tolkiens legendarium - When were Frodo and Sam first nceptualized as gay? - Science Fictn & Fantasy Stack Exchange

Contents:

• ESCRORA EXPLI POR QUé Sí POSIBLE TERPRETAR A FRODO Y SAM O PAREJA GAY
• WAS FRODO BAGGS GAY AND IS SAM LOVE WH HIM?
• HOW FRODO AND SAM WERE “MOSTLY GAY”
• WHEN WERE FRODO AND SAM FIRST NCEPTUALIZED AS GAY?

ESCRORA EXPLI POR QUé Sí POSIBLE TERPRETAR A FRODO Y SAM O PAREJA GAY

Note: This say ntas discsn of homophobia and mentn of suici.

Outsi of the safe darkns of the theater, the Mordor-like wasteland of middle school, the movi were synonymo wh the favored sult of the time — “gay. Early-2000s preteen Ameri was a time of gay jok, of “no homo, ” of mockg voic and slurs, and secret, punive vlence enacted the locker room agast anyone who had a whiff of otherns. He never would have wrten about gay people!

He faced a urt-martial 1918 after one of his letters scribed “homosexual relatns wh men his pany.

WAS FRODO BAGGS GAY AND IS SAM LOVE WH HIM?

Two years before The Lord of the Rgs was published, war-wng breaker and geni mathematician Alan Turg stood trial for “homosexual acts and gross cency” — that is, beg ught his own home wh another man. Lewis wrote a letter to Sheldon Vanken (later reprted Vanken’s tobgraphy) that Lewis had received a letter om a “p male homosexual [...

The only mentn is a bland reference his bgraphy by Humphrey Carpenter: “As to homosexualy, Tolkien claimed that at neteen he did not even know the word. Tolkien wrote of the openly gay poet W. As scribed by thor Reynolds Price, at least one member of Tolkien’s iend group, the Inklgs, “separated om his wife and lived a quietly homosexual life.

She beme an in the gay male muny for wrg sympathetilly about same-sex relatnships ancient Greece. Bilbo and Frodo’s home of Bag End is scribed by other hobbs as “a queer place, and s folk are queerer” — an adjective which had a strong nnotatn of homosexualy by the late 1800s. It’s tricky to apply morn labels to people that they did not claim life — but morn labels clu “straight” and “cisgenr” jt as much as “gay” or “transgenr.

HOW FRODO AND SAM WERE “MOSTLY GAY”

One of them was Geofey Bache Smh, a poet whose work is nsired homoromantic by morn rears.

“Homosexualy the First World War. Todo to seguramente ya tá siendo rechazado por muchos, y Ostertag se alantó a los que dirán que Tolkien era tóli y jamás habría cro sobre personaj gays, pero a diferencia su amigo C.

Lewis, quien jó nstancia su marda homofobia, el tor El Señor los Anillos mostró tar abierto a ser amigo personas homosexual o el poeta W. Otra pista que apunta en a dirección el térmo “queer”, que Tolkien a para scribir a Bilbo y a Frodo, y acuerdo n Ostertag, el adjetivo ya tenía una fuerte nnotación homosexual a fal los 1800. What's your opn the the gay subtext between Sam and Frodo?

WHEN WERE FRODO AND SAM FIRST NCEPTUALIZED AS GAY?

It's clear that Tolkien would have read The Iliad, The Odyssey, etc and would have no doubt unrstood the homosexualy folk stori and legends. While Merry and Pipp seem to have a much more normal iendship whout a lot of homoeroticism.