[PDF] GEORGE CHAUNCEY'S GAY NEW YORK: A VIEW FROM 25 YEARS LATER | Semantic Scholar

Contents:

• GAY NEW YORK : GENR, URBAN CULTURE, AND THE MAKGS OF THE GAY MALE WORLD, 1890-1940
• GEORGE CHAUNCEY'S GAY NEW YORK: A VIEW FROM 25 YEARS LATER
• GAY NEW YORK : THE MAKG OF THE GAY MALE WORLD, 1890-1940
• GEORGE CHAUNCEY'S GAY NEW YORK: A VIEW FROM 25 YEARS LATER
• GAY NEW YORK
• GEORGE CHAUNCEY'S GAY NEW YORK: A VIEW FROM 25 YEARS LATER
• GAY NEW YORK SUMMARY
• GAY NEW YORK ANALYSIS
• GAY NEW YORK: GENR, URBAN CULTURE, AND THE MAKGS OF THE GAY MALE WORLD, 1890-1940
• GAY NEW YORK [ELECTRONIC ROURCE] : GENR, URBAN CULTURE, AND THE MAKGS OF THE GAY MALE WORLD, 1890-1940
• GAY NEW YORK : THE MAKG OF THE GAY MALE WORLD, 1890-1940
• GAY NEW YORK SUMMARY

GAY NEW YORK : GENR, URBAN CULTURE, AND THE MAKGS OF THE GAY MALE WORLD, 1890-1940

[365]-457) and xThis groundbreakg work shatters the myth that before the 1960s gay life existed only the closet where gay men were isolated, visible, and self-hatg.

Based on years of rearch and accs to a rich trove of public and private documents, this is a look at a gay world that was not supposed to have existed. Focg on New York Cy, the gay pal of the natn for nearly a century, Chncey recreat the saloons, speakeasi, and feterias where gay men gathered, the timate parti and immense drag balls where they celebrated, and the highly visible rintial enclav they built Greenwich Village, Harlem, and Tim Square.

GEORGE CHAUNCEY'S GAY NEW YORK: A VIEW FROM 25 YEARS LATER

He offers new perspectiv on the gay rights revolutn of our time by showg that the opprsn the gay and lbian movement attacked the 1960s was not an unchangg phenomenon-- had tensified the 1920s and 1930s as a direct rponse to the visibily of the gay world those years. Men Like That: A Southern Queer HistoryJohn HowardHistory1999One don't ually associate thrivg queer culture wh ral Ameri, but John Howard's history of queer life the South seeks to bunk the myth that same-sex sir n't fd exprsn… Mappg the Erotic Body: Gay New YorkR.

Tle: Gay New York: Genr, Urban Culture, and the Makg of the Gay Male World, 1890-1940. Gee Chncey unvers a prevly hidn "gay male world" New York Cy before World War II, a world that had been lost through the myths of "isolatn, visibily, and ternalizatn.

" Instead, the world Chncey scrib is a vibrant and surprisgly visible gay culture between 1890-1940. In this world, the later homosexual/heterosexual bary was not yet force, and men were fed on the basis of their masculy or femy rather than the sex of their sexual partners. In this way, workg-class mascule men, particularly sailors and laborers, uld have sex wh effemate "fairi" yet not be nsired "gay" (provid they were the one dog the peratg).

GAY NEW YORK : THE MAKG OF THE GAY MALE WORLD, 1890-1940

In Part II, Chncey scrib how gay men produced the space of an urban "gay world.

Chncey not that, until the 1930s, thori would often take a hands-off approach unls gay men's prence moved beyond the tegory of harmls spectacle. He also not the tensn between private and public, where gay men were often forced out of the public sphere to engage activi and socializg public areas (although plac such as parks and streets were often dangero).

Fally, he pots to the velopment of two gay neighborhood enclav: Greenwich Village the 1910s (part of a larger bohemian culture) and Harlem the 1920s and 1930s (which was much more visible and vibrant).

GEORGE CHAUNCEY'S GAY NEW YORK: A VIEW FROM 25 YEARS LATER

Chncey not that until the 1930s, the spac, particular Harlem, beme a space for highly visible spectacl of gay life - for example, massive drag queen balls which thoands attend and were vered by the prs.

The unrme any notns of gay life beg eply the closet until the 1960s. Chncey ends wh a discsn of the cle of this gay world.

GAY NEW YORK

Wh s repeal the state had broar surveillance and regulatory powers which they ed to lim gay public space. This occurs most vividly wh vlent crackdowns on any bars that allowed gay men visibily (leadg to the rise of exclively gay bars).

GEORGE CHAUNCEY'S GAY NEW YORK: A VIEW FROM 25 YEARS LATER

Chncey's narrative ends wh the gay world beg driven largely unrground durg the 1930s.

- Gay world was que visible before 1930s, then went to the closet (anti-Whiggish view of history). - Centraly of workg class to gay world. - For much of perd there was no hetero/homo bary, stead fed by masculy/femy, NOT sexual orientatn - straight men uld have sex wh "fairi" and "queers" (fed by their femy) and not be nsired gay.

- Gay men create a space for activy that bridg public and private (ex. - Decle of gay world (gets put to the closet) begng 1930s due middle class male anxieti and repeal of Prohibn (broar state surveillance).

GAY NEW YORK SUMMARY

Xi, 478 pag: 20 cmThis award-wng book shatters the myth that before the 1960s gay life existed only the closet, where gay men were self- hatg, visible and isolated.

GAY NEW YORK ANALYSIS

Extract When Gee Chncey's Gay New York appeared a quarter century ago, did so wh served fanfare. ” While reviews of Gay New York appeared the ual Amerin history journals, many of the were unmonly long, ditg the book's immediate importance. The Associatn of Amerin Geographers held a roundtable on Gay New York 1995 which a participant dubbed , “one of the more important texts wrten by a nongeographer to be clud a non of new social geography.

” Beyond the amy, the popular prs also exprsed nsirable tert the book, wh the New York Tim, the New Yorker, the New Republic, and the Gay Communy News each takg up the matter of Gay New York s pag.

GAY NEW YORK: GENR, URBAN CULTURE, AND THE MAKGS OF THE GAY MALE WORLD, 1890-1940

And beyond the bounds of the Uned Stat, scholarly publitns Canada, Atralia, and the Uned Kgdom also missned reviews of Gay New York. Wh s first few years of publitn, Gay New York also llected a number of notable priz, cludg the Los Angel Tim Book Prize for history, the Frerick Jackson Turner Award om the Organizatn of Amerin Historians (OAH), the Lambda Lerary Award for gay men's studi, and the Merle Curti Award om the OAH. Referenc 1 See reviews by Bullough, Vern L., Amerin Journal of Soclogy 100:6 (May 1995): 1637CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Gutiérrez, Ramón, “Mappg the Erotic Body: Gay New York, ” Amerin Quarterly 48:3 (Sept.

GAY NEW YORK [ELECTRONIC ROURCE] : GENR, URBAN CULTURE, AND THE MAKGS OF THE GAY MALE WORLD, 1890-1940

1996): 506CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Plummer, Ken, Contemporary Soclogy 24:3 (May 1995): 355CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Elr, Glen, “Readg the Spac Gee Chncey's Gay New York, ” Environment and Planng D: Society and Space 14:6 (1996): 758CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Knopp, Lawrence, “Space(s) lost Gee Chncey's Gay New York, ” Environment and Planng D: Society and Space 14:6 (1996): 759Google Scholar; Brown, Michael, “Closet Geography, ” Environment and Planng D: Society and Space 14:6 (1996): 762Google Scholar; Farman, Lillian, Journal of the History of Sexualy 6:2 (Oct. 1995): 340Google Scholar; Tmbach, Randolph, “The Third Genr Twentieth-Century Ameri, ” Journal of Social History 30:2 (Wter 1996): 500CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Miron, Ja, “The Queerg of History: A Review Essay, ” Maryland Historian 27:1 (1996): 28Google Scholar; and Kopp, Clayton R., “A Goln Age Gay Gotham, ” Reviews Amerin History 24:2 (Jun.

2 See reviews by Drcher, Jack, Archiv of Sexual Behavr 28:5 (1999): 404–7Google Scholar; Judson, Pieter M., “History Meets Ethnography, ” GLQ: A Journal of Lbian and Gay Studi 3:2–3 (1996): 327–31CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Cohen, Lizabeth, Journal of Amerin History 84:2 (Sept. Some long reviews also clud works bis Gay New York.

See Hood, Clifton, “New Studi Gay and Lbian History, ” Journal of Urban History 24:6 (1998): 782–92CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Strange, Carolyn, “Bad Girls and Masked Men: Recent Works on Sexualy US History, ” Labour / Le Travail 39 (Sprg 1997): 261–75CrossRefGoogle Scholar; and Miron, “The Queerg of History, ” 27–51. 3 See reviews by Bullough, Amerin Journal of Soclogy, 1636–37; Gutiérrez, “Mappg the Erotic Body, ” 500–06; Bunzl, Matti, “Between Opprsn and Affirmatn: Historil Ethnography of Lbian and Gay Pasts, ” Anthropologil Quarterly 68:2 (Apr. : Inventg Cultur, Inti and the Closet, ” Gay Communy News 20:4 (Wter 1995): 14–17Google Scholar; Elizar Barkan, “15th Annual Los Angel Tim Book Priz; Wner: Gee Chncey's ‘Gay New York’; Out of the Closet, Into the Cy, ” Los Angel Tim, Nov.

GAY NEW YORK : THE MAKG OF THE GAY MALE WORLD, 1890-1940

6 Chncey, Gee, Gay New York (1890–1940), tradu l'amérin par Didier Eribon (Paris: Fayard, 2003)Google Scholar. 7 Chncey, Gee, Gay New York: Genr, Urban Culture, and the Makg of the Gay Male World, 1890–1940 (New York: Basic Books, 1994)Google Scholar. 8 Newton, Esther, Cherry Grove, Fire Island: Sixty Years Ameri's First Gay and Lbian Town (Boston: Bean Prs, 1993)Google Scholar; Kennedy, Elizabeth Lapovsky and Davis, Male D., Boots of Leather, Slippers of Gold: The History of a Lbian Communy (New York: Routledge, 1993)Google Scholar; D'E, John, Sexual Polics, Sexual Communi: The Makg of a Homosexual Mory the Uned Stat (Chigo: Universy of Chigo Prs, 1983)Google Scholar; Bébé, Allan, Comg Out Unr Fire: The History of Gay Men and Women World War Two (New York: Free Prs, 1990)Google Scholar; Weeks, Jefey, Comg Out: Homosexual Polics Bra om the Neteenth Century to the Prent (London: Quartet Books, 1977)Google Scholar; Weeks, Jefey, Sexualy (Chichter, UK: Ellis Horwood, 1986)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Sedgwick, Eve Kosofsky, Epistemology of the Closet (Berkeley: Universy of California Prs, 1990)Google Scholar; Katz, Jonathan Ned, Gay Amerin History: Lbians and Gay Men the U.

9 Atks, Gary, Gay Seattle: Stori of Exile and Belongg (Seattle: Universy of Washgton Prs, 2003)Google Scholar; Kaiser, Charl, The Gay Metropolis: 1940–1966 (Boston: Houghton Miffl, 1997)Google Scholar; Beachy, Robert, Gay Berl: Birthplace of a Morn Inty (New York: Vtage Books, 2014)Google Scholar; Farman, Lillian and Timmons, Stuart, Gay L. : A History of Sexual Outlaws, Power Polics, and Lipstick Lbians (New York: Basic Books, 2006)Google Scholar; Burg, Daneel, Lbian and Gay Memphis: Buildg Communi Behd the Magnolia Curt (New York: Garland Prs, 1997)Google Scholar; and Tw Ci GLBT Oral History Project, Queer Tw Ci (Mneapolis: Universy of Mnota Prs, 2010)Google Scholar.

GAY NEW YORK SUMMARY

Other book-length histori takg the lol, se study approach, clu Boag, Peter, Same-Sex Affairs: Constctg and Controllg Homosexualy the Pacific Northwt (Berkeley: Universy of California Prs, 2003)Google Scholar; Boyd, Nan, Wi Open Town: A History of Queer San Francis to 1965 (Berkeley: Universy of California Prs, 2003)Google Scholar; Hurewz, Daniel, Bohemian Los Angel and the Makg of Morn Polics (Berkeley: Universy of California Prs, 2008)Google Scholar; Ste, Marc, Cy of Sisterly and Brotherly Lov: Lbian and Gay Philalphia, 1945–1972 (Chigo: Universy of Chigo Prs, 2000)Google Scholar; Howard, John, Men Like That: A Southern Queer History (Chigo: Universy of Chigo Prs, 1999)Google Scholar; Johnson, David K., The Lavenr Sre: The Cold War Persecutn of Gays and Lbians the Feral Government (Chigo: Universy of Chigo Prs, 2004)Google Scholar; Project, The History, Improper Bostonians: Lbian and Gay History om the Purans to Playland (Boston: Bean Prs, 1998)Google Scholar; and Stewart-Wter, Timothy, Queer Clout: Chigo and the Rise of Gay Polics (Philalphia: Universy of Pennsylvania Prs, 2016)CrossRefGoogle Scholar. 10 For Chncey's discsn of such issu, see Gay New York, 27.