Unexpected victim may have revealed Canada's 'Gay Village' serial killer

Contents:

• “UNVER: THE VILLAGE”: A SERIAL KILLER, TORONTO’S GAY COMMUNY, AND A PODST THAT TRANSCENDS TE CRIME
• THE STORY BEHD UNSOLVED MURRS TORONTO'S GAY VILLAGE
• CRACKG THE TORONTO GAY VILLAGE SERIAL KILLER CASE: HOW BCE MCARTHUR WAS FALLY CGHT
• SERIAL KILLER WHO STALKED AND TERRORIZED TORONTO’S GAY VILLAGE SENTENCED TO LIFE
• BCE MCARTHUR: TORONTO SERIAL KILLER STROYED GAY SAFE SPACE
• WHAT WE KNOW ABOUT THE SPECT THE DISAPPEARANC OM TORONTO'S GAY VILLAGE
• TORONTO'S GAY VILLAGE MOURNS DJ MURRED MIDTOWN APARTMENT
• TORONTO SERIAL KILLER? MAN ARRTED FOR GAY VILLAGE MURRS
• UNEXPECTED VICTIM MAY HAVE REVEALED CANADA'S 'GAY VILLAGE' SERIAL KILLER
• TORONTO'S ALLEGED 'GAY VILLAGE' SERIAL KILLER FACG 7TH MURR CHARGE
• WHAT WE KNOW ABOUT THE TORONTO MAN CHARGED WH MURRG TWO GAY MEN
• TORONTO POLICE VTIGATED WHETHER GAY VILLAGE MURR SPECT HAD HELP OM NOTOR KILLER LA MAGNOTTA

“UNVER: THE VILLAGE”: A SERIAL KILLER, TORONTO’S GAY COMMUNY, AND A PODST THAT TRANSCENDS TE CRIME

In what beme the largt forensic vtigatn Toronto police history, officers found the remas of eight men Fraser’s planters and a nearby Febary, McArthur, sixty-seven, was nvicted, a Toronto crimal urt, of killg those eight men, all of them gay and six of them immigrant men of lor, between 2010 and 2017. It also reopened another, possibly related, set of mysteri, which “go back s, to a time when beg gay meant beg a target; to when the muny had to fend self, bee police wouldn’t; when the closet was, for many, jt a safer choice than g out; to a time when queer people were wdg up ad and their killers were gettg away wh .

THE STORY BEHD UNSOLVED MURRS TORONTO'S GAY VILLAGE

The re that Lg brgs to the story elevat beyond te crime; what’s beg unvered isn’t a culpr but a se of that history is Toronto’s Gay Village. In the third episo, Lg tak the narrative on a sharp turn—back to ld-se mysteri that he mentned at the begng of the seri and the tortured history between police and the gay muny Toronto. In the seventi, a rash of murrs of gay men stck the cy, several of them characterized by “overkill”—excsive btaly that marks a crime as rage-driven, personal.

CRACKG THE TORONTO GAY VILLAGE SERIAL KILLER CASE: HOW BCE MCARTHUR WAS FALLY CGHT

A gay bar lled David’s Distheque, one of the neighborhood’s first gay-owned gay bars, featured a life-sized founta repli of Michelangelo’s David the middle of the dance floor. He talks to police, too, cludg a well-meang retired p who had unrstood the “overkill” murrs to be the work of gay killers who “had not e to terms wh their sexual problems.

In the seventh episo, Lg talks to a kdly widower whose partner died 1979, police ctody, after he was arrted by “moraly officers” the men’s room of a gay bar.

SERIAL KILLER WHO STALKED AND TERRORIZED TORONTO’S GAY VILLAGE SENTENCED TO LIFE

Raids on sexual activy bars and bathho were mon; growg tratn wh the raids helped lead to gay-rights activism he vtigat all of this, Lg mak fascatg headway.

Front BurnerIn this season of Unver: The Village, reporter Jt Lg reveals the history of unsolved murr and missg-persons s Toronto’s Gay Burner21:56The story behd unsolved murrs Toronto's gay villageWhen men started disappearg om Toronto's Gay Village, people the muny there worried a serial killer uld be rponsible. The s that eventually led to McArthur's nvictn spurred reporter Jt Lg to dig eper to a seri of unsolved murr and missg-persons s Toronto's Gay Village. Some argued that police were too slow to warn the muny of a possible serial killer, sayg liv uld have been make matters worse, Toronto police appeared to put some blame on the gay muny for the killgs when chief Mark Snrs told reporters that they might have ught McArthur sooner had rints of the gay village been more forthg.

Their requt to participate 2018 was, April, a move that some have terpreted as an acknowledgment of their neglect of the gay muny, police announced that they were reopeng 25 ld s – all murrs associated wh Toronto’s gay date om 1997 all the way back to no one is suggtg is Santa to serial killerWhile vtigators are still velopg a profile of the alleged serial killer, they are certa of one thg. His age, as well as his unthreateng appearance – round featur and a broad, cheery se – ma him seem approachable to children shoppg wh their parents, as well as to gay men seekg a dark sexual enunter wh someone they uld McArthur a photo posted on a social media acunt. Photograph: RtersAfter divorcg his wife, McArthur, who had been active on his church board Oshawa, east of Toronto, beme a regular the cy’s gay village.

BCE MCARTHUR: TORONTO SERIAL KILLER STROYED GAY SAFE SPACE

He was sentenced 2003 to two years probatn and told to stay away om the gay 2010, reports started to e through of men gog missg om the village.

WHAT WE KNOW ABOUT THE SPECT THE DISAPPEARANC OM TORONTO'S GAY VILLAGE

The first, Skandaraj Navaratnam, rts particularly heavily on the md of Haran Vijayanathan, executive director of the Alliance for South Asian Aids Preventn (ASAAP) men are Sri Lankan, Ta and gay. Jt as gay men om North Bay and Moose Jaw flocked to Toronto the 1970s to live ee and open liv, a new generatn of gay men om south Asia and the Middle East have been drawn to Canada the last 20 years for the same reasons. Gay men – particularly gay refuge or other relatively new Canadians – f to a populatn that clus prostut, aborigal women and then there is what Lee refers to as “missg whe woman syndrome”: the ia that police, media and the public are ls cled to pay attentn to crim that are perpetrated on margalized muni.

TORONTO'S GAY VILLAGE MOURNS DJ MURRED MIDTOWN APARTMENT

Vijayanathan, who is one of the most outspoken crics of how Toronto let s gay muny down, sists that police only took the vtigatns serly when Andrew Ksman, one of two whe victims, was reported he also pots to racism wh the gay muny – parg the massive lol search mounted after the reported disappearance of the other whe victim, Andrew Ksman, wh the slower and ls hive rponse to the disappearanc of the brown-skned victims. Vijayanathan also believ the fai of some of the missg immigrant men failed to report their some s, he says, the disappearanc were the first time fay members learned their relative was gay (or MSM, men who have sex wh men but don’t intify as gay).

TORONTO SERIAL KILLER? MAN ARRTED FOR GAY VILLAGE MURRS

For example, Kishna Kumar Kanagaratnam was a Ta refugee who me to Canada 2016 and was never reported missg, and after Navaratnam’s refugee claim was nied he rarely left the nf of the gay village. “Throughout our history, people have e to the cy as a refuge and a place to explore their sexualy – often whout the knowledge of their fay and iends, ” says Tom Hooper, a York Universy historian who has voted much of his studi to the gay experience Toronto the Hooper also pots the fger at police. ”Homophobic atmosphereThe difficult relatnship between Toronto’s gay muny and police force cis wh reports of missg gay men gog back s.

Seven of those s rema btal stabbg ath of William Dunn Robson at his home November 1978 me shortly after the popular 1970s gay magaze the Body Polic to qutn the sluggish police rponse to the strg of murrs, and the official stance that they were unrelated: “Could they have been mted by one man? Crics dispute that theory by potg to a very different manner of executn and body disposal: the 1970s murrs were mostly stabbgs, and the victims were left where they were is disputable is that police never ught the killer, or killers – and ’s hardly a stretch to image that they didn’t feel much prsure to do so the homophobic atmosphere of the was a holiday tradn each Halloween durg the 1960s and 70s for Toronto rints to tnt gay men, pecially drag queens, as they entered bars on Yonge Street like the St Charl Tavern and the Parksi.

They pelted eggs, which turned to rocks, which turned to beatgs on darkened si mostly looked the other way, rells the Rev Brent Hawk, a longtime lear of the cy’s gay rights movement who was once himself rtraed on a siwalk by two officers as a third punched him.

UNEXPECTED VICTIM MAY HAVE REVEALED CANADA'S 'GAY VILLAGE' SERIAL KILLER

Photograph: Frank Lennon/Toronto Star/GettyThe nstant harassment by police reach the boilg pot 1981, when 200 police officers scend on four gay bathho. Photograph: Ian Willms/Getty ImagBut even as Toronto’s more tablished gay muny gas strength, new arrivals ntue to lead margal, vulnerable Hank Idsga, 50, the lead vtigator on the most high-profile of murr s, is keenly aware of media cricism that police did not take the missg persons reports or speculatn of a serial killer serly bee the men were gay and mostly brown-skned. ” He pots out that he was recently sld by a reporter for g the exprsn “gay liftyle”, and promis: “I will avoid the term om now on.

”The cisn to open the ld s – Idsga timat the number of unrolved s of murred gay men at 20 or more – is a belated attempt to make somethg very wrong at least a b more right. A former Mr Leatherman Toronto, Cribb told Global TV a wi-rangg terview that he felt fortable submtg to McArthur’s wish bee he looked so even brought up the mour of a serial killer attackg gay men Toronto, but says McArthur didn’t McArthur, Cribb has a tough appearance: sleeve tattoos, a black beard and a thick nose rg.

Photograph: Bernard Weil/Toronto Star via Getty ImagBut as well as gettg to the head of McArthur, means tryg to heal a rift wh the gay muny that stretch back Sunday’s otherwise jubiliant Pri para will end wh a ntgent of anizers drsed black, to pay rpect to the victims of the killer and to all LGBTQ people who don’t feel safe their own some the gay muny argue that this is a time for healg – and that police participatn is ccial if the gay muny is gog to move forward – Black Liv Matter is not so eager to five, sistg that banng uniformed officers is a need prott agast broar police neglect and abe. He also exprs sympathy for the many LGBTQ members on Toronto’s police force who ually enjoy marchg uniform the says he has wnsed the growg matury of the partment over the s – wh an emphasis placed on sensivy trag and recg gay officers, cludg an openly lbian puty chief. Over the next three years, three more men lked to the cy’s gay neighborhood vanished, cludg Soroh Mahmudi, 50, Kishna Kumar Kanagaratnam, 37, and Dean Lisowick, 47.

TORONTO'S ALLEGED 'GAY VILLAGE' SERIAL KILLER FACG 7TH MURR CHARGE

For years, members of Toronto’s gay muny warned that there was a serial killer on the loose, that vulnerable men were gog missg, that the streets were not safe. He plead guilty last a sentencg hearg that end Tuday, Canadians heard how he lured and murred men he met  Toronto’s Gay Village, then posed rps stum, keepg pictur of each victim labeled digal learned McArthur was stopped when police raid his home, fdg a man tied to a bed.

He was a potential nth victim, the urt heard, and McArthur had a folr a cy that pris self on beg gay-iendly and welg to new Canadians, McArthur sought out men margalized by their sexualy, ethnicy, immigratn stat or poverty.

Some have argued that the police rponse was slowed by homophobia and racism — that the force might have acted more quickly if different men had disappeared. “Would police have taken more and swifter actn if McArthur’s victims had not been gay or people of lour, homels or addicted to dgs?

WHAT WE KNOW ABOUT THE TORONTO MAN CHARGED WH MURRG TWO GAY MEN

Image source, FacebookImage ptn, Bce McArthur was arrted on 18 JanuaryFor years, there were whispers Toronto's gay muny about a serial killer stalkg the muny. Now that one of their own has plead guilty to the murrs of eight missg men, they wonr why the police didn't act a small park the heart of Toronto's Gay Village, about 200 people assembled the snow to mourn the victims of an alleged serial wore armbands pated wh the words "love", "heal", "rise", "grieve". He knew he was gay om a young age, but tried to ignore , urt documents for an asslt charge would later grandfather and father of two me out his 40s after abptly leavg his fay Oshawa and movg to Toronto, where he beme a regular the Gay Zipperz, one of the bars equented by many of his alleged victims, he uld often be found stg at the bar, havg a drk or chattg up a fellow patron.

In 2003 he was given a two-year ndnal sentence for assltg a male prostute wh a metal source, BBC SportImage ptn, An attene at the vigil wears an armband wh the word "love"As part of his sentence, he was required to stay away om male prostut, the Gay Village and rea om g amyl nre, also known as was close wh several of his landspg clients. Loted at the tersectn of Church Street and Wellley Street, Toronto's Gay Village has been the cy's enclave for the LGBT muny sce the 1960s. Kishna Kumar Kanagaratnam, 37, January 2016Dean Lisowick, 47, April 2016Selim Esen, 44, April 2017Andrew Ksman, 49, June 2017Image ptn, Toronto's Gay VillageUnanswered qutnsPolice have not said how Bce McArthur beme a spect the killgs.

Image source, FacebookImage ptn, Friends hung posters of Andrew Ksman around the Village and CabbagetownThen June 2017, Ksman's disappearance sparked a muny-wi search and rekdled mours of a serial killer the gay after, police lnched a send task force, to look to both Ksman and Esen's as late as December that year, Toronto police were publicly sayg there was "no evince" of a serial nial has damaged an already agile relatnship between the Toronto LGBT muny and the ptn, Street art Toronto's Gay VillageUnanswered qutns still hnt Haran Vijayanathan, executive director of the Alliance for South Asian Aids Preventn, who has been speakg on behalf of many of the victims. He plead guilty to murrg eight men between 2010 and 2017, who had all disappeared whout a trace om Toronto's Gay Village district. W5 has spent months vtigatg the shadowy and twisted world of nnibal fantasy webs, as we retraced the first police probe to three men who had disappeared om Toronto’s gay village between 2010 and 2012.

TORONTO POLICE VTIGATED WHETHER GAY VILLAGE MURR SPECT HAD HELP OM NOTOR KILLER LA MAGNOTTA

The arrt of a 66-year-old landsper the prumed aths of two gay men, who disappeared om downtown Toronto last year, stunned many the cy's LGBT muny when the news broke on Thursday. Bce McArthur, of Toronto, fac two unts of first-gree murr the aths of Andrew Ksman, 49, and Selim Esen, 44, who vanished close to Church and Wellley, the cy's predomantly gay neighbourhood, 2017.