The Exhib That Bombed: The Enola Gay Controversy and Contted Memory - U.S. Studi Onle

Contents:

• EXHIBG THE ENOLA GAY
• THE SMHSONIAN’S DECISN TO EXHIB THE ‘ENOLA GAY’
• WHAT HAPPENED TO THE ENOLA GAY AFTER IT DROPPED THE ATOMIC BOMB
• TOURG THE SMHSONIAN AIR AND SPACE MM’S ENOLA GAY EXHIB
• ENOLA GAY
• HISTORIANS PROTT NEW ENOLA GAY EXHIB
• THE SMHSONIAN AND THE ENOLA GAY
• ENOLA GAY EXHIBIT: PLANE AND SIMPLE
• THE EXHIB THAT BOMBED: THE ENOLA GAY CONTROVERSY AND CONTTED MEMORY
• THE ENOLA GAY
• SMHSONIAN SUBSTANTIALLY ALTERS ENOLA GAY EXHIB AFTER CRICISM
• HISTORY AND THE CULTURE WARS: THE CASE OF THE SMHSONIAN INSTUTN'S ENOLA GAY EXHIBN
• FIRST SCRIPT OF THE ENOLA GAY EXHIB COMPLETED
• THE NEW ENOLA GAY CONTROVERSY: PRO AND CON

EXHIBG THE ENOLA GAY

While this exhib is now closed, Mm specialists ntued to rtore the remag ponents of the airplane, and after an addnal ne years the fully assembled Enola Gay went on permanent display at the Natnal Air and Space Mm’s Steven F. This past exhibn, cidg wh the 50th anniversary of the end of World War II, told the story of the role of the Enola Gay securg Japane surrenr. It ntaed several major ponents of the Enola Gay, the B-29 bomber ed the atomic missn that stroyed Hiroshima, Japan.

A vio prentatn about the Enola Gay's missn clud terviews wh the crew before and after the missn cludg missn pilot Col. Another portn of the exhib tailed the pastakg efforts of Smhsonian aircraft rtoratn specialists who had spent more than a rtorg parts of the Enola Gay for this exhibn. Many veterans had advoted for the display of the Enola Gay, the B-29 Superfortrs ed to drop the bombs, as a celebratn of Amerin triumph over Japan, but there were already ncerns that the Smhsonian was creatg a polilly rrect, revisnist terpretatn of the events.

Harw rigned on May 2, 1995, jt days before he was schled to ttify Senate June 28, 1995, an exhibn, simply tled "Enola Gay, " opened at the Natnal Air and Space Mm. Only the felage was on display, acpanied by basic facts and rmatn about the plane's entire Enola Gay bomber is currently on display the "World War II Aviatn" exhibn at the Natnal Air and Space Mm's Steven F. Related RourcCollectns related to the Enola Gay, Smhsonian Instutn ArchivThe Enola Gay: A Natn's, and a Mm's, Dilemma, Edorial by Mart Harw, The Washgton Post, Augt 7, 1994Special Report: The Smhsonian and the Enola Gay, Air Force Associatn, March 15, 1994Smhsonian Cancels Exhib on Atomic Bomb, The Baltimore Sun, January 31, 1995Recent Acquisn - Rerds om Mart Harw, Director, NASM, 1986-1995, The Bigger Picture, Smhsonian Instutn Archiv.

THE SMHSONIAN’S DECISN TO EXHIB THE ‘ENOLA GAY’

For the 50th anniversary of the end of World War II, the Natnal Air and Space Mm (NASM) proposed an exhibn that would clu displayg the Enola Gay, the B-29 Superfortrs that was ed to drop the bomb on Hiroshima. The veterans formed “the Commtee for the Rtoratn and Proud Display of the Enola Gay” to raise funds. At first, the Enola Gay was planned to be displayed at an annex NASM facily near Washgton Dull Internatnal Airport.

The Enola Gay had recently fished beg renovated and the mm had been ncerned about transportatn and reassemble fe; therefore, the proposed annex appeared to be a ftg lotn. They cid to exhib the Enola Gay at the annex, wh an acpanyg msage about the dangers of strategic bombg and latn.

WHAT HAPPENED TO THE ENOLA GAY AFTER IT DROPPED THE ATOMIC BOMB

Commtee member Admiral Noel Gayler believed that any exhibn of the Enola Gay would imply “that we are celebratg the first and so far the only e of nuclear weapons agast human begs.” Heedg this warng, the mtee tabled the discsn and cid to first tt the waters wh a sixteen-month seri of talks, panels, and exhibs on “Strategic Bombgs World War II.” Meanwhile the proposed annex did not receive necsary fundg until 1999, om a private donatn. Correll, edor of the Air Force Magaze, llg the exhib a “strint attack on airpower World War I” by characterizg the ary aircraft as “stment of ath.” Still, Harw phed for a follow-up wh an exhibn on World War II that would clu the Enola Gay.

While they were “unanimo agreeg that the Enola Gay is an artifact of pivotal signifince and that should be exhibed,” they asked the mm to avoid discsg the cisn to drop the bomb and to nsir an alternative se, such as an armed servic mm.

The planned exhibn was replaced by a simple display of the felage of Enola Gay wh ltle historil ntext. Officials om the Universy stated was not tend as a replacement for the Enola Gay exhibn at the Smhsonian. The 2003 exhibn of Enola Gay, followg s trend of ntroversy, also raised a new round of protts, om Japane survivors and others.

TOURG THE SMHSONIAN AIR AND SPACE MM’S ENOLA GAY EXHIB

The Smhsonian’s Decisn to Exhib the 'Enola Gay' - Public History Weekly - The Open Peer Review Journal. What harbgers of the future of public history the US rid the mid-1990s fight over the meang of the Enola Gay? When the Smhsonian cid to exhib the “Enola Gay, ” the B-29 bomber that dropped the atomic bomb on Hiroshima, the director and curators of the Natnal Air & Space Mm (NASM) hardly anticipated the firtorm of ntroversy that would rult.

While the “Enola Gay fias, ” as some at the mm me to ll , was not the first skirmish Ameri’s ongog culture wars, was an omo warng of the battl to e. As a NASM curator volved the early planng of the exhib, who was also prent at the bacle, the followg is a first-person acunt of the origs, evolutn, and fate of the “Enola Gay” exhib, tled “The Last Act: The Atomic Bomb and the End of World War II. One project was to brg the “Enola Gay” out of the Garber llectns and rtoratn facily, and fish the plane’s rtoratn time for a major exhib on the Capol Mall to ci wh the 50th anniversary of the end of WWII.

Sce I had wrten a doctoral dissertatn on the aftermath of the atomic bombg, later published as The Wng Weapon: The Atomic Bomb the Cold War, 1945-1950, Mart asked me to take the ial lead planng the “Enola Gay” exhib, until Tom arrived at NASM. To my amazement, he was entirely supportive of our plans to tell the story of the atomic bombg, and even offered to loan any of the artifacts his mm had s llectn, for as long as the “Enola Gay” remaed on display at NASM. Mart and Steve likewise cid that we should show a draft of the exhib’s planng document and label script to those we thought might be our most proment crics, wh the hope of rpondg to and fg their cricisms before the “Enola Gay” went on display.

ENOLA GAY

My memory is that the AFA required to say the followg three thgs the “Enola Gay” exhib, and we were given to unrstand that the assertns were unequivol and non-negotiable.

The exhib that opened at the Mall mm on June 28, 1995, was a pale shadow of the “Enola Gay” exhib as origally nceived. The mimal exhib script and a short vio featured quotatns om the “Enola Gay” pilot, retired Air Force brigadier general Pl Tibbets, and the other crew members, scribg the missn.

In retrospect, none of at the mm had an appreciatn of how much the polil climate had changed Washgton sce planng for the “Enola Gay” exhib began. On December 16, 2003, the day after the “Enola Gay” was unveiled s new—and likely permanent—home, NASM’s new annex near Dull airport, a half-dozen atomic bomb survivors joed fifty self-intified “peace activists” to unfurl a banner readg: “Hiroshima—Never Aga” ont of the plane. “The Enola Gay and the Smhsonian Chronology of the Controversy 1993-1995, ” Air & Space Forc Magaze.

HISTORIANS PROTT NEW ENOLA GAY EXHIB

[2] My troductn to the Enola Gay me shortly after I arrived NASM, when I vised the Garber rtoratn facily. [3] Mart Harw, An Exhib Denied: Lobbyg the History of Enola Gay (New York: Sprger-Verlag, 1996), 247. [10] “Enola Gay Display Angers Victims, ” BBC News, December 16, 2003, accsed Augt 4, 2022, (last accsed 3 October 2022).

The Enola Gay is a B-29 Superfortrs, which pilot Pl Tibbets named after his mother, and which had been stripped of everythg but the necsi, so as to be thoands of pounds lighter than an ordary plane of that make.

THE SMHSONIAN AND THE ENOLA GAY

While did not drop the bomb on Nagasaki, the Enola Gay did take flight to get data on the weather the lead-up to the send strike on Japan. In the aftermath of World War II, the Army Air Forc flew the Enola Gay durg an atomic tt program the Pacific; was then livered to be stored an airfield Arizona before beg flown to Illois and transferred to the Smhsonian July 1949. Adams, who is leavg his job after 10 relatively ntroversy-ee years, sent back a three-page answer stiffly turng down her requt for the Enola Gay.

ENOLA GAY EXHIBIT: PLANE AND SIMPLE

Demonstrators prott at the Enola Gay exhib at the the Smhsonian Natnal Air and Space Mm's Steven F. And as long as is on display, the qutns rais are likely to ntue — after all, they have been wh the Enola Gay sce first beme a hoehold name.

Enola Gay: Today, Enola Gay -- the B-29 bomber that dropped the atomic bomb on Hiroshima -- is parked at the Smhsonian Air and Space Mm Chantilly, Virgia.

A somber artifact: Jeremy Kney, curator at the Smhsonian Air and Space Mm, stands ont of Enola Gay. The ckp: Visors to the Smhsonian Air and Space Mm Chantilly, Virgia, n look down to the ckp of Enola Gay.

THE EXHIB THAT BOMBED: THE ENOLA GAY CONTROVERSY AND CONTTED MEMORY

Terntental bomber: Enola Gay was signed to be an terntental bomber, one that uld fly om the ntental US to Europe se Bra fell to Nazi Germany.

Enola Gay, the B-29bomber that was ed by the Uned Stat on Augt 6, 1945, to drop an atomic bomb on Hiroshima, Japan, the first time the explosive vice had been ed on an enemy target. ” The Enola Gay—Tibbets had a matenance man pat that name on the aircraft’s nose shortly before takeoff—was acpanied by var other plan.

THE ENOLA GAY

Three days later the Enola Gay nducted weather rennaissance the lead-up to the bombg of Nagasaki, Japan. Japan officially surrenred on September 2, Enola Gay remaed service for several years before beg given to the Smhsonian Instutn on July 3, 1949.

SMHSONIAN SUBSTANTIALLY ALTERS ENOLA GAY EXHIB AFTER CRICISM

A group of historians and activists has livered a petn challengg the Natnal Air and Space Mm's proposed exhib of the Enola Gay, the B-29 Superfortrs ed the atomic bombg of Hiroshima on Augt 6, 1945. The new exhib, schled to open December 2003, will, as a NASM prs release (available at) not, intify the Enola Gay as the aircraft that "dropped the first atomic weapon ed bat" and scribe the B-29 as "the most sophistited propeller-driven bomber of World War II, " but will not otherwise explore the historil ntext of Hiroshima or nuclear weapons. ) The mtee's Statement of Prcipl (also available on the web se) clar that displayg the Enola Gay as a technologil achievement reflects "extraordary llons toward the victims, difference to the ep divisns among Amerin cizens about the propriety of the actns, and disregard for the feelgs of most of the world's peopl.

"1 The mm nceled the plans for a ntextual exhib, and merely displayed the felage of the Enola Gay wh mimal text. Lenthal, "Anatomy of a Controversy, " History Wars: The Enola Gay and Other Battl for the Amerin Past, ed.

HISTORY AND THE CULTURE WARS: THE CASE OF THE SMHSONIAN INSTUTN'S ENOLA GAY EXHIBN

Not sce 1855 has the Smhsonian been riven by a ntroversy to equal that precipated by the proposed Enola Gay exhib.

When the Enola Gay exhib was beg planned the 1990s, one observer was uncerta whether the staff of the Air and Space Mm uld "overe" the celebratory character of s tablishment "and make the exhib of the Enola Gay the tnal opportuny is planng... Wrg a statement drafted "well before my stallatn as Secretary" and published the October 1994 issue of the Smhsonian magaze, Heyman put the Enola Gay ntroversy terms of "prcipl of fundamental importance to the Smhsonian. I will not attempt to al wh the evolutn of the Enola Gay script, as fascatg as such an exercise would be, except to say that var revisns of were sent out for ment to outsi anizatns, such as the Air Force Assotn and nasm's own Advisory Commtee on Rearch and Collectns Management (head by Richard Kohn of the Universy of North Carola).

Young which proposed, the wake of the ntroversi over the Smhsonian's "The Wt as Ameri" exhib and the "year-long polil attack" on the script for the Enola Gay exhib, "that Amerin mms adopt a Bill of Rights to protect eedom of terpretatn. I will not attempt to terme who blked first the face-off between the secretary of the Smhsonian and Capol Hill over scrappg the origal ncept of the Enola Gay exhib. Secretary Heyman stated a letter to The New Republic that "Speaker Newt Ggrich and I never negotiated any arrangement ncerng the Enola Gay exhib.

FIRST SCRIPT OF THE ENOLA GAY EXHIB COMPLETED

Heyman, ed, outflanked and renred superfluo the Enola Gay curators by flatly assertg that he--not they--was now the curator of the exhib and he would be the thor of the script that will acpany the Enola Gay when is fally exhibed to memorate the fiftieth anniversary of the end of the war. Tibbets, Jr., the manr of the Enola Gay, or the equally simple label on the Bock's Car, the plane that dropped the send bomb on Nagasaki, which is now at the U.

Comments reflectg this attu have been thrown about by opponents of the Smhsonian's Enola Gay policy. The danger that the Smhsonian's budget uld be cut bee of the polil ntroversy engenred by the Enola Gay exhib still remas. The Enola Gay's trip to the northwt rner of the Air and Space Mm has been far more tortuo than the flight took the morng of Aug.

Pl Tibbets, who piloted the Enola Gay, sent a letter of ngratulatns after tourg the exhib, sayg he was "pleased and proud" of . "To display the Enola Gay whout ntext, and whout the nsirable historil rmatn and terpretatn that is available, is to glorify and legimate the e of nuclear weapons, " said Jo Becker of the Fellowship of Renciliatn, speakg on behalf of a aln of peace and relig groups.

THE NEW ENOLA GAY CONTROVERSY: PRO AND CON

" A sign reassur visors that the Enola Gay is not radactive and pos no danger, and that the bomb sg do not nta an actual bomb. The voice-over, om an Enola Gay crew member, stat that the Japane would not acknowledge what happened Hiroshima and th was necsary to drop the send atomic bomb. Eventually the entire Enola Gay will be reassembled and moved to the new Air and Space Mm extensn planned for Dull Internatnal Airport, to be placed on permanent exhibn.

" CAPTION: Japane reporter Searo Murao fil his story om ont of the Enola Gay at the Natnal Air and Space Mm.