoQ asset-embed__asset-ntaer"><span class="SpanWrapper-umhxW kKwZhx rponsive-asset AssetEmbedRponsiveAsset-cXBNxi eCxVQK asset-embed__rponsive-asset"><div data-attr-viewport-monor="" class="RponsiveCartoonWrapper-iTMMjI eXTYsS rponsive-rtoon AssetEmbedRponsiveAsset-cXBNxi eCxVQK asset-embed__rponsive-asset viewport-monor-anchor"><a class="external-lk rponsive-rtoon__image-lk" data-event-click="{"element":"ExternalLk","outgogURL":"" href=" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank"><picture class="RponsiveImagePicture-cWuUZO dUOtEa RponsiveCartoonImage-hzNqyc ikeCcH rponsive-rtoon__image rponsive-image"><noscript><img alt="“The problem is ther no enge. Jt a myster plot vice.”" class="RponsiveImageContaer-eybHBd fptoWY rponsive-image__image" src=" srcSet=" 120w, 240w, 320w, 640w, 960w, 1280w, 1600w" siz="100vw"/></noscript></picture></a><div class="CaptnWrapper-jSZdqE gdZTpI ptn RponsiveCartoonCaptn-dokfdF hJgaLQ rponsive-rtoon__ptn"><span class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ CaptnText-bHjzlu iUEiRd hWyo bsWloa ptn__text">“The problem is there’s no enge. Jt a myster plot vice.”</span></div><div class="RponsiveCartoonCTA-eiqqMB iDCQRs"><div class="RponsiveCartoonCTAWrapper-CYIqa iTbFtf"><div class="RponsiveCartoonLkButtonWrapper-hqDAJK eSEhbj"><button aria-label="Copy lk to rtoon" class="BaseButton-bLlsy ButtonWrapper-xCepQ bqVKKv YsOBB button button--primary-pair RponsiveCartoonInButton-hBCBMq lpsjql" data-event-click="{"element":"Button"}" data-ttid="Button" type="button"><span class="ButtonLabel-cjAuJN bBWXSg button__label">Copy lk to rtoon</span><div class="ButtonInWrapper-gFdzAL bPDyTT button__in-ntaer"><svg class="in in-pylk" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" xmlns="><tle>Copy lk to rtoon</tle><g clip-path="url(#clip0_3732_178637)"><path fill-le="evenodd" clip-le="evenodd" d="M16.3488 10.5017C16.2107 10.7357 16.2926 11.035 16.5318 11.17C16.7709 11.3052 17.0767 11.225 17.2148 10.991L18.4648 8.87225C19.5694 7.00002 18.9139 4.60601 17.0007 3.52508C15.0875 2.44415 12.6412 3.08562 11.5366 4.95785L9.53657 8.34782C8.432 10.22 9.08751 12.6141 11.0007 13.6949C11.1888 13.8012 11.382 13.8908 11.5785 13.9642C11.7819 14.0403 12.0058 13.9485 12.1147 13.764C12.2794 13.4849 12.1103 13.1276 11.8083 12.9992C11.7041 12.9549 11.6014 12.9044 11.5007 12.8475C10.0658 12.0368 9.57417 10.2413 10.4026 8.83712L12.4026 5.44715C13.2311 4.04298 15.0658 3.56187 16.5007 4.37257C17.9356 5.18327 18.4272 6.97878 17.5988 8.38295L16.3488 10.5017ZM7.6526 13.4983C7.79067 13.2643 7.70873 12.965 7.46959 12.8299C7.23044 12.6948 6.92464 12.775 6.78657 13.009L5.53657 15.1278C4.432 17 5.0875 19.394 7.00068 20.475C8.91385 21.5558 11.3602 20.9144 12.4648 19.0422L14.4648 15.6521C15.5694 13.78 14.9139 11.3859 13.0007 10.305C12.8127 10.1988 12.6195 10.1091 12.4229 10.0357C12.2195 9.95975 11.9956 10.0515 11.8867 10.236C11.7221 10.5151 11.8911 10.8724 12.1932 11.0008C12.2973 11.0451 12.4 11.0956 12.5007 11.1525C13.9356 11.9632 14.4272 13.7587 13.5988 15.1628L11.5988 18.5529C10.7704 19.957 8.93555 20.4382 7.50068 19.6274C6.0658 18.8167 5.57417 17.0212 6.4026 15.6171L7.6526 13.4983Z" fill="black"></path></g><fs><clipPath id="clip0_3732_178637"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath><clipPath id="clip1_3732_178637"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath></fs></svg></div></button><div class="AlertWrapper-gvFATk MdjE RponsiveCartoonLkAlertPopup-BPAXn kdMXRM shoppg-alert" role="dialog"><div aria-hidn="te" role="prentatn" class="AlertArrow-daOgye AlLda alert-arrow"></div><div class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ AlertMsage-jgAjgo bVCFRm ifgabc iOlxjf alert-msage"><p aria-hidn="te">Lk pied</p></div></div></div><button aria-label="Shop" class="BaseButton-bLlsy ButtonWrapper-xCepQ bqVKKv YsOBB button button--primary-pair RponsiveCartoonInButton-hBCBMq lpsjql" data-event-click="{"element":"Button"}" data-ttid="Button" type="button"><span class="ButtonLabel-cjAuJN bBWXSg button__label">Shop</span><div class="ButtonInWrapper-gFdzAL bPDyTT button__in-ntaer"><svg class="in in-rt" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" xmlns="><tle>Shop</tle><g clip-path="url(#clip0_3732_178638)"><path fill-le="evenodd" clip-le="evenodd" d="M4 3H2V4H4.23828L6.99617 15.2631C7.11483 15.6982 7.50998 16 7.96094 16H18.0365C18.4875 16 18.8826 15.6982 19.0013 15.2631L20.9648 7.26312C21.1383 6.62698 20.6594 6 20 6H10V7H20L18.0365 15H7.96094L5.03652 3H4.58055H4ZM10.0365 19C10.0365 19.5523 9.58881 20 9.03652 20C8.48424 20 8.03652 19.5523 8.03652 19C8.03652 18.4477 8.48424 18 9.03652 18C9.58881 18 10.0365 18.4477 10.0365 19ZM11.0365 19C11.0365 20.1046 10.1411 21 9.03652 21C7.93195 21 7.03652 20.1046 7.03652 19C7.03652 17.8954 7.93195 17 9.03652 17C10.1411 17 11.0365 17.8954 11.0365 19ZM18.0365 19C18.0365 19.5523 17.5888 20 17.0365 20C16.4842 20 16.0365 19.5523 16.0365 19C16.0365 18.4477 16.4842 18 17.0365 18C17.5888 18 18.0365 18.4477 18.0365 19ZM19.0365 19C19.0365 20.1046 18.1411 21 17.0365 21C15.932 21 15.0365 20.1046 15.0365 19C15.0365 17.8954 15.932 17 17.0365 17C18.1411 17 19.0365 17.8954 19.0365 19Z" fill="black"></path></g><fs><clipPath id="clip0_3732_178638"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath><clipPath id="clip1_3732_178638"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath></fs></svg></div></button></div></div></div></span></div></figure><p class="paywall">Gabbard is a member of the Hoe Foreign Affairs and Armed Servic mte. But she is still tryg to build support for her signature piece of legislatn, the Stop Armg Terrorists Act, which would prohib feral fundg for “Al Qaeda, Jabhat Fateh al-Sham, and <em class="small">ISIL</em>, or any dividual or group that is affiliated wh, associated wh, operatg wh, or adherents to such groups.” Its ma aim, as Gabbard scrib , is to force the C.I.A. to stop aidg ants Syria. The current versn of the bill has fourteen -sponsors, eight Republins and six Democrats, but has not received a vote. Gabbard’s tert foreign policy sets her apart om other amb Democrats, many of whom have difficulty articulatg a clear posn on Syria, and virtually all of whom would rather attach themselv to the kds of domtic issu—stoppg Tmp, fightg poverty, battg discrimatn—that thrill the Democratic base. In this and other ways, Gabbard’s untertuive approach n make her seem unually prcipled, or maybe jt unual. The Uned Stat has been prosecutg a war on terror for more than sixteen years; Gabbard is one of vanishgly few Democratic policians who are eager to talk about .</p><p class="has-dropp has-dropp__lead-standard-headg paywall">One afternoon Hawaii, as Gabbard ma her way to vis a Filipo-Amerin veteran at home, she explaed that lols sometim intify one another by askg, “What high school did you go to?” This is a plited qutn for Gabbard, who is not que a native Hawaiian. She was born Amerin Samoa and moved to Hawaii 1983, when she was two. She was both a tomboy and a nerd, a batn that ed her no problems the lol schools, bee she didn’t go to one: Gabbard was maly homchooled. Her first polil passn was environmentalism, an tert rived om her first recreatnal passn, which was the ocean. She liv on Oahu’s east si, and whenever she is home she lik to start her day on the water. On the morng after Memorial Day, she and Williams woke up before dawn and drove to an unmarked beach so that they uld take paddleboards out to an island they like. As the sun rose, they ate mango and lyche on the sand. Williams, who is twenty-eight and solico, monored a group of tourists nearby, makg sure they didn’t get too close to a monk seal and her pup, playg the surf.</p><p class="paywall">One of Gabbard’s iends scrib her parents, fondly, as “fuck’ hippi,” and was her father who enuraged her to turn her tert the ocean to a polil e. Polics was a fay votn: Carol Gabbard, Tulsi’s mother, won a seat on the State Board of Edutn 2000. For a , Mike Gabbard was Hawaii’s leadg opponent of the gay-rights movement, an energetic and often bsque activist who stood ever ready to nounce what he lled “the radil homosexual agenda.” In 1999, after one of the ma characters on the teen drama “Dawson’s Creek” was revealed to be gay, Mike Gabbard flew to North Carola, where the program was filmed, to lead a prott.</p><div data-attr-viewport-monor="le-recirc" class="le-recirc-wrapper le-recirc-observer-target-3 viewport-monor-anchor"></div><p class="paywall">In 2002, when Tulsi Gabbard was only twenty-one, she ran, as a Democrat, for the Hawaii State Hoe of Reprentativ, alongsi another first-time ndidate: her father, who sought and won a seat on the nonpartisan Honolulu Cy Council. She is eager, now, to expla that she and her father had entirely separate polil liv. “He was talkg pothol and trash and sewage, and I was talkg about tn and environment and other issu,” she says. “We’d see each other every now and then.” In fact, the two Gabbards -found a pair of nonprof anizatns: Stand Up for Ameri, a patrtic pro-ary group, and the Healthy Hawaii Coaln, which promoted environmentalism, and which secured a ernment grant to send Gabbard to schools drsed as a pollutn-fightg superhero named Water Woman.</p><p class="paywall">In her first polil rnatn, Gabbard balanced liberal environmentalism wh a pronounced nservative streak. In 2003, she voted agast a bill to oblige hospals to “provi emergency ntraceptn immediately” to survivors of sexual asslt, bee did not nta a “nscience clse,” to allow provirs wh a relig objectn to opt out. She supported ernment surveillance efforts, warng that the “mand for unfettered civil liberti” uld make the natn vulnerable to terrorists. And she joed her father’s battle agast what she lled “homosexual extremists.” In 1998, Mike Gabbard had succsfully phed for an amendment to the Hawaii State Constutn, to perm the legislature to ban same-sex marriage, which did. Six years later, Tulsi Gabbard led a prott agast a bill that would have legalized civil unns for same-sex upl. That same year, the Hawaii State Hoe, she livered a long, fierce speech agast a proposed rolutn meant to target anti-gay bullyg public schools. She objected to the ia of stunts beg tght that homosexualy is “normal and natural,” and worried that passg the rolutn would have the effect of “vg homosexual-advocy anizatns to our schools to promote their agenda to our vulnerable youth.”</p></div></div></div><div class="GridItem-buujkM fVLMby grid--em grid-layout__asi"><div class="StickyBoxWrapper-jfYB jxBcTH sticky-box"><div class="StickyBoxPrimary-dzWDWL cdhYoN sticky-box__primary"></div><div class="StickyBoxPlaceholr-grPmrg dxAvXx"></div></div></div></div><div class="RowWrapper-UmqTg HEhan full-bleed-ad row-mid-ntent-ad"><div class="StickyMidContentAdWrapper-fSBzwl drzyIa ad-stickymidntent"><div class="AdWrapper-dQtivb fZrssQ ad ad--mid-ntent should-hold-space"><div class="ad__slot ad__slot--mid-ntent" data-no-id="7w4g"></div></div></div></div><div class="GridWrapper-cAzTTK kHBDeH grid grid-margs grid-ems-2 ArticlePageChunksGrid-hfxa bjczjj grid-layout--adrail narrow wi-adrail"><div class="GridItem-buujkM stRKV grid--em grid-layout__ntent"><div class="BodyWrapper-kufPGa EOneK body body__ntaer article__body" data-journey-hook="client-ntent" data-ttid="BodyWrapper"><div class="body__ner-ntaer"><p class="paywall">As Gabbard was settlg to her polil reer, 2003, she did somethg surprisg: she joed the Natnal Guard, and, when her briga was shipped to Iraq, she volunteered to go, even though her name was not on the mandatory-ployment roster. She served as a medil-operatns specialist on a base the Sunni Triangle, and also as a ary police officer, before attendg officer-ndidate school Alabama, where she excelled; a send ployment took her to Kuwa. She often c her time the Middle East when asked to expla her polil reventn. By the time she ran for Congrs, 2012, Gabbard was prentg herself as a more or ls orthodox progrsive, pro-choice and pro-same-sex-marriage. “Experiencg as a woman, firsthand, the impacts of untri that are actg as moral arbers for their people— really ed me to rethk the posns I held,” she says. This realizatn was well timed, bee enabled her to w a Democratic primary a state that was creasgly blue. (Mike Gabbard, who is now a state senator, fected om the Republin Party and beme a Democrat 2007.) At a meetg 2012, she apologized to L.G.B.T. activists Hawaii for “very divisive and even disrpectful” thgs she had said. But Gabbard has seemed unually nflicted about sexual orientatn, an issue on which young Democrats are typilly uned and enthiastic; she has been cled to tolerate same-sex marriage but not to celebrate . “Jt bee that’s not my life style, I don’t thk that ernment should make sure that everybody else’s life styl match my own,” she told me, over the summer. Perhaps her views are still evolvg, bee a recent nversatn she said that “gay marriage should be celebrated.”</p><p class="paywall">The new versn of Gabbard is better sued to the era of Bernie Sanrs, whose Our Revolutn group endorsed her. (She was also chosen to be an gural fellow at the Sanrs Instute, found by Bernie’s wife, Jane Sanrs.) She supports sgle-payer health re and a fifteen-dollar mimum wage; her 2016 crique of Clton, as too close to rporate and polil él, now sounds ls like apostasy and more like the nventnal wisdom of a changg Democratic Party. Gabbard is also a symbol of mographic change: she is om Hawaii, where nonwh make up about three-quarters of the populatn, and she is the product of an terracial marriage—her father is Samoan, and her mother is whe. Gabbard is, promently, a relig mory, the first reprentative to swear the oath of office on the Bhagavad Ga, a central Hdu text. She releas yearly holiday vios celebratg Diwali, the grand Hdu ftival of lights, and has cultivated a close relatnship wh Indian-Amerins. In 2014, she travelled to India, where she met wh the ntroversial Prime Mister Narendra Modi, who has bee a polil ally, and she is now a -chair of the Congrsnal India Cc.</p><p class="paywall">Wh her brown sk, black hair, and Hdu name, Gabbard is sometim mistaken for an Indian-Amerin. (She is named for the holy-basil plant, also known as <em>tulasi</em>, a sweet-smellg herb that appears the Bhagavad Ga as an offerg to the Lord.) “Hdu,” of urse, refers to her spirual orientatn, not to her natnal orig, but she is often scribed as “Hdu-Amerin,” a formulatn that blurs the le between fah and inty. Gabbard has grown more fortable talkg about her fah, which she barely mentned earlier her polil reer. But she has risted tellg the story of her spirual journey. This summer, when I asked her about the teacher who led her to Hduism, Gabbard grew evasive. “I’ve had many different spirual teachers, and ntue to,” she said.</p><figure class="AssetEmbedWrapper-eVDQiB byBkf asset-embed"><div class="AssetEmbedAssetContaer-eJxoAx dBHGoQ asset-embed__asset-ntaer"><span class="SpanWrapper-umhxW kKwZhx rponsive-asset AssetEmbedRponsiveAsset-cXBNxi eCxVQK asset-embed__rponsive-asset"><div data-attr-viewport-monor="" class="RponsiveCartoonWrapper-iTMMjI eXTYsS rponsive-rtoon AssetEmbedRponsiveAsset-cXBNxi eCxVQK asset-embed__rponsive-asset viewport-monor-anchor"><a class="external-lk rponsive-rtoon__image-lk" data-event-click="{"element":"ExternalLk","outgogURL":"" href=" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank"><picture class="RponsiveImagePicture-cWuUZO dUOtEa RponsiveCartoonImage-hzNqyc ikeCcH rponsive-rtoon__image rponsive-image"><noscript><img alt="What Do Tulsi Gabbard Believe" class="RponsiveImageContaer-eybHBd fptoWY rponsive-image__image" src=" srcSet=" 120w, 240w, 320w, 640w, 960w, 1280w, 1600w" siz="100vw"/></noscript></picture></a><div class="RponsiveCartoonCTA-eiqqMB iDCQRs"><div class="RponsiveCartoonCTAWrapper-CYIqa iTbFtf"><div class="RponsiveCartoonLkButtonWrapper-hqDAJK eSEhbj"><button aria-label="Copy lk to rtoon" class="BaseButton-bLlsy ButtonWrapper-xCepQ bqVKKv YsOBB button button--primary-pair RponsiveCartoonInButton-hBCBMq lpsjql" data-event-click="{"element":"Button"}" data-ttid="Button" type="button"><span class="ButtonLabel-cjAuJN bBWXSg button__label">Copy lk to rtoon</span><div class="ButtonInWrapper-gFdzAL bPDyTT button__in-ntaer"><svg class="in in-pylk" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" xmlns="><tle>Copy lk to rtoon</tle><g clip-path="url(#clip0_3732_178637)"><path fill-le="evenodd" clip-le="evenodd" d="M16.3488 10.5017C16.2107 10.7357 16.2926 11.035 16.5318 11.17C16.7709 11.3052 17.0767 11.225 17.2148 10.991L18.4648 8.87225C19.5694 7.00002 18.9139 4.60601 17.0007 3.52508C15.0875 2.44415 12.6412 3.08562 11.5366 4.95785L9.53657 8.34782C8.432 10.22 9.08751 12.6141 11.0007 13.6949C11.1888 13.8012 11.382 13.8908 11.5785 13.9642C11.7819 14.0403 12.0058 13.9485 12.1147 13.764C12.2794 13.4849 12.1103 13.1276 11.8083 12.9992C11.7041 12.9549 11.6014 12.9044 11.5007 12.8475C10.0658 12.0368 9.57417 10.2413 10.4026 8.83712L12.4026 5.44715C13.2311 4.04298 15.0658 3.56187 16.5007 4.37257C17.9356 5.18327 18.4272 6.97878 17.5988 8.38295L16.3488 10.5017ZM7.6526 13.4983C7.79067 13.2643 7.70873 12.965 7.46959 12.8299C7.23044 12.6948 6.92464 12.775 6.78657 13.009L5.53657 15.1278C4.432 17 5.0875 19.394 7.00068 20.475C8.91385 21.5558 11.3602 20.9144 12.4648 19.0422L14.4648 15.6521C15.5694 13.78 14.9139 11.3859 13.0007 10.305C12.8127 10.1988 12.6195 10.1091 12.4229 10.0357C12.2195 9.95975 11.9956 10.0515 11.8867 10.236C11.7221 10.5151 11.8911 10.8724 12.1932 11.0008C12.2973 11.0451 12.4 11.0956 12.5007 11.1525C13.9356 11.9632 14.4272 13.7587 13.5988 15.1628L11.5988 18.5529C10.7704 19.957 8.93555 20.4382 7.50068 19.6274C6.0658 18.8167 5.57417 17.0212 6.4026 15.6171L7.6526 13.4983Z" fill="black"></path></g><fs><clipPath id="clip0_3732_178637"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath><clipPath id="clip1_3732_178637"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath></fs></svg></div></button><div class="AlertWrapper-gvFATk MdjE RponsiveCartoonLkAlertPopup-BPAXn kdMXRM shoppg-alert" role="dialog"><div aria-hidn="te" role="prentatn" class="AlertArrow-daOgye AlLda alert-arrow"></div><div class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ AlertMsage-jgAjgo bVCFRm ifgabc iOlxjf alert-msage"><p aria-hidn="te">Lk pied</p></div></div></div><button aria-label="Shop" class="BaseButton-bLlsy ButtonWrapper-xCepQ bqVKKv YsOBB button button--primary-pair RponsiveCartoonInButton-hBCBMq lpsjql" data-event-click="{"element":"Button"}" data-ttid="Button" type="button"><span class="ButtonLabel-cjAuJN bBWXSg button__label">Shop</span><div class="ButtonInWrapper-gFdzAL bPDyTT button__in-ntaer"><svg class="in in-rt" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" xmlns="><tle>Shop</tle><g clip-path="url(#clip0_3732_178638)"><path fill-le="evenodd" clip-le="evenodd" d="M4 3H2V4H4.23828L6.99617 15.2631C7.11483 15.6982 7.50998 16 7.96094 16H18.0365C18.4875 16 18.8826 15.6982 19.0013 15.2631L20.9648 7.26312C21.1383 6.62698 20.6594 6 20 6H10V7H20L18.0365 15H7.96094L5.03652 3H4.58055H4ZM10.0365 19C10.0365 19.5523 9.58881 20 9.03652 20C8.48424 20 8.03652 19.5523 8.03652 19C8.03652 18.4477 8.48424 18 9.03652 18C9.58881 18 10.0365 18.4477 10.0365 19ZM11.0365 19C11.0365 20.1046 10.1411 21 9.03652 21C7.93195 21 7.03652 20.1046 7.03652 19C7.03652 17.8954 7.93195 17 9.03652 17C10.1411 17 11.0365 17.8954 11.0365 19ZM18.0365 19C18.0365 19.5523 17.5888 20 17.0365 20C16.4842 20 16.0365 19.5523 16.0365 19C16.0365 18.4477 16.4842 18 17.0365 18C17.5888 18 18.0365 18.4477 18.0365 19ZM19.0365 19C19.0365 20.1046 18.1411 21 17.0365 21C15.932 21 15.0365 20.1046 15.0365 19C15.0365 17.8954 15.932 17 17.0365 17C18.1411 17 19.0365 17.8954 19.0365 19Z" fill="black"></path></g><fs><clipPath id="clip0_3732_178638"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath><clipPath id="clip1_3732_178638"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath></fs></svg></div></button></div></div></div></span></div></figure><p class="paywall">“There’s not one that’s more important than the others?”</p><p class="paywall">“No,” she said. But there is, fact, a teacher who has played a central role her life—a teacher whom Gabbard referred to, a 2015 vio, as her “gu v,” which means, roughly, “spirual master.” His name is Chris Butler.</p><p class="has-dropp has-dropp__lead-standard-headg paywall">In 1965, an elrly Indian man known as A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada arrived Ameri, and soon began sgg and preachg Tompks Square Park, New York’s East Village. For reasons that rist secular explanatn, Bhaktivedanta drew a crowd, and the crowd grew to somethg new: the Hare Krishna movement, which troduced Wterners to the five-hundred-year-old Hdu tradn known as Gdiya Vaishnavism. The Hare Krishna votee beme, for a time, a faiar figure, and sometim a figure of fun: a young whe man wh a shaved head and an orange-sherbet robe, chantg ceaselsly and rryg an armload of books to sell. The Beatl’ rerd label released a Hare Krishna sgle, and Gee Harrison wrote “My Sweet Lord” unr the group’s fluence. (Although Harrison was never iated to the movement, Bhaktivedanta once praised him as “humble, meek, pole, and vout.”) From 1965 until his ath, 1977, Bhaktivedanta tght and travelled nstantly, while rrpondg wh seekers all over the world.</p><p class="paywall">By the early seventi, his msage had reached Hawaii, where Chris Butler was a young yoga teacher and surfer. Butler, the son of a proment doctor and antiwar activist who had e om the maland, was somethg of a prodigy: a self-styled gu who began attractg followers soon after he dropped out of llege. Even so, Butler was awed by Bhaktivedanta, who had a knack for makg ancient Indian texts sound like sensible stctn manuals. In his annotated translatn of the Bhagavad Ga, rears uld learn how to be pleasg to Lord Krishna by chewg meat and spicy food (which uld “e misery by producg muc the stomach”), by workg hard, by chantg his name—small, tangible steps that uld brg a votee close to the dive.</p><div data-attr-viewport-monor="le-recirc" class="le-recirc-wrapper le-recirc-observer-target-4 viewport-monor-anchor"></div><p class="paywall">In 1971, Bhaktivedanta me to Hawaii, and Butler, who was twenty-three, met him, and ma a tra: he turned all of his discipl over to Bhaktivedanta, and exchange gaed a new name, Siddhaswapananda, which marked him as an iated disciple and a proment figure the growg Hare Krishna movement. It was not always an easy relatnship. At tim, Bhaktivedanta admonished Butler for non-orthodox teachg, and Butler qutned Bhaktivedanta’s sistence that iat shave their heads and wear rob.</p><p class="paywall">After Bhaktivedanta’s ath, Butler no longer had to choose between votn and pennce. As the Hare Krishna movement actured, Butler created his own group, now known as the Science of Inty Foundatn, and amassed a tight-kn, low-profile work of followers, hundreds or perhaps thoands of them, stretchg wt om Hawaii to Atralia, New Zealand, and Southeast Asia. Butler ëmphasized age-old Indian texts and practic, prentg himself stead as a smart and cur guy who had figured out the answers to some very puzzlg qutns. In 1984, he published “Who Are You? Disverg Your Real Inty,” which ed exampl om science to argue that materialism was false, and that the self was real—and eternal. (Krishna and the Bhagavad Ga are mentned only passg.) He rerd a seri of televisn specials, which he rembled a hip young llege profsor on a uch, surround by quisive stunts.</p><p class="paywall">One of those stunts was Mike Gabbard, who had been terted Hduism sce the neteen-seventi: he once rrpond wh Bhaktivedanta, askg for advice on tablishg a temple, and Tulsi Gabbard’s name reflects the fay’s pre-existg spirual mments. When the Gabbards moved to Hawaii, 1983, they joed the circle of discipl around Butler. Tulsi Gabbard says that she began learng the spirual prcipl of Vaishnava Hduism as a kid, and that she grew up largely among fellow-discipl, some of whom would gather on the beach for <em>kirtan</em>, the practice of sgg or chantg sacred songs. Gabbard pursued a spirual tn: as a girl, she spent two years the Philipp, at rmal schools n by followers of Butler.</p><figure class="AssetEmbedWrapper-eVDQiB byBkf asset-embed"><div class="AssetEmbedAssetContaer-eJxoAx dBHGoQ asset-embed__asset-ntaer"><span class="SpanWrapper-umhxW kKwZhx rponsive-asset AssetEmbedRponsiveAsset-cXBNxi eCxVQK asset-embed__rponsive-asset"><div data-attr-viewport-monor="" class="RponsiveCartoonWrapper-iTMMjI eXTYsS rponsive-rtoon AssetEmbedRponsiveAsset-cXBNxi eCxVQK asset-embed__rponsive-asset viewport-monor-anchor"><a class="external-lk rponsive-rtoon__image-lk" data-event-click="{"element":"ExternalLk","outgogURL":"" href=" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank"><picture class="RponsiveImagePicture-cWuUZO dUOtEa RponsiveCartoonImage-hzNqyc ikeCcH rponsive-rtoon__image rponsive-image"><noscript><img alt="“The systems not perfect but by God s transparent.”" class="RponsiveImageContaer-eybHBd fptoWY rponsive-image__image" src=" srcSet=" 120w, 240w, 320w, 640w, 960w, 1280w, 1600w" siz="100vw"/></noscript></picture></a><div class="CaptnWrapper-jSZdqE gdZTpI ptn RponsiveCartoonCaptn-dokfdF hJgaLQ rponsive-rtoon__ptn"><span class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ CaptnText-bHjzlu iUEiRd hWyo bsWloa ptn__text">“The system’s not perfect, but, by God, ’s transparent.”</span></div><div class="RponsiveCartoonCTA-eiqqMB iDCQRs"><div class="RponsiveCartoonCTAWrapper-CYIqa iTbFtf"><div class="RponsiveCartoonLkButtonWrapper-hqDAJK eSEhbj"><button aria-label="Copy lk to rtoon" class="BaseButton-bLlsy ButtonWrapper-xCepQ bqVKKv YsOBB button button--primary-pair RponsiveCartoonInButton-hBCBMq lpsjql" data-event-click="{"element":"Button"}" data-ttid="Button" type="button"><span class="ButtonLabel-cjAuJN bBWXSg button__label">Copy lk to rtoon</span><div class="ButtonInWrapper-gFdzAL bPDyTT button__in-ntaer"><svg class="in in-pylk" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" xmlns="><tle>Copy lk to rtoon</tle><g clip-path="url(#clip0_3732_178637)"><path fill-le="evenodd" clip-le="evenodd" d="M16.3488 10.5017C16.2107 10.7357 16.2926 11.035 16.5318 11.17C16.7709 11.3052 17.0767 11.225 17.2148 10.991L18.4648 8.87225C19.5694 7.00002 18.9139 4.60601 17.0007 3.52508C15.0875 2.44415 12.6412 3.08562 11.5366 4.95785L9.53657 8.34782C8.432 10.22 9.08751 12.6141 11.0007 13.6949C11.1888 13.8012 11.382 13.8908 11.5785 13.9642C11.7819 14.0403 12.0058 13.9485 12.1147 13.764C12.2794 13.4849 12.1103 13.1276 11.8083 12.9992C11.7041 12.9549 11.6014 12.9044 11.5007 12.8475C10.0658 12.0368 9.57417 10.2413 10.4026 8.83712L12.4026 5.44715C13.2311 4.04298 15.0658 3.56187 16.5007 4.37257C17.9356 5.18327 18.4272 6.97878 17.5988 8.38295L16.3488 10.5017ZM7.6526 13.4983C7.79067 13.2643 7.70873 12.965 7.46959 12.8299C7.23044 12.6948 6.92464 12.775 6.78657 13.009L5.53657 15.1278C4.432 17 5.0875 19.394 7.00068 20.475C8.91385 21.5558 11.3602 20.9144 12.4648 19.0422L14.4648 15.6521C15.5694 13.78 14.9139 11.3859 13.0007 10.305C12.8127 10.1988 12.6195 10.1091 12.4229 10.0357C12.2195 9.95975 11.9956 10.0515 11.8867 10.236C11.7221 10.5151 11.8911 10.8724 12.1932 11.0008C12.2973 11.0451 12.4 11.0956 12.5007 11.1525C13.9356 11.9632 14.4272 13.7587 13.5988 15.1628L11.5988 18.5529C10.7704 19.957 8.93555 20.4382 7.50068 19.6274C6.0658 18.8167 5.57417 17.0212 6.4026 15.6171L7.6526 13.4983Z" fill="black"></path></g><fs><clipPath id="clip0_3732_178637"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath><clipPath id="clip1_3732_178637"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath></fs></svg></div></button><div class="AlertWrapper-gvFATk MdjE RponsiveCartoonLkAlertPopup-BPAXn kdMXRM shoppg-alert" role="dialog"><div aria-hidn="te" role="prentatn" class="AlertArrow-daOgye AlLda alert-arrow"></div><div class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ AlertMsage-jgAjgo bVCFRm ifgabc iOlxjf alert-msage"><p aria-hidn="te">Lk pied</p></div></div></div><button aria-label="Shop" class="BaseButton-bLlsy ButtonWrapper-xCepQ bqVKKv YsOBB button button--primary-pair RponsiveCartoonInButton-hBCBMq lpsjql" data-event-click="{"element":"Button"}" data-ttid="Button" type="button"><span class="ButtonLabel-cjAuJN bBWXSg button__label">Shop</span><div class="ButtonInWrapper-gFdzAL bPDyTT button__in-ntaer"><svg class="in in-rt" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" xmlns="><tle>Shop</tle><g clip-path="url(#clip0_3732_178638)"><path fill-le="evenodd" clip-le="evenodd" d="M4 3H2V4H4.23828L6.99617 15.2631C7.11483 15.6982 7.50998 16 7.96094 16H18.0365C18.4875 16 18.8826 15.6982 19.0013 15.2631L20.9648 7.26312C21.1383 6.62698 20.6594 6 20 6H10V7H20L18.0365 15H7.96094L5.03652 3H4.58055H4ZM10.0365 19C10.0365 19.5523 9.58881 20 9.03652 20C8.48424 20 8.03652 19.5523 8.03652 19C8.03652 18.4477 8.48424 18 9.03652 18C9.58881 18 10.0365 18.4477 10.0365 19ZM11.0365 19C11.0365 20.1046 10.1411 21 9.03652 21C7.93195 21 7.03652 20.1046 7.03652 19C7.03652 17.8954 7.93195 17 9.03652 17C10.1411 17 11.0365 17.8954 11.0365 19ZM18.0365 19C18.0365 19.5523 17.5888 20 17.0365 20C16.4842 20 16.0365 19.5523 16.0365 19C16.0365 18.4477 16.4842 18 17.0365 18C17.5888 18 18.0365 18.4477 18.0365 19ZM19.0365 19C19.0365 20.1046 18.1411 21 17.0365 21C15.932 21 15.0365 20.1046 15.0365 19C15.0365 17.8954 15.932 17 17.0365 17C18.1411 17 19.0365 17.8954 19.0365 19Z" fill="black"></path></g><fs><clipPath id="clip0_3732_178638"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath><clipPath id="clip1_3732_178638"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath></fs></svg></div></button></div></div></div></span></div></figure><p class="paywall">Gabbard rells her childhood as lively and eewheelg: she excelled at martial arts and veloped a passn for garng; she was a ser rear, enuraged by her parents. But a number of Butler’s former discipl rell a harsher, more thorarian atmosphere. Defectors tell stori of children disuraged by Butler om attendg secular schools; of followers forbidn to speak publicly about the group; of returng travellers quaranted for days, lt they transm a ntag disease to Butler; of vote lyg prostrate whenever he entered the room, or addg bs of his nail clippgs to their food, or eatg spoonfuls of sand that he had walked upon. Some former members portray themselv as survivors of an abive cult. Butler ni the reports, and Gabbard says that she fds them hard to cred. “I’ve never heard him say anythg hateful, or say anythg mean about anybody,” she says of Butler. “I n speak to my own personal experience and, ankly, my gratu to him, for the gift of this wonrful spirual practice that he has given to me, and to so many people.”</p></div></div></div><div class="GridItem-buujkM fVLMby grid--em grid-layout__asi"><div class="StickyBoxWrapper-jfYB jxBcTH sticky-box"><div class="StickyBoxPrimary-dzWDWL cdhYoN sticky-box__primary"><div class="AdWrapper-dQtivb fZrssQ ad ad--rail"><div class="ad__slot ad__slot--rail" data-no-id="09ifl"></div></div><div class="ConsumerMarketgUnThemedWrapper-iUTMTf jssHut nsumer-marketg-un nsumer-marketg-un--display-rail" role="prentatn" aria-hidn="te"><div class="nsumer-marketg-un__slot nsumer-marketg-un__slot--display-rail"></div><div class="journey-un"></div></div></div><div class="StickyBoxPlaceholr-grPmrg dxAvXx"></div></div></div></div><div class="RowWrapper-UmqTg HEhan full-bleed-ad row-mid-ntent-ad"><div class="StickyMidContentAdWrapper-fSBzwl drzyIa ad-stickymidntent"><div class="AdWrapper-dQtivb fZrssQ ad ad--mid-ntent should-hold-space"><div class="ad__slot ad__slot--mid-ntent" data-no-id="tykc2f8"></div></div></div></div><div class="GridWrapper-cAzTTK kHBDeH grid grid-margs grid-ems-2 ArticlePageChunksGrid-hfxa bjczjj grid-layout--adrail narrow wi-adrail"><div class="GridItem-buujkM stRKV grid--em grid-layout__ntent"><div class="BodyWrapper-kufPGa EOneK body body__ntaer article__body" data-journey-hook="client-ntent" data-ttid="BodyWrapper"><div class="body__ner-ntaer"><p class="paywall">A number of those people have bs. One of Butler’s followers is Wai Lana, a yoga entreprenr who is also his wife. Her pany, which produc yoga vios, has helped fund the Science of Inty Foundatn. Another person who seems to be a follower is Joseph Bismark, the -founr of a global multilevel-marketg pany lled <em class="small">QNET</em>, whose products clu a small disk meant to protect ers om “the harmful effects of electrosmog.” (A ago, Indonian police, alerted by Interpol, reportedly arrted Bismark on charg of d; the charg were eventually whdrawn.)</p><p class="paywall">Unlike Bhaktivedanta, whose every utterance seems to have been rerd for postery, Butler has refully ntrolled his public appearanc, and has sentially stopped talkg to the media recent s. But he agreed to talk wh me, by telephone, about his teachgs and his star pupil. Butler will be seventy next year, but he still speaks wh the boyish, wondro voice of a md-blown surfer, enriched by a trace of the clipped, sgsong accent that, Hawaii, provis a form of lol cred. He often terpts himself to chuckle, or to terject his favore rhetoril qutn: “Right?”</p><p class="paywall">Although Hdu inty plays an important role Gabbard’s reer, the term self has a plited history: is often ed as a tchall for wily varyg spirual practic on the Indian subntent, and is neher universally accepted nor reliably fed. “In the Bhagavad Ga, where is the mentn of ‘Hdu’?” Bhaktivedanta once asked. Butler, too, fds the term nstrictg. “I’m not a Hdu, I’m not a Christian, I’m not a Buddhist, I’m not a Mlim,” he says. “I’m an eternal spir soul—an <em>atma</em>, part and parcel of the supreme soul.” (His followers have generally avoid the term; Mike Gabbard scrib himself as a Catholic, notwhstandg his ti to the foundatn.) But Butler regniz the efulns of a ncise, regnizable label, pecially polics, and so he suggted to Gabbard a promise: “I told her, ‘Why don’t you e the phrase “transcenntal Hduism”?’ ” (Ined, durg a recent nversatn the ngrsnal dg room Gabbard did precisely that.) Gabbard and Butler both say that the foundatn is a rource, not a relig anizatn; there is no official hierarchy, and therefore no system of acuntabily, bis Butler’s own nscience, and the nscience of those who are voted to him. In one lecture, he acknowledged the potential for skepticism, offerg followers his versn of Pasl’s wager. “If I’m not the reprentative of God, and you dovetail your will wh me, then your life is stroyed,” he said. “And if I am the reprentative of God, and you don’t dovetail your will wh me, then your life is wasted.”</p><p class="paywall">And yet he allows that he do have “discipl,” who ll him Jagad Gu, or “teacher of the world.” “What the Jagad Gu tle nveys is that what’s beg tght is not jt for a certa group of people,” Butler says. “It’s somethg that everybody n appreciate, and ’s for people all over the world.” A gu, Butler once explaed, is supposed to be “a bona-fi reprentative of the Supreme Lord.” In mentary on the Bhagavad Ga, Bhaktivedanta emphasized that submissn was ccial to spirual advancement. “A spirual master should be accepted full surrenr,” he wrote, “and one should serve the spirual master like a menial servant, whout false prtige.” Butler is sensive to the perceptn that he is an thorarian; he prefers to talk about himself as a stunt and a follower, rather than as a teacher and a lear. “My teacher lov me,” he said. (He was referrg, the eternal-spir prent tense, to Bhaktivedanta.) “It’s a relatnship of love. And so the stunts of such a lovg gu will love their teachers—’s natural that you will love that person.” Not cintally, he speaks lovgly of Gabbard, whom he’s known virtually all her life. As a girl, he remembers, she had “a real gravy and serns that was way beyond her years.” Nowadays, Butler regards Gabbard wh fatherly pri, likeng himself to a mic teacher watchg a star pupil excel. “He’s tght one of his stunts cello,” he says. “And he se that, oh, this stunt of me is now playg cello the philharmonic orchtra. And ’s betiful.”</p><p class="has-dropp has-dropp__lead-standard-headg paywall">Gabbard is not the first disciple of Butler’s to enter polics. In the late seventi, a rather opaque group lled Inpennts for Godly Government appeared Hawaii and field more than a dozen ndidat for lol rac. The group prented self as a multifah aln of nservative-md reformers, but 1977 the Honolulu <em>Advertiser</em> published a three-part exposé intifyg I.G.G. as an iative created maly, or entirely, by discipl of Butler. One ndidate told the newspaper that discretn was part of his polil strategy. “I know for a fact that, if I said I was a Hare Krishna, the first thg people would thk was I had a shaved head, bells on my feet, and I bothered people at the airport,” he said. “To munite, I have to keep the doors open.” In <em>Valley Isle</em>, a newspaper based Mi and iendly to Butler, Bill Penaroza, one of the lears of the iative, announced that the group—which hadn’t got any of s ndidat elected—was “rtcturg.” Penaroza didn’t intify Butler as s lear, but he did nce that he had some fluence. “There was an tertg nversatn wh a iend of me who I nsir to be a very spirually advanced person, whose name is Siddha Swap Swami,” Penaroza said. (He was g a versn of Butler’s iated name, Siddhaswapananda.) “He said he thought we were a ltle too self-righteo, and that we seem to have limed ourselv to workg wh people who were of Eastern spirual discipl, neglectg many of the people we uld probably work wh the more tablished Wtern-oriented church.”</p><p class="paywall">The publisher of <em>Valley Isle</em> was a bsman named Rick Reed, who was elected to the State Senate 1986. That year, Reed, who had worked for a lol prosecutor, was acced of leakg nfintial state documents orr to discred a Democratic polician; Reed’s ex-wife told the <em>Advertiser</em> that Butler had been part of the plot. (Both Reed and Butler nied .) In 1992, Reed challenged Daniel Inouye, the old ln of Hawaiian polics, for his seat the U.S. Senate, and the mpaign brought more scty to Reed’s relatnship wh Butler. Reed had prevly referred to Butler as his “spirual adviser,” but he told the <em>Advertiser</em> that there was “no evince I have ever been a member of a Hare Krishna anizatn, or of Inpennts for Godly Government.” Reed lost the electn, but he succsfully fend off the Feral Electn Commissn, which vtigated a Christmas vio he had filmed the Philipp and distributed Hawaii, allegedly an attempt to beguile the state’s sizable Filipo-Amerin populatn. The F.E.C. ultimately led that the vio was a legimate (if dub) bs venture, and that the nety-thoand-dollar loan Reed had received to produce was not, therefore, an unlawful mpaign donatn.</p><div data-attr-viewport-monor="le-recirc" class="le-recirc-wrapper le-recirc-observer-target-5 viewport-monor-anchor"></div><p class="paywall">In Gabbard, Butler’s movement fally seems to have produced a wily appealg polician, wh a natnal profile. And there are lks between Gabbard’s polil operatn and those of I.G.G., gog all the way back to Bill Penaroza: 2015, Gabbard hired Penaroza’s son, Kaoa Penaroza, to be her chief of staff, even though he had virtually no polil experience. Gabbard, like her precsors, firmly rejects the ia that she is part of a polil iative tied to her spirual lear. “It’s a whole lot of njecture,” she told me. She offered a hypothetil parison. “Senator Brian Schatz, om Hawaii—he’s Jewish,” she said. “His chief of staff is Jewish. So there mt be some great plan of the Jewish muny Hawaii to advance this Jewish lear and those around him?”</p><p class="paywall">The difference is that the world of Butler’s discipl is relatively small and dizzygly terlked. Reed’s vio of Christmas the Philipp begs wh a vis to Toby Tamayo, a longtime employee of the group who helped n a Butler-affiliated school there. Tamayo happens to be the uncle of Gabbard’s first hband, Eddie Tamayo, whom she married 2002 and divorced four years later—partly, she says, bee of the strs of servg overseas. Both of Gabbard’s parents worked Rick Reed’s office. And the loan Reed received to make that Christmas vio me om Richard Bellord, whose son, Rupa Bellord, recently married Gabbard’s sister and roommate, Vrdavan. Richard Bellord himself ed to be married to Wai Lana, the yoga stctor who is now Butler’s wife; Abraham Williams, Gabbard’s hband, has helped film her vios. (Williams’s mother, Anya Anthony, is Gabbard’s office manager Washgton; she ss behd the “<em class="small">ALOHA SPIRIT</em>” sign.) Wai Lana’s pany is n by a longtime Butler associate named Sunil Khemaney, who is also a bs associate of Joseph Bismark’s. Khemaney helps n Gabbard’s outreach to the Indian-Amerin muny; he acpanied her on her 2014 trip to India. One person faiar wh Gabbard’s operatn scrib an office divid between discipl and non-discipl: “Everyone wonred who was the group and who wasn’t. It was taboo—people the group didn’t talk about , so no one knew for sure.”</p><figure class="AssetEmbedWrapper-eVDQiB byBkf asset-embed"><div class="AssetEmbedAssetContaer-eJxoAx dBHGoQ asset-embed__asset-ntaer"><span class="SpanWrapper-umhxW kKwZhx rponsive-asset AssetEmbedRponsiveAsset-cXBNxi eCxVQK asset-embed__rponsive-asset"><div data-attr-viewport-monor="" class="RponsiveCartoonWrapper-iTMMjI eXTYsS rponsive-rtoon AssetEmbedRponsiveAsset-cXBNxi eCxVQK asset-embed__rponsive-asset viewport-monor-anchor"><a class="external-lk rponsive-rtoon__image-lk" data-event-click="{"element":"ExternalLk","outgogURL":"" href=" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank"><picture class="RponsiveImagePicture-cWuUZO dUOtEa RponsiveCartoonImage-hzNqyc ikeCcH rponsive-rtoon__image rponsive-image"><noscript><img alt="What Do Tulsi Gabbard Believe" class="RponsiveImageContaer-eybHBd fptoWY rponsive-image__image" src=" srcSet=" 120w, 240w, 320w, 640w, 960w, 1280w, 1600w" siz="100vw"/></noscript></picture></a><div class="RponsiveCartoonCTA-eiqqMB iDCQRs"><div class="RponsiveCartoonCTAWrapper-CYIqa iTbFtf"><div class="RponsiveCartoonLkButtonWrapper-hqDAJK eSEhbj"><button aria-label="Copy lk to rtoon" class="BaseButton-bLlsy ButtonWrapper-xCepQ bqVKKv YsOBB button button--primary-pair RponsiveCartoonInButton-hBCBMq lpsjql" data-event-click="{"element":"Button"}" data-ttid="Button" type="button"><span class="ButtonLabel-cjAuJN bBWXSg button__label">Copy lk to rtoon</span><div class="ButtonInWrapper-gFdzAL bPDyTT button__in-ntaer"><svg class="in in-pylk" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" xmlns="><tle>Copy lk to rtoon</tle><g clip-path="url(#clip0_3732_178637)"><path fill-le="evenodd" clip-le="evenodd" d="M16.3488 10.5017C16.2107 10.7357 16.2926 11.035 16.5318 11.17C16.7709 11.3052 17.0767 11.225 17.2148 10.991L18.4648 8.87225C19.5694 7.00002 18.9139 4.60601 17.0007 3.52508C15.0875 2.44415 12.6412 3.08562 11.5366 4.95785L9.53657 8.34782C8.432 10.22 9.08751 12.6141 11.0007 13.6949C11.1888 13.8012 11.382 13.8908 11.5785 13.9642C11.7819 14.0403 12.0058 13.9485 12.1147 13.764C12.2794 13.4849 12.1103 13.1276 11.8083 12.9992C11.7041 12.9549 11.6014 12.9044 11.5007 12.8475C10.0658 12.0368 9.57417 10.2413 10.4026 8.83712L12.4026 5.44715C13.2311 4.04298 15.0658 3.56187 16.5007 4.37257C17.9356 5.18327 18.4272 6.97878 17.5988 8.38295L16.3488 10.5017ZM7.6526 13.4983C7.79067 13.2643 7.70873 12.965 7.46959 12.8299C7.23044 12.6948 6.92464 12.775 6.78657 13.009L5.53657 15.1278C4.432 17 5.0875 19.394 7.00068 20.475C8.91385 21.5558 11.3602 20.9144 12.4648 19.0422L14.4648 15.6521C15.5694 13.78 14.9139 11.3859 13.0007 10.305C12.8127 10.1988 12.6195 10.1091 12.4229 10.0357C12.2195 9.95975 11.9956 10.0515 11.8867 10.236C11.7221 10.5151 11.8911 10.8724 12.1932 11.0008C12.2973 11.0451 12.4 11.0956 12.5007 11.1525C13.9356 11.9632 14.4272 13.7587 13.5988 15.1628L11.5988 18.5529C10.7704 19.957 8.93555 20.4382 7.50068 19.6274C6.0658 18.8167 5.57417 17.0212 6.4026 15.6171L7.6526 13.4983Z" fill="black"></path></g><fs><clipPath id="clip0_3732_178637"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath><clipPath id="clip1_3732_178637"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath></fs></svg></div></button><div class="AlertWrapper-gvFATk MdjE RponsiveCartoonLkAlertPopup-BPAXn kdMXRM shoppg-alert" role="dialog"><div aria-hidn="te" role="prentatn" class="AlertArrow-daOgye AlLda alert-arrow"></div><div class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ AlertMsage-jgAjgo bVCFRm ifgabc iOlxjf alert-msage"><p aria-hidn="te">Lk pied</p></div></div></div><button aria-label="Shop" class="BaseButton-bLlsy ButtonWrapper-xCepQ bqVKKv YsOBB button button--primary-pair RponsiveCartoonInButton-hBCBMq lpsjql" data-event-click="{"element":"Button"}" data-ttid="Button" type="button"><span class="ButtonLabel-cjAuJN bBWXSg button__label">Shop</span><div class="ButtonInWrapper-gFdzAL bPDyTT button__in-ntaer"><svg class="in in-rt" width="24" height="24" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" xmlns="><tle>Shop</tle><g clip-path="url(#clip0_3732_178638)"><path fill-le="evenodd" clip-le="evenodd" d="M4 3H2V4H4.23828L6.99617 15.2631C7.11483 15.6982 7.50998 16 7.96094 16H18.0365C18.4875 16 18.8826 15.6982 19.0013 15.2631L20.9648 7.26312C21.1383 6.62698 20.6594 6 20 6H10V7H20L18.0365 15H7.96094L5.03652 3H4.58055H4ZM10.0365 19C10.0365 19.5523 9.58881 20 9.03652 20C8.48424 20 8.03652 19.5523 8.03652 19C8.03652 18.4477 8.48424 18 9.03652 18C9.58881 18 10.0365 18.4477 10.0365 19ZM11.0365 19C11.0365 20.1046 10.1411 21 9.03652 21C7.93195 21 7.03652 20.1046 7.03652 19C7.03652 17.8954 7.93195 17 9.03652 17C10.1411 17 11.0365 17.8954 11.0365 19ZM18.0365 19C18.0365 19.5523 17.5888 20 17.0365 20C16.4842 20 16.0365 19.5523 16.0365 19C16.0365 18.4477 16.4842 18 17.0365 18C17.5888 18 18.0365 18.4477 18.0365 19ZM19.0365 19C19.0365 20.1046 18.1411 21 17.0365 21C15.932 21 15.0365 20.1046 15.0365 19C15.0365 17.8954 15.932 17 17.0365 17C18.1411 17 19.0365 17.8954 19.0365 19Z" fill="black"></path></g><fs><clipPath id="clip0_3732_178638"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath><clipPath id="clip1_3732_178638"><rect width="24" height="24" fill="whe"></rect></clipPath></fs></svg></div></button></div></div></div></span></div></figure><p class="paywall">Gabbard’s most pronounced polil tenncy—her stct toward bipartisanship—is, Butler says, entirely keepg wh what he teach. But he says that he do not tell her, or any other disciple, how to vote. “That sense of aloha, or love for others, and the sire to work for the well-beg of others—that’s a succsful polician, om a spirual perspective,” he says. “But as far as posns on different issu that e before policians? That is somethg that every dividual has to al wh on their own.”</p><p class="has-dropp has-dropp__lead-standard-headg paywall">When asked about Hduism, Gabbard often talks about anti-Hdu bigotry. One of her prime exampl is Kawika Crowley, her Republin opponent the 2012 electn, who told CNN that he thought Gabbard’s Hduism nflicted wh the Amerin system of ernment. (Crowley, a smokers’-rights activist who lived his mivan, lost the electn by nearly sixty percentage pots.) In an say about her fah that she sent to me, Gabbard pared herself to John F. Kennedy, who sought to reassure voters who were worried by his Catholicism; he promised to discharge the duti of the office “whout regard to outsi relig prsur or dictat.” But there is no simple way to distguish between the relig “dictat” that might make voters nervo and the relig “valu” that policians—particularly Christian policians—so equently pledge to uphold. It would be absurd to expect Gabbard to make polil cisns whout reference to the spirual path that she has walked all her life. After all, her termatn to seek agreement outsi her party is, no small way, a product of that path, and que possibly a ldable one. Gowdy, the South Carola Republin, lik to tell Gabbard that she is “the most Christlike member of Congrs,” a plited sort of pliment that says somethg about the way we try to rencile spirual tradns that are ultimately mensurable.</p><p class="paywall">It is possible, though, to discern somethg more specific than all-purpose aloha the shiftg polil prri of Butler’s followers. In the neteen-eighti, Butler exriated same-sex sire; he wrote, for stance, that bisexualy was “sense gratifitn” n amok, and warned that the logil ncln of such hedonistic nduct was pedophilia and btialy. (He clared, wh strikg certaty, that “an creasg number of women the Uned Stat keep dogs for sexual reasons.”) Reed, Mike Gabbard, and other polil ndidat associated wh him tend to echo the pronouncements. Nowadays, Tulsi Gabbard tak a different view, and Butler seems to have ëmphasized the issue: there is no mentn of homosexualy on the foundatn’s Web se, or his recent teachgs. Gabbard says that she and Butler have discsed same-sex marriage—“perhaps, a while ago.” She says, “It’s somethg that we don’t agree on.”</p><p class="paywall">In recent s, Butler has prented himself ls as a Hare Krishna dissint and more as a member of a loosely nnected worldwi Vaishnava movement. To expla how he fs , Gabbard e-mailed me “The Genealogil Tree of Theistic Vedanta,” which picts dozens of great teachers om across the centuri, most of them Indian; Butler occupi a secure but most place, at the end of a th branch. By fg relatnships wh Modi and other Indian lears, Gabbard has ma herself a proment ambassador of Amerin Hduism, and she may be brgg Butler’s prevly obscure movement closer to the global Hdu mastream. Last year, when the Indian ernment announced the wners of s annual Padma Awards, only two non-Indians were clud. One was a former U.S. Ambassador. The other was Wai Lana.</p><p class="paywall">Gabbard’s relatnship wh India is also a strategic alliance: she has fend Modi’s polil anizatn, the Bharatiya Janata Party, which champns the view that India is—and should rema—an sentially Hdu natn. In 2013, she opposed a rolutn on “relig vlence” India that was seen as a veiled cricism of Modi, and she suggts that, whatever the problems faced by India’s Mlim mory, they n’t pare wh the tribulatns of relig mori many Mlim untri. This summer, she me to New York to participate an Indian-Amerin bs fom. She had the bad luck to appear after Anil Kapoor, the garlo Indian movie star, but she seemed entirely at ease, chattg wh the Indian Ambassador about enomic partnership and secury öperatn. This was Gabbard’s kd of crowd: iendly and relatively nonpartisan. One of the first qutners began by tablishg herself as a mted fan. “Congrswoman, I was really hopg you would get a Cabet posn Tmp’s Admistratn,” she said. “Now I’m hopg for the day when I n vote for you the Printial electn.”</p><p class="paywall">Gabbard sed and shook her head at the suggtn. But, October, she went to Iowa to appear at a Democratic fund-raiser, a sign that she is thkg about the 2020 uc, and that she is one of dozens—or perhaps hundreds—of Democratic policians who thk they have a chance to be elected Print. For now, she is on the list of possible ndidat, though not the short list; her relatively nciliatory attu toward Tmp seems to have dimished her profile among the kd of Democrats who start thkg about primary ntts three years advance. But if Gabbard jos the field she will almost certaly be the most tertg ndidate . One qutn is whether her life story will turn out to be too tertg—too unual—for her own good.</p></div></div></div><div class="GridItem-buujkM fVLMby grid--em grid-layout__asi"><div class="StickyBoxWrapper-jfYB jxBcTH sticky-box"><div class="StickyBoxPrimary-dzWDWL cdhYoN sticky-box__primary"></div><div class="StickyBoxPlaceholr-grPmrg dxAvXx"></div></div></div></div><div class="RowWrapper-UmqTg HEhan full-bleed-ad row-mid-ntent-ad"><div class="StickyMidContentAdWrapper-fSBzwl drzyIa ad-stickymidntent"><div class="AdWrapper-dQtivb fZrssQ ad ad--mid-ntent should-hold-space"><div class="ad__slot ad__slot--mid-ntent" data-no-id="k466rh"></div></div></div></div><div class="GridWrapper-cAzTTK kHBDeH grid grid-margs grid-ems-2 ArticlePageChunksGrid-hfxa bjczjj grid-layout--adrail narrow wi-adrail"><div class="GridItem-buujkM stRKV grid--em grid-layout__ntent"><div class="BodyWrapper-kufPGa EOneK body body__ntaer article__body" data-journey-hook="client-ntent" data-ttid="BodyWrapper"><div class="body__ner-ntaer"><p class="paywall">Former discipl of Butler tend to be extraordarily bter about the time they spent spirual service to him, and extraordarily spic of his motiv. This spicn extends to some of the people who have supported Gabbard but fd themselv troubled by the ambiguo role that Butler and his followers have played Hawaiian polics. Ne years ago, another promisg polician had to figure out what to do about a spirual lear who beme a mag for cricism: as a ndidate, Barack Obama fend his pastor, the Reverend Jeremiah Wright, until, fally, he abandoned him. But Wright reprented only a small slice of Obama’s life, whereas Gabbard’s life would be unregnizable whout Butler’s fluence. Des ago, her father tried, wh some succs, to make mon e wh Mormons, evangelils, and other people of fah who shared his opposn to same-sex marriage. His dghter is far more polilly skilled, but her task is also far more difficult: she mt fd a way to make mon e wh a Democratic Party that is creasgly secular and creasgly partisan.</p><div data-attr-viewport-monor="le-recirc" class="le-recirc-wrapper le-recirc-observer-target-6 viewport-monor-anchor"></div><p class="paywall">Gabbard don’t seem too trated by the stalled progrs of her signature bill, the Stop Armg Terrorists Act; polil terms, may be more effective as a blocked bill—a symbol of the transigence she wants to battle—than as an enacted law. And although she remas relatively reluctant to cricize the Print, or even to mentn his name, she has found plenty of chanc this year to voice her disagreement wh “the Admistratn.” Still, the current climate Gabbard is aware that Democratic voters are drawn to policians who seem to be leadg the ristance to Tmp and the Republins, rather than searchg for ways to work wh them. Many of her supporters believe that, eventually, the mood will change. “At some pot,” Van Jon says, “the untry’s gog to be tired of people whose only qualifitn is that they hate the other si.”</p><p class="paywall">Gabbard, more than most policians, is a celebry. (At the airport Kai, she was stopped by a T.S.A. agent, who wanted a photograph wh her. “This is my perfect week,” he said. “My son got married—and I get to meet you!”) And she has one of the most important quali a polician n have: an unnny abily to make people believe her, even if they don’t agree wh her. One of her longtime fans on Oahu is Lda Wong, who hosted fund-raisers durg Gabbard’s first ngrsnal mpaign, and who has grown ed to fieldg qutns about her var acts of polil subordatn. “She mak a move, but then I get the phone lls: ‘What is she dog?’ ” Wong says. “I say, ‘I don’t know what she’s dog, but I know she’s thought through.’ ”</p><p class="paywall">Dependg on the day, and the mood of the untry, Gabbard’s stubbornly personal approach to polics n seem eher rehg or disfg. When she talks about her passn for “service,” she is speakg the language of polics and the ary and fah all at once. She is talkg about her termatn, which is obv, and her aims, which aren’t, always. “She’s got a servant attu, a servant’s heart,” Butler says. “Whether she’s polics or anythg else, she’s gog to take that same servant’s heart wh her.” ♦</p></div></div></div><div class="GridItem-buujkM fVLMby grid--em grid-layout__asi"><div class="StickyBoxWrapper-jfYB jxBcTH sticky-box"><div class="StickyBoxPrimary-dzWDWL cdhYoN sticky-box__primary"><div class="AdWrapper-dQtivb fZrssQ ad ad--rail"><div class="ad__slot ad__slot--rail" data-no-id="d9hpsi"></div></div><div class="ConsumerMarketgUnThemedWrapper-iUTMTf jssHut nsumer-marketg-un nsumer-marketg-un--display-rail" role="prentatn" aria-hidn="te"><div class="nsumer-marketg-un__slot nsumer-marketg-un__slot--display-rail"></div><div class="journey-un"></div></div></div><div class="StickyBoxPlaceholr-grPmrg dxAvXx"></div></div></div></div></div><div class="GridWrapper-cAzTTK kHBDeH grid grid-margs grid-ems-2 PaywallInleBarrierWhWrapperGrid-fyrGfS kLQIUk grid-layout--adrail narrow wi-adrail"><div class="GridItem-buujkM stRKV grid--em grid-layout__ntent"><div class="body body__le-barrier article__body"><div class="ntaer ntaer--body"><div class="ntaer--body-ner"><asi class="PaywallInleBarrierWrapper-iBnuqk lfXXa-D" data-ttid="PaywallInleBarrierWrapper"><div class="ConsumerMarketgUnThemedWrapper-iUTMTf jssHut nsumer-marketg-un nsumer-marketg-un--paywall-le-barrier" role="prentatn" aria-live="pole" aria-hidn="te"><div class="nsumer-marketg-un__slot nsumer-marketg-un__slot--paywall-le-barrier"></div><div class="journey-un"></div></div></asi></div></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="GridWrapper-cAzTTK kHBDeH grid grid-margs grid-ems-2 ContentWrapperGrid-fvkmBv brYtrA grid-layout--adrail narrow wi-adrail"><div class="GridItem-buujkM stRKV grid--em grid-layout__ntent"><div class="body body__ntaer"><div class="ntaer ntaer--body"><div class="ntaer--body-ner"></div></div></div></div></div></div></article><div class="ContentFooterWrapper-jVNdRG dTJkpP ArticlePageContentFooterGrid-ccsXYy eMZRHU article-body__footer"><div class="GridWrapper-cAzTTK kHBDeH grid grid-margs grid-ems-2 grid-layout--adrail narrow wi-adrail"><div class="GridItem-buujkM stRKV grid--em grid-layout__ntent"><footer class="ContentFooterMagazeDisclaimer-gzKAqo iZIuUU" data-ttid="MagazeDisclaimerWrapper">Published the prt edn of the <a href="/magaze/2017/11/06" data-reactroot="">November 6, 2017</a>, issue, wh the headle “Agast the Ti.”</footer></div></div><div class="RowWrapper-UmqTg HEhan"><div class="GridWrapper-cAzTTK kHBDeH grid grid-margs grid-ems-2 grid-layout--adrail narrow wi-adrail"><div class="GridItem-buujkM stRKV grid--em grid-layout__ntent"></div></div></div><div class="RowWrapper-UmqTg HEhan"><div class="GridWrapper-cAzTTK kHBDeH grid grid-margs grid-ems-2 grid-layout--adrail narrow wi-adrail"><div class="GridItem-buujkM stRKV grid--em grid-layout__ntent"><div class="ContributorsWrapper-eNpWFu GWFsc ntributors" data-ttid="Contributors"><div class="ContributorBWrapper-bnVHbt gMon"><div class="ContributorBAvatar-bIGTqf eMWbvj"><a href="/ntributors/kelefa-sanneh"><span class="SpanWrapper-umhxW jvZaPI rponsive-asset"><picture class="RponsiveImagePicture-cWuUZO dUOtEa rponsive-image"><source media="(max-width: 767px)" srcSet=" 120w, 240w" siz="100vw"/><source media="(m-width: 768px)" srcSet=" 120w, 240w" siz="100vw"/><img alt="" class="RponsiveImageContaer-eybHBd fptoWY rponsive-image__image" src="></picture></span></a></div><div class="ContributorBContent-ubQdr jZTSSi"><div class="ContributorBHear-ledood XOIEx"></div><div class="ContributorBB-fBolsO giFhKz"><a href="/ntributors/kelefa-sanneh">Kelefa Sanneh</a> has been a staff wrer at The New Yorker sce 2008. He is the thor of “<a href=">Major Labels: A History of Popular Mic Seven Genr</a>.”</div><div class="ContributorBFooter-brqDlv ezUmSv"></div></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="RowWrapper-UmqTg HEhan"><div class="GridWrapper-cAzTTK kHBDeH grid grid-margs grid-ems-2 grid-layout--adrail narrow wi-adrail"><div class="GridItem-buujkM stRKV grid--em grid-layout__ntent"><div data-ttid="TagCloudWrapper" class="TagCloudWrapper-gGgndx ctyZyK ContentFooterTagCloud-krQmRG ZLGh"><span class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ TagCloudSectnHear-cOforY iUEiRd bPyAoD kQQRmu">More:</span><a href="/tag/tulsi-gabbard" class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ BaseLk-eNWuiM TagCloudLk-kvjZFu iUEiRd ggMZaT gFob hIhJOI"><span class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ TagCloudName-eAUnLd iUEiRd gwIVBQ bUkXwu">Tulsi Gabbard</span></a><a href="/tag/hawaii" class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ BaseLk-eNWuiM TagCloudLk-kvjZFu iUEiRd ggMZaT gFob hIhJOI"><span class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ TagCloudName-eAUnLd iUEiRd gwIVBQ bUkXwu">Hawaii</span></a><a href="/tag/policians" class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ BaseLk-eNWuiM TagCloudLk-kvjZFu iUEiRd ggMZaT gFob hIhJOI"><span class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ TagCloudName-eAUnLd iUEiRd gwIVBQ bUkXwu">Policians</span></a><a href="/tag/-ngrs" class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ BaseLk-eNWuiM TagCloudLk-kvjZFu iUEiRd ggMZaT gFob hIhJOI"><span class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ TagCloudName-eAUnLd iUEiRd gwIVBQ bUkXwu">U.S. Congrs</span></a><a href="/tag/mocrats" class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ BaseLk-eNWuiM TagCloudLk-kvjZFu iUEiRd ggMZaT gFob hIhJOI"><span class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ TagCloudName-eAUnLd iUEiRd gwIVBQ bUkXwu">Democrats</span></a></div></div></div></div><div data-ttid="ContentFooterBottom" class="ContentFooterBottom-jwWZfC kcbyiW"><div class="ContentFooterNewsletterContentWrapper-bmjtna kixtae"><div class="GridWrapper-cAzTTK kHBDeH grid grid-margs grid-ems-2 grid-layout--adrail narrow wi-adrail"><div class="GridItem-buujkM stRKV grid--em grid-layout__ntent"><div data-ttid="NewsletterSubscribeFormWrapper" class="NewsletterSubscribeFormWrapper-fCqqkN jKSBhE newsletter-subscribe-form ContentFooterNewsletterForm-hKeYwa liPqcf"><div data-ttid="NewsletterSubscribeFormHedDekWrapper" class="NewsletterSubscribeFormHedDekWrapper-fpMElW eglIBL"><h3 class="NewsletterSubscribeFormDangeroHed-kRwWjt feDzQf newsletter-subscribe-form__hed ContentFooterNewsletterForm-hKeYwa liPqcf">Weekly</h3><div class="NewsletterSubscribeFormDek-kXonvc grEaES newsletter-subscribe-form__k">Your gui to the latt magaze and our biggt stori of the week, pl highlights om podsts, humor, and more.</div></div><div data-ttid="NewsletterSubscribeFormInputsWrapper" class="NewsletterSubscribeFormInputsWrapper-keARJE hVWbzr"><form class="form-wh-validatn NewsletterSubscribeFormValidatn-iCYa-Dt dweEln" id="newsletter" name="newsletter" novalidate="" method="POST"><span class="TextFieldWrapper-Pzdqp hNhevp text-field" data-ttid="TextFieldWrapper__email"><label class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ TextFieldLabel-klrYvg iUEiRd stdEm fvoOvz text-field__label text-field__label--sgle-le" for="newsletter-text-field-email" data-ttid="TextFieldLabel__email"><div class="TextFieldLabelText-cvvxBl eeDYTb">E-mail addrs</div><div class="TextFieldInputContaer-jcMPhb oFrOs"><put type="email" aria-scribedby="privacy-text" aria-valid="false" id="newsletter-text-field-email" required="" name="email" placeholr="E-mail addrs" class="BaseInput-fAzTdK TextFieldControlInput-eFUxkf eGzzTT lglhcT text-field__ntrol text-field__ntrol--put" data-ttid="TextFieldInput__email"/></div></label><button class="BaseButton-bLlsy ButtonWrapper-xCepQ bqVKKv dwpimO button button--utily TextFieldButton-csBrgY edxbrw" data-event-click="{"element":"Button"}" data-ttid="Button" type="subm"><span class="ButtonLabel-cjAuJN hzwRuG button__label">Sign up</span></button></span><div id="privacy-text" tabx="-1" class="NewsletterSubscribeFormDisclaimer-bTVtiV bsgLJZ"><span><p>By signg up, you agree to our <a href=" rel="nofollow noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">User Agreement</a> and <a href=" rel="nofollow noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">Privacy Policy & Cookie Statement</a>. This se is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google<a href=" rel="nofollow noopener noreferrer" target="_blank"> Privacy Policy</a> and<a href=" rel="nofollow noopener noreferrer" target="_blank"> Terms of Service</a> apply.</p></span></div></form></div></div></div></div></div><div class="ntent-bottom-anchor"></div><div class="ConsumerMarketgUnThemedWrapper-iUTMTf jssHut nsumer-marketg-un nsumer-marketg-un--article-footer" role="prentatn" aria-hidn="te"><div class="nsumer-marketg-un__slot nsumer-marketg-un__slot--article-footer"></div><div class="journey-un"></div></div><div data-attr-viewport-monor="" class="recirc-list-wrapper viewport-monor-anchor"><div class="RowWrapper-UmqTg HEhan ContentFooterRelated-kEBiFe kVUuwq"><div class="GridWrapper-cAzTTK eRggVV grid grid-margs grid-ems-0 SummaryCollectnGridComponent-ktyEog bdTTVU summary-llectn-grid RecircListDefltOverlaySummaryCollectnGrid-AHJhY bEaXiL recirc-list__ems summary-llectn-grid--four-lumns summary-llectn-grid--TextBelowLeft"><div class="GridItem-buujkM kHPPIF grid--em"><div class="SummaryCollectnGridContent-eVUpRm jTGbEO"><div class="SectnTleRoot-dBGvdq hpRFVl SummaryCollectnGridSectnTle-fCmYwG izjbVn" data-ttid="SectnTle"><hear class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ SectnTleHed-dKqZet dxqEAa jfOfxc jttyjJ">Read More</hear></div><div class="SummaryCollectnGridItems-DZShR jBCYOL hi-read-more-ad" data-ttid="SummaryCollectnGridItems"><div class="SummaryItemWrapper-iwvBff hNpSyX summary-em summary-em--article summary-em--no-in summary-em--text-align-left summary-em--layout-placement-text-below summary-em--layout-posn-image-left summary-em--layout-proportns-50-50 summary-em--si-by-si-align-center summary-em--si-by-si-image-right-mobile-false summary-em--standard SummaryCollectnGridSummaryItem-WColm hKqhyj" role="button" tabx="0"><div class="SummaryItemAssetContaer-gwhFFH VOyg summary-em__asset-ntaer"><a class="SummaryItemImageLk-dshqxb cPpCwE summary-em__image-lk summary-em-trackg__image-lk" href="/magaze/2012/09/17/the-profsor-jefey-toob" aria-hidn="te" tabx="-1" data-ponent-type="recirc-river" data-recirc-id="em-image-1" data-recirc-pattern="summary-em" target="_self"><span class="SpanWrapper-umhxW kGxnNB rponsive-asset SummaryItemRponsiveAsset-hjGIGg bDvSkO summary-em__image"><div data-tt="aspect-rat-ntaer" class="AspectRatContaer-bJHpJz ktcjQn"><div class="aspect-rat--overlay-ntaer"><picture class="RponsiveImagePicture-cWuUZO dUOtEa SummaryItemRponsiveAsset-hjGIGg bDvSkO summary-em__image rponsive-image"><noscript><source media="(max-width: 767px)" srcSet=" 120w, 240w, 320w, 640w" siz="100vw"/><source media="(m-width: 768px)" srcSet=" 120w, 240w, 320w" siz="100vw"/><img alt="The Profsor" class="RponsiveImageContaer-eybHBd fptoWY rponsive-image__image" src="></noscript></picture></div></div></span></a></div><div class="SummaryItemContent-eiDYMl XMZX summary-em__ntent"><div class="RubricWrapper-dKmCNX kImuKS bric bric--disvery SummaryItemRubric-dguGKN lapGFj summary-em__bric"><span class="RubricName-fVtemz cLxcNi">Profil</span></div><a class="SummaryItemHedLk-civM dVrbhU summary-em-trackg__hed-lk summary-em__hed-lk" data-ponent-type="recirc-river" data-recirc-id="em-hed-1" data-recirc-pattern="summary-em" href="/magaze/2012/09/17/the-profsor-jefey-toob" target="_self"><div class="SummaryItemHedBase-hiFYpQ fzzTdh summary-em__hed" data-ttid="SummaryItemHed">The Profsor</div></a><div class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ SummaryItemDek-CRfsi iUEiRd kxnNhB jDyfzW summary-em__k">Elizabeth Warren’s long journey to polics.</div><div class="SummaryItemByleWrapper-boCfbi cuRXdL summary-em__byle-date-in"><div class="SummaryItemBaseByle-fFbXkY cgDBtc summary-em__byle"><div class="summary-em__byle__ntent"><div data-ttid="BylWrapper" class="BylWrapper-KIudk irTIfE byl"><p class="ByleWrapper-jWHrLH dSEWiO byle byl__byle" data-ttid="ByleWrapper" emProp="thor" emType="><span emProp="name" class="ByleNamWrapper-jbHncj fuDQVo"><span data-ttid="ByleName" class="ByleName-kwmrLn cYaBaU byle__name"><span class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ BylePreamble-iJolpQ iUEiRd jslZfG gnILss byle__preamble">By </span>Jefey Toob</span></span></p></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="SummaryItemWrapper-iwvBff hNpSyX summary-em summary-em--article summary-em--no-in summary-em--text-align-left summary-em--layout-placement-text-below summary-em--layout-posn-image-left summary-em--layout-proportns-50-50 summary-em--si-by-si-align-center summary-em--si-by-si-image-right-mobile-false summary-em--standard SummaryCollectnGridSummaryItem-WColm hKqhyj" role="button" tabx="0"><div class="SummaryItemAssetContaer-gwhFFH VOyg summary-em__asset-ntaer"><a class="SummaryItemImageLk-dshqxb cPpCwE summary-em__image-lk summary-em-trackg__image-lk" href="/magaze/1928/10/27/that-was-new-york" aria-hidn="te" tabx="-1" data-ponent-type="recirc-river" data-recirc-id="em-image-2" data-recirc-pattern="summary-em" target="_self"><span class="SpanWrapper-umhxW kGxnNB rponsive-asset SummaryItemRponsiveAsset-hjGIGg bDvSkO summary-em__image"><div data-tt="aspect-rat-ntaer" class="AspectRatContaer-bJHpJz ktcjQn"><div class="aspect-rat--overlay-ntaer"><picture class="RponsiveImagePicture-cWuUZO dUOtEa SummaryItemRponsiveAsset-hjGIGg bDvSkO summary-em__image rponsive-image"><noscript><source media="(max-width: 767px)" srcSet=" 120w, 240w, 320w, 640w" siz="100vw"/><source media="(m-width: 768px)" srcSet=" 120w, 240w, 320w" siz="100vw"/><img alt="Victoria Woodhull’s Campaign" class="RponsiveImageContaer-eybHBd fptoWY rponsive-image__image" src="></noscript></picture></div></div></span></a></div><div class="SummaryItemContent-eiDYMl XMZX summary-em__ntent"><div class="RubricWrapper-dKmCNX kImuKS bric bric--disvery SummaryItemRubric-dguGKN lapGFj summary-em__bric"><span class="RubricName-fVtemz cLxcNi">That Was New York</span></div><a class="SummaryItemHedLk-civM dVrbhU summary-em-trackg__hed-lk summary-em__hed-lk" data-ponent-type="recirc-river" data-recirc-id="em-hed-2" data-recirc-pattern="summary-em" href="/magaze/1928/10/27/that-was-new-york" target="_self"><div class="SummaryItemHedBase-hiFYpQ fzzTdh summary-em__hed" data-ttid="SummaryItemHed">Victoria Woodhull’s Campaign</div></a><div class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ SummaryItemDek-CRfsi iUEiRd kxnNhB jDyfzW summary-em__k">The story of Ameri’s first female Printial ndidate.</div><div class="SummaryItemByleWrapper-boCfbi cuRXdL summary-em__byle-date-in"><div class="SummaryItemBaseByle-fFbXkY cgDBtc summary-em__byle"><div class="summary-em__byle__ntent"><div data-ttid="BylWrapper" class="BylWrapper-KIudk irTIfE byl"><p class="ByleWrapper-jWHrLH dSEWiO byle byl__byle" data-ttid="ByleWrapper" emProp="thor" emType="><span emProp="name" class="ByleNamWrapper-jbHncj fuDQVo"><span data-ttid="ByleName" class="ByleName-kwmrLn cYaBaU byle__name"><span class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ BylePreamble-iJolpQ iUEiRd jslZfG gnILss byle__preamble">By </span>Rsel Croe</span></span></p></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="SummaryItemWrapper-iwvBff hNpSyX summary-em summary-em--article summary-em--no-in summary-em--text-align-left summary-em--layout-placement-text-below summary-em--layout-posn-image-left summary-em--layout-proportns-50-50 summary-em--si-by-si-align-center summary-em--si-by-si-image-right-mobile-false summary-em--standard SummaryCollectnGridSummaryItem-WColm hKqhyj" role="button" tabx="0"><div class="SummaryItemAssetContaer-gwhFFH VOyg summary-em__asset-ntaer"><a class="SummaryItemImageLk-dshqxb cPpCwE summary-em__image-lk summary-em-trackg__image-lk" href="/news/news-sk/n-tulsi-gabbard-swg-hawaiian-voters-to-sanrs" aria-hidn="te" tabx="-1" data-ponent-type="recirc-river" data-recirc-id="em-image-3" data-recirc-pattern="summary-em" target="_self"><span class="SpanWrapper-umhxW kGxnNB rponsive-asset SummaryItemRponsiveAsset-hjGIGg bDvSkO summary-em__image"><div data-tt="aspect-rat-ntaer" class="AspectRatContaer-bJHpJz ktcjQn"><div class="aspect-rat--overlay-ntaer"><picture class="RponsiveImagePicture-cWuUZO dUOtEa SummaryItemRponsiveAsset-hjGIGg bDvSkO summary-em__image rponsive-image"><noscript><source media="(max-width: 767px)" srcSet=" 120w, 240w, 320w, 640w" siz="100vw"/><source media="(m-width: 768px)" srcSet=" 120w, 240w, 320w" siz="100vw"/><img alt="Can Tulsi Gabbard Swg Hawaiian Voters to Sanrs?" class="RponsiveImageContaer-eybHBd fptoWY rponsive-image__image" src="></noscript></picture></div></div></span></a></div><div class="SummaryItemContent-eiDYMl XMZX summary-em__ntent"><div class="RubricWrapper-dKmCNX kImuKS bric bric--disvery SummaryItemRubric-dguGKN lapGFj summary-em__bric"><span class="RubricName-fVtemz cLxcNi">News Dk</span></div><a class="SummaryItemHedLk-civM dVrbhU summary-em-trackg__hed-lk summary-em__hed-lk" data-ponent-type="recirc-river" data-recirc-id="em-hed-3" data-recirc-pattern="summary-em" href="/news/news-sk/n-tulsi-gabbard-swg-hawaiian-voters-to-sanrs" target="_self"><div class="SummaryItemHedBase-hiFYpQ fzzTdh summary-em__hed" data-ttid="SummaryItemHed">Can Tulsi Gabbard Swg Hawaiian Voters to Sanrs?</div></a><div class="SummaryItemByleWrapper-boCfbi cuRXdL summary-em__byle-date-in"><div class="SummaryItemBaseByle-fFbXkY cgDBtc summary-em__byle"><div class="summary-em__byle__ntent"><div data-ttid="BylWrapper" class="BylWrapper-KIudk irTIfE byl"><p class="ByleWrapper-jWHrLH dSEWiO byle byl__byle" data-ttid="ByleWrapper" emProp="thor" emType="><span emProp="name" class="ByleNamWrapper-jbHncj fuDQVo"><span data-ttid="ByleName" class="ByleName-kwmrLn cYaBaU byle__name"><span class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ BylePreamble-iJolpQ iUEiRd jslZfG gnILss byle__preamble">By </span>Sara Davidson</span></span></p></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="SummaryItemWrapper-iwvBff hNpSyX summary-em summary-em--article summary-em--no-in summary-em--text-align-left summary-em--layout-placement-text-below summary-em--layout-posn-image-left summary-em--layout-proportns-50-50 summary-em--si-by-si-align-center summary-em--si-by-si-image-right-mobile-false summary-em--standard SummaryCollectnGridSummaryItem-WColm hKqhyj" role="button" tabx="0"><div class="SummaryItemAssetContaer-gwhFFH VOyg summary-em__asset-ntaer"><a class="SummaryItemImageLk-dshqxb cPpCwE summary-em__image-lk summary-em-trackg__image-lk" href="/magaze/2016/11/07/hd-for-tmp" aria-hidn="te" tabx="-1" data-ponent-type="recirc-river" data-recirc-id="em-image-4" data-recirc-pattern="summary-em" target="_self"><span class="SpanWrapper-umhxW kGxnNB rponsive-asset SummaryItemRponsiveAsset-hjGIGg bDvSkO summary-em__image"><div data-tt="aspect-rat-ntaer" class="AspectRatContaer-bJHpJz ktcjQn"><div class="aspect-rat--overlay-ntaer"><picture class="RponsiveImagePicture-cWuUZO dUOtEa SummaryItemRponsiveAsset-hjGIGg bDvSkO summary-em__image rponsive-image"><noscript><source media="(max-width: 767px)" srcSet=" 120w, 240w, 320w, 640w" siz="100vw"/><source media="(m-width: 768px)" srcSet=" 120w, 240w, 320w" siz="100vw"/><img alt="Hd for Tmp" class="RponsiveImageContaer-eybHBd fptoWY rponsive-image__image" src="></noscript></picture></div></div></span></a></div><div class="SummaryItemContent-eiDYMl XMZX summary-em__ntent"><div class="RubricWrapper-dKmCNX kImuKS bric bric--disvery SummaryItemRubric-dguGKN lapGFj summary-em__bric"><span class="RubricName-fVtemz cLxcNi">Bedfellows Dept.</span></div><a class="SummaryItemHedLk-civM dVrbhU summary-em-trackg__hed-lk summary-em__hed-lk" data-ponent-type="recirc-river" data-recirc-id="em-hed-4" data-recirc-pattern="summary-em" href="/magaze/2016/11/07/hd-for-tmp" target="_self"><div class="SummaryItemHedBase-hiFYpQ fzzTdh summary-em__hed" data-ttid="SummaryItemHed">Hd for Tmp</div></a><div class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ SummaryItemDek-CRfsi iUEiRd kxnNhB jDyfzW summary-em__k">The ndidate spoke and Indian movie stars performed at an event to raise money for victims of terrorism.</div><div class="SummaryItemByleWrapper-boCfbi cuRXdL summary-em__byle-date-in"><div class="SummaryItemBaseByle-fFbXkY cgDBtc summary-em__byle"><div class="summary-em__byle__ntent"><div data-ttid="BylWrapper" class="BylWrapper-KIudk irTIfE byl"><p class="ByleWrapper-jWHrLH dSEWiO byle byl__byle" data-ttid="ByleWrapper" emProp="thor" emType="><span emProp="name" class="ByleNamWrapper-jbHncj fuDQVo"><span data-ttid="ByleName" class="ByleName-kwmrLn cYaBaU byle__name"><span class="BaseWrap-sc-gjQpdd BaseText-ewhhUZ BylePreamble-iJolpQ iUEiRd jslZfG gnILss byle__preamble">By </span>Roza Ali</span></span></p></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="AdWrapper-dQtivb fZrssQ SummaryCollectnGridSummaryItem-WColm hKqhyj ad ad--read-more"><div class="ad__slot ad__slot--read-more" data-no-id="jmnwv"></div></div></div><div class="SummaryCollectnGridToActnWrapper-gnReGN eGayfk"></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="RowWrapper-UmqTg HEhan"><div class="TaboolaWrapper-hMVdpE iYfBhy"><div class="TaboolaWidgetWrapper-egPIjc hkSrgt TaboolaWidget-eUSdED hQCCRa" data-ttid="TaboolaWidgetWrapper"><div class="TaboolaWidgetContent-iBEQTO eXroXG TABOOLA" id="taboola-below-article-thumbnails---f" data-ttid="TaboolaWidgetContent"></div></div></div></div><div class="RowWrapper-UmqTg HEhan"><div class="AdWrapper-dQtivb fZrssQ ad ad--footer should-hold-space"><div class="ad__slot ad__slot--footer" data-no-id="bk2xfs"></div></div></div></div></div></ma><div class="BasePageMaFooterFiller-hTlZph jSriYf page__ma-footer-filler"></div><div class="RowWrapper-UmqTg HEhan"><div class="ConsumerMarketgUnThemedWrapper-iUTMTf jssHut nsumer-marketg-un nsumer-marketg-un--cm-footer" role="prentatn" aria-hidn="te"><div class="nsumer-marketg-un__slot nsumer-marketg-un__slot--cm-footer"></div><div class="journey-un"></div></div></div><div class="RowWrapper-UmqTg HEhan BasePageSeFooterRow-kpEBGH rjBtU"><div class="GridWrapper-cAzTTK eRggVV grid grid-margs grid-ems-0 BasePageSeFooterRowGrid-iBGjXL zQNeb"><div class="GridItem-buujkM kHPPIF grid--em"><footer class="SeFooterWrapper-bXjkRY gKJGws se-footer--wh-store"><div class="SeFooterGridNoMargs-jSrXSj cQgGDp" data-ttid="SeFooterGridNoMargs"><div class="SeFooterBrandInfo-cdoqKy cdkwFG"><div class="SeFooterLogo-eYlNHY eigdAF se-footer__logo"><a href="/"><span class="SpanWrapper-umhxW jvZaPI rponsive-asset SeFooterLogoRponsiveAsset-ckjzWk kubVDn se-footer__rponsive-image"><picture class="RponsiveImagePicture-cWuUZO dUOtEa SeFooterLogoRponsiveAsset-ckjzWk kubVDn se-footer__rponsive-image rponsive-image"><img alt="The New Yorker" class="RponsiveImageContaer-eybHBd fptoWY rponsive-image__image" src="/verso/static/the-new-yorker/assets/" srcSet="" siz="100vw"/></picture></span></a></div></div><nav aria-label="Sectns" class="NavigatnWrapper-bFftAs fKSZRK SeFooterNavigatnVertil-eawNCf hgahMe" data-ttid="navigatn"><p data-ttid="navigatn__headg" class="NavigatnHeadgWrapper-befTuI kSFYXD navigatn__headg"><button data-ttid="navigatn__headg-button" type="button" aria-expand="false" class="NavigatnHeadgButton-eDVixB fiYwDK">Sectns<span data-ttid="navigatn__headg-arrow" class="NavigatnHeadgArrow-iJeTMa gGaHQm"></span></button></p><ul class="NavigatnListWrapper-gWXLVS fSEziN navigatn__list" data-ttid="navigatn__list"><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD JsNkg navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/news" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">News</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD JsNkg navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/culture" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Books & Culture</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD JsNkg navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/fictn-and-poetry" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Fictn & Poetry</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD JsNkg navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/humor" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Humor & Cartoons</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD JsNkg navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/magaze" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Magaze</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD JsNkg navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/crossword-puzzl-and-gam" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Crossword</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD JsNkg navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href=" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Vio</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD JsNkg navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/podst" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Podsts</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD JsNkg navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/archive" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Archive</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD JsNkg navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/gogs-on-about-town" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Gogs On</a></li></ul></nav><span class="NavigatnDivir-fEDnwq ixXXMs navigatn__divir"></span><nav aria-label="More" class="NavigatnWrapper-bFftAs fKSZRK SeFooterNavigatnContactVertil-kReQvb ejvbAv" data-ttid="navigatn"><p data-ttid="navigatn__headg" class="NavigatnHeadgWrapper-befTuI kSFYXD navigatn__headg"><button data-ttid="navigatn__headg-button" type="button" aria-expand="false" class="NavigatnHeadgButton-eDVixB fiYwDK">More<span data-ttid="navigatn__headg-arrow" class="NavigatnHeadgArrow-iJeTMa gGaHQm"></span></button></p><ul class="NavigatnListWrapper-gWXLVS fSEziN navigatn__list" data-ttid="navigatn__list"><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD JsNkg navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href=" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Ctomer Care</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD JsNkg navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href=" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Shop The New Yorker</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD JsNkg navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href=" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Buy Covers and Cartoons</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD JsNkg navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href=" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Condé Nast Store</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD JsNkg navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/digal-edns" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Digal Accs</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD JsNkg navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/newsletter" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Newsletters</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD JsNkg navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/jigsaw" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Jigsaw Puzzle</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD JsNkg navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/about/feeds" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">RSS</a></li></ul></nav><span class="NavigatnDivir-fEDnwq ixXXMs navigatn__divir"></span><div class="SeFooterNoticWrapper-gbuTHd kdRVhS"><div class="SeFooterNoticContaerWrapper-cQMYXm jYCnSe"><nav aria-label="Notic" class="NavigatnWrapper-bFftAs fKSZRK SeFooterNavigatnHorizontal-cWLRMH eTQAIE" data-ttid="navigatn"><ul class="NavigatnListWrapper-gWXLVS dnLcIy navigatn__list" data-ttid="navigatn__list"><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD dsgTQs navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/about/" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">About</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD dsgTQs navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/about/reers" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Careers</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD dsgTQs navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/about/ntact" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Contact</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD dsgTQs navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/about/faq" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">F.A.Q.</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD dsgTQs navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href=" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Media K</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD dsgTQs navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/about/prs" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" role="lk">Prs</a></li><li class="NavigatnListItemWrapper-cxLZKD dsgTQs navigatn__list-em" data-ttid="navigatn__list-em"><a class="NavigatnInternalLk-cWEaeo knabMb navigatn__lk" href="/about/accsibily-help" data-ttid="navigatn__ternal-lk" rel="nofollow" role="lk">Accsibily Help</a></li></ul></nav><span class="NavigatnDivir-fEDnwq ixXXMs navigatn__divir"></span><p data-ttid="dangero-legale-brand-text" class="SeFooterLegaleText-bquxSW eUChdN">© 2023 Condé Nast. All rights rerved. Use of this se nstut acceptance of our <a class="external-lk" data-event-click="{"element":"ExternalLk","outgogURL":"" href=" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">User Agreement</a> and <a class="external-lk" data-event-click="{"element":"ExternalLk","outgogURL":"" href=" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement</a> and <a class="external-lk" data-event-click="{"element":"ExternalLk","outgogURL":"" href=" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">Your California Privacy Rights.</a> <em>The New Yorker</em> may earn a portn of sal om products that are purchased through our se as part of our Affiliate Partnerships wh retailers. The material on this se may not be reproduced, distributed, transmted, ched or otherwise ed, except wh the prr wrten permissn of Condé Nast. <a class="external-lk" data-event-click="{"element":"ExternalLk","outgogURL":"" href=" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">Ad Choic</a></p><div class="SeFooterCollectnContaer-iKPzYu cUTUWM"></div><div class="SocialInsWrapper-hKMEXV hwdgCG social-ins social-ins--footer SeFooterSocialIns-cLAKVY cPpkaJ"><ul data-ttid="socialInslist" class="SocialInsList-cHVTIA gBoIvv social-ins__list"><li class="SocialInsListItem-mbhR izQXJd social-ins__list-em social-ins__list-em--facebook social-ins__list-em--footer thner"><a aria-label="Follow on Facebook" class="external-lk SocialInExternalLk-huuzOU kupRzT social-ins__lk social-ins__lk--facebook" data-event-click="{"element":"ExternalLk","outgogURL":"" href=" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank"><div class="SocialInContaer-huXzUC pMzVC social-ins__in-ntaer"><svg class="SocialInNetworkInComponent-cZaKGz dlOAhZ in in-facebook" focable="false" width="7.2" height="16" viewBox="0 0 7.2 16" xmlns="><tle>Facebook .

TOP

Tulsi Gabbard, 2020 Democratic ndidate, apologiz for past anti-gay ments | Fox News

Recent Posts

Tags

Contents:

TULSI GABBARD ONCE TOUTED WORKG FOR ANTI-GAY GROUP THAT BACKED NVERSN THERAPY

TULSI GABBARD, 2020 DEMOCRATIC NDIDATE, APOLOGIZ FOR PAST ANTI-GAY MENTS

TULSI GABBARD, DEMOCRATIC PRINTIAL CANDIDATE, APOLOGIZ FOR ANTI-GAY PAST

GAY LAWMAKER SUMS UP WHAT EVERYONE IS THKG ABOUT TULSI GABBARD JT 6 WORDS

BEAR-MAGAZINE.COM TULSI GABBARD GAY MARRIAGE

Tulsi Gabbard, 2020 Democratic ndidate, apologiz for past anti-gay ments | Fox News

Recent Posts

Tags

Contents:

TULSI GABBARD ONCE TOUTED WORKG FOR ANTI-GAY GROUP THAT BACKED NVERSN THERAPY

TULSI GABBARD, 2020 DEMOCRATIC NDIDATE, APOLOGIZ FOR PAST ANTI-GAY MENTS

TULSI GABBARD, DEMOCRATIC PRINTIAL CANDIDATE, APOLOGIZ FOR ANTI-GAY PAST

GAY LAWMAKER SUMS UP WHAT EVERYONE IS THKG ABOUT TULSI GABBARD JT 6 WORDS

*BEAR-MAGAZINE.COM* TULSI GABBARD GAY MARRIAGE

BEAR-MAGAZINE.COM TULSI GABBARD GAY MARRIAGE