Why So Few Lbians and Gays Mastream Poly Communy? | Psychology Today

gay polygamy

If you're one of those rare people who thk one spoe is not enough, your prayers may be answered After the Supreme Court cisn favor of gay marriage, nservative crics spotted sister wiv on the horizon Polygamy, here we e! tweeted Weekly Standard edor William Kristol

Contents:

GAY MARRIAGE WAS ALWAYS LEADG TO POLYGAMY

Gay Marriage And Polygamy * gay polygamy *

The most natural advance next for marriage li legalized polygamy—yet many of the same people who prsed for marriage equaly for gay upl oppose . They’re trapped, I spect, prr opposn that they voiced om a standpot of polil pragmatism orr to advance the e of gay marriage.

They choose to si-step the issue by sistg that gay marriage wouldn’t lead to polygamy. To advote for polygamy durg the marriage equaly fight may have seemed to nfirm the socially nservative narrative, that gay marriage gured a wholale llapse tradnal valu. I thk ’s time to turn the qutn back on them: given what you know about the advancement of human rights, are you sure your opposn to group marriage won’t sound as anachronistic as opposn to gay marriage sounds to you now?

And sce we have sisted that there is no legimate way to oppose gay marriage and rpect gay love, how n you oppose group marriage and rpect group love?

GAY MARRIAGE AND POLYGAMY

Are you lookg to meet gay polygamists your area for love and marriage? If so, jo Gay Polygamist for ee today and make your life plete!, Gay Polygamist * gay polygamy *

This, of urse, is somethg we were promised would never happen when gay marriage beme a nstutnal right. Wrg Poli 2015, Jonathan Rch said, “There might nceivably (although not likely) be a se for takg the trouble to do all that msy and nfg rewirg if the moral claim of polygamy were remotely as strong as to the moral claim of gay marriage. There are many more exampl, and what was clear then and is playg out now is that the arguments suggtg gay marriage would not lead to polygamy simply make no sense.

Jt like the fallac claims that tearg down Conferate monuments would not lead to attacks on Gee Washgton and Thomas Jefferson, the pla logic of gay marriage always poted the directn of polygamy. Both Rch and Young ma moral claims their arguments as to why polygamy would not flow om gay marriage.

WHY SO FEW LBIANS AND GAYS MASTREAM POLY COMMUNY?

Gay marriage succeed by breakg down tradnal norms. There's no brgg them back to stave off polygamy. * gay polygamy *

How is a moral argument agast polygamy any different om a moral argument agast gay marriage? But also exists wh straight and gay marriag.

Now that the ncept of marriage has been turned to a malleable plastic, how n crics of polygamy who champned gay marriage say wh a straight face that nsentg adults should be barred om the practice?

And is somethg we will accept, jt as we have accepted gay marriage. Cathy YoungGay MarriageJonathan RchpolygamyProgrsivismUtah. Do you support the ncept of gay marriage?

NO, POLYGAMY ISN’T THE NEXT GAY MARRIAGE

The battle for gay marriage, if succsful, will naturally give rise to other mory groups fightg for their own refn of marriage. Enlightened people who support gay marriage should beg searchg their nscience for an hont answer to the qutn: if is acceptable for two gay people to marry, why shouldn't be acceptable for three (or more) people -- of any sex -- to be married?

He sums up the argument nicely:"In an say 10 years ago, I poted out that is utterly logil for polygamy rights to follow gay rights. After all, if tradnal marriage is fed as the unn of (1) two people of (2) oppose genr, and if, as advot of gay marriage sist, the genr requirement is nothg but prejudice, excln and an arbrary nial of one's tonomo choic love, then the first requirement -- the number rtrictn (two and only two) -- is a siarly arbrary, discrimatory and fensible nial of dividual choice. "He go on to pot out an tertg velopment:"This le of argument mak gay activists fur.

"But Krthammer ends up supportg both gay marriage and polygamy:"Call me agnostic. Although gay marriage is growg acceptance and support, polygamy is only acceptable to a ty agment of Amerins. What's strange about this is that while gay marriage is opposed on relig grounds by many, the same argument simply nnot be ma about polygamy.

HOW GAY MARRIAGE PAV THE WAY FOR LEGAL POLYGAMY

Polygamy, unlike gay marriage, has a long pedigree Judaism, Christiany, and Islam.

My pot is, there is a se to be ma today that there are people of fah more than one relign who believe the practice is sanctned by holy ncept of gay marriage didn't have that gog for , but has ma huge roads to acceptance by mastream Ameri which polygamy hasn't (yet). Now, mt be admted that gay marriage is still a hugely divisive issue self, and to date has lost almost every popular vote on the issue (all the "fense of marriage" ballot iativ); and furthermore has ed a feral law to be passed (the "Defense of Marriage Act") by Congrs which will one day undoubtedly be held up by law stunts as a blatantly unnstutnal example of a "bad lawmakg" (much as we view miscegenatn laws today), sce so obvly was passed and signed due to what Tocqueville lled "the tyranny of the majory. "But who among n't see a day the future when gay marriage is as unntroversial as, say, an Ain-Amerin marryg a Korean-Amerin?

FROM GAY MARRIAGE TO POLYGAMY?

Although still has a long way to go, the momentum is on s si (younger members of the public are much more tolerant of the ncept, pretty much guaranteeg s eventual acceptance) of this is what the right wg lls "Hollywood morals, " and they do have a pot -- the entertament dtry has advanced gay rights among mastream Ameri more than any other factor, I would be willg to bet. On televisn, particular, homosexualy was prent the past, but unacknowledged prr to the 1970s.

The clost Hollywood me to an actual gay character was on Three's Company -- and he was nothg more than a straight man pretendg to be gay to fool the landlord who lived downstairs, so he uld live wh two women (as if any Southern California landlord would have red, the '70s, as long as the rent checks didn't bounce... ) forward a few s, and gay characters abound on ss and dramas. Osr-wng films portray gay life, love, and tragedy -- om Philalphia (1993) to Brokeback Mounta (2005) recently, the show Big Love appeared on the air -- a look at polygamy as a ser subject (rather than merely beg lampooned) which was also the show's re ncept.

The gay rights movement has had to work long and hard to separate s e om the public's misguid perceptn of s associatn wh pedophilia, and the polygamy movement will have the same tough road ahead of, many people read my lumns and tend to thk I am advotg a pot, when I see myself as merely clarifyg the issue an objective way. But I also break this le ocsnally, and (due to the extremely ntroversial nature of this issue) I will do so now and tell you what I personally gay marriage, I have evolved om my roots of playg a game elementary school durg recs which we lled "smear the queer" (not even really knowg what a "queer" was, md you, at age eight), to now fully supportg gay rights as strongly as the next liberal. I have known many gay people my life, and thk they should be treated equally and whout discrimatn all thgs, up to and cludg marriage.

BT GAY POLYAMORO ROMANCE

A w-w solutn all around as far as I n see, and if you don't like "gay marriage" then you n jt jo a church that don't practice the subject of polygamy, I also fully support the ncept, while (of urse) remag vilently opposed to both unrage marriage and erced marriage.

MANY BRONS HAVE CHANGED THEIR MDS ON GAY MARRIAGE

There are currently tens of thoands (timat vary wildly, of urse) of Amerin cizens livg this liftyle who would be more than happy to have their unns legalized -- the same as gay the qutn needs now to be asked:If you support gay marriage, uld you also support polygamy? For stance, I began workg wh a gay male uple who told me that they were monogamo. This appears to acknowledge the lack of nversatn and openns amongst upl—gay or straight—that leads to a pture the relatnship and exs om timacy.

For stance, at a recent talk I gave on gay marriage, a group of Csian CEOs challenged me on the ncept. One man, particular, asked, “If we open the doors to gay marriage, then what’s next—polygamy?

Rearch shows that around 50 percent of gay male upl manage open relatnships succsfully. Too many happy and succsful relatnships, both gay and straight, have open ntracts around sex.

*BEAR-MAGAZINE.COM* GAY POLYGAMY

No, Polygamy Isn’t the Next Gay Marriage - POLITICO Magaze .

TOP