The Bchit Quot om Slia’s Gay Marriage Dissent | Vany Fair

Contents:

• WHY FOUR JTIC WERE AGAST THE SUPREME COURT'S HUGE GAY-MARRIAGE DECISN
• ANOTHER FERAL JUDGE TROLLS SLIA WHILE STRIKG DOWN GAY MARRIAGE BAN
• SLIA WARNED LAWRENCE V. TEXAS DISSENT THAT STRIKG DOWN SODOMY LAWS WOULD LEAD TO GAY MARRIAGE
• JTICE SLIA ON GAY ‘MARRIAGE’: ‘I DON’T KNOW HOW YOU N GET MORE EXTREME THAN THAT’
• SLIA'S ANGRY, INHERENT GAY MARRIAGE DISSENT
• THE BCHIT QUOT OM SLIA’S GAY MARRIAGE DISSENT
• SAME-SEX MARRIAGE SYMPOSIUM: JTICE SLIA’S NSTUTNAL SE FOR GAY MARRIAGE
• SLIA: GAY MARRIAGE CISN SHOWS AMERI’S ‘LER’ IS SUPREME COURT
• SLIA: ‘MORAL ISSU SUCH AS GAY MARRIAGE…HAVE NO BS BEG CID BY THE URT’
• SLIA’S GAY MARRIAGE PROBLEM
• ANTON SLIA'S GAY MARRIAGE DISSENT IS DRIPPG WH CONTEMPT AND SARSM
• SLIA BLAM GAY MARRIAGE CISN ON COURT’S LACK OF DIVERSY. THAT MAK NO SENSE.
• JTIC KENNEDY AND SLIA AND THEIR DIVI ON GAY RIGHTS

WHY FOUR JTIC WERE AGAST THE SUPREME COURT'S HUGE GAY-MARRIAGE DECISN

” Fally, Slia warned that the lg to extend marriage rights to gay upl across the untry would rob the urt of s power: “Hubris is sometim fed as o’erweeng pri; and pri, we know, goeth before a fall.

ANOTHER FERAL JUDGE TROLLS SLIA WHILE STRIKG DOWN GAY MARRIAGE BAN

In lg favor of gay marriage, he said, "Five lawyers have closed the bate and enacted their own visn of marriage as a matter of nstutnal law. "(RELATED: What 2016 Candidat Are Sayg About the Gay Marriage Rulg)Roberts's other dispute is that many of the arguments ma support of gay marriage uld also be ed to support plural marriage. "If not havg the opportuny to marry 'serv to disrpect and subordate' gay and lbian upl, why wouldn't the same 'imposn of this disabily, '...

"(RELATED: Watch The Two GOP Printial Candidat After the Supreme Court's Gay Marriage Decisn)Slia wrote that if he ever were to jo an opn that began wh that sentence he "would hi my head a bag, " sayg such language was more like the "mystil aphorisms of the fortune okie" than, say, legendary Chief Jtice John Marshall. "Jtice Samuel AloIn his dissent, Alo argued that gay marriage is not protected the Constutn unr the Due Procs Clse bee "liberty" only appli to those prcipl that are rooted U. The Jtic the majory claim the thory to nfer nstutnal protectn upon that right simply bee they believe that is fundamental, " Alo also reaffirmed his posn that there is no way to nfirm what the oute of gay marriage may be on the stutn of tradnal marriage, and therefore the Court is and should not be a posn to take on the "For lennia, marriage was extribly lked to the one thg that only an oppose-sex uple n do: procreate.

SLIA WARNED LAWRENCE V. TEXAS DISSENT THAT STRIKG DOWN SODOMY LAWS WOULD LEAD TO GAY MARRIAGE

Their basic argument is that Stat formalize and promote marriage, unlike other fulfillg human relatnships, orr to enurage potentially procreative nduct to take place wh a lastg un that has long been thought to provi the bt atmosphere for raisg that the majory has led favor of gay marriage, Alo offered a stark warng about future nflict between relig liberty and progrsive ias. Rellg the harsh treatment of gays and lbians the past, some may thk that turnabout is fair play. "Although the Court fds Idaho’s Marriage Laws were motivated, part, by important ernmental terts, their history monstrat that moral disapproval of homosexualy was an unrlyg, animatg factor, " Dale wrote.

JTICE SLIA ON GAY ‘MARRIAGE’: ‘I DON’T KNOW HOW YOU N GET MORE EXTREME THAN THAT’

As was the se wh the feral Defense of Marriage Act, stck down by the Supreme Court last year, the practil effect of Idaho’s same-sex marriage ban "is 'to impose a disadvantage, a separate stat, and so a stigma' on a class of people based solely on their sexual orientatn, " Dale joed feral judg Utah, Oh, Virgia, Kentucky, Texas, Oklahoma and Michigan cg Slia's dissent the 2003 Lawrence se, or his ragg dissent the DOMA se, strikg down state gay marriage You GoAnton Slia's Supreme FacPopular the CommunyYou May Like.

SLIA'S ANGRY, INHERENT GAY MARRIAGE DISSENT

(Charl Dharapak/AP)The Supreme Court avoid a lg on California's Proposn 8 se Wednday, which cleared the way for gay marriage to rume California, makg the 13th state (pl the District of Columbia) where same-sex marriage is legal. Exactly 10 years ago today, the Supreme Court siarly ma a landmark cisn for gay upl – strikg down the sodomy law Texas by a vote of 6-3 the landmark se Lawrence v.

In his dissent of that lg, Jtice Anton Slia angrily warned that if the urt was willg to strike down sodomy laws, other state laws on moral choic uld soon be lifted, among them gay marriage. If moral disapprobatn of homosexual nduct is 'no legimate state tert' for purpos of proscribg that nduct...

THE BCHIT QUOT OM SLIA’S GAY MARRIAGE DISSENT

What jtifitn uld there possibly be for nyg the benefs of marriage to homosexual upl exercisg '[t]he liberty protected by the Constutn?

SAME-SEX MARRIAGE SYMPOSIUM: JTICE SLIA’S NSTUTNAL SE FOR GAY MARRIAGE

On Wednday, the Court did not grant marriage equaly to all stat, as many gay advot hoped would. WASHINGTON -- In his dissent the Supreme Court's cisn to legalize gay marriage throughout the untry, Jtice Anton Slia rted part of his se on the notn that marriage was herently a self-limg proposn.

In dissent [ the Supreme Court lg which legaliz gay marriage natnwi], Jtice Anton Slia mocked the soarg language of Jtice Kennedy, who has bee the natn's most important judicial champn of gay rights: "The opn is. [Jtice Kennedy wrote legalizg gay marriage], "The generatns that wrote and ratified the Bill of Rights and the 14th Amendment did not prume to know the extent of eedom all of s dimensns, and so they entsted to future generatns a.

In 2003, the Supreme Court heard the se of two homosexual men who had been arrted and nvicted unr a Texas law that prohibed the act of sodomy.

SLIA: GAY MARRIAGE CISN SHOWS AMERI’S ‘LER’ IS SUPREME COURT

The people may feel that their disapprobatn of homosexual nduct is strong enough to disallow homosexual marriage, but not strong enough to crimalize private homosexual acts--and may legislate acrdgly. Consir that ls than eight months later, the Massachetts Supreme Court stck down that state's ban on homosexual marriage.

Supreme Court nomee John Roberts donated his time to work behd the scen for gay rights activists--and helped w a cisn that's been hailed as the "sgle most important posive lg" for the gay rights movement.

SLIA: ‘MORAL ISSU SUCH AS GAY MARRIAGE…HAVE NO BS BEG CID BY THE URT’

Roberts agreed to help reprent the gay rights activists as part of his law firm's pro bono work.

SLIA’S GAY MARRIAGE PROBLEM

Colorado iative that would have allowed employers and landlords to exclu gays om jobs and hog.

ANTON SLIA'S GAY MARRIAGE DISSENT IS DRIPPG WH CONTEMPT AND SARSM

A 6-3 lg strikg down the iative was hand down May gay activist lled the Supreme Court lg the "sgle most. 2003, the State Supreme Judicial Court gave the Massachetts legislature 6 months to enact a law grantg homosexuals the right to marry. In July, the US Supreme Court had stck down the laws of 17 stat and clared homosexual sodomy to be a.

though he and the state legislature believed that nothg the nstutn of the monwealth mandated gay marriag. In "Romer v Evans", the Supreme Court stck down, 6-3, the Colorado nstuent's provisn that homosexual, lbian, or bisexual stat should not entle any person to claim quota preferenc, protected stat, or discrimatn.

SLIA BLAM GAY MARRIAGE CISN ON COURT’S LACK OF DIVERSY. THAT MAK NO SENSE.

room to rent uld refe to let to a pair of homosexual men, or a church whose relign prohibed homosexual nduct uld ny a practicg homosexual a posn on s staff. whdraw this special protectn, which was not required to give the first place, was motivated only by "anim" and so uld not stand unr the ratnale of the equal protectn cisn is an unsupported victory for homosexual.

In "Romer v Evans", the Supreme Court led that Colorado uld not whdraw special protectn for homosexuals. [The Court's cisn] plac the prtige of this stutn behd the proposn that opposn to homosexualy is as reprehensible as racial or relig bias. jt observatn that the Colorado provisn "was an entirely reasonable provisn which do not even disfavor homosexuals any substantive sense, but merely ni them preferential treatment.

On public property about 1000 feet om his funeral service, the Wtboro Baptist Church followed s ctom of prottg at the funerals of service members wh signs nmng both homosexualy and the US for supportg .

JTIC KENNEDY AND SLIA AND THEIR DIVI ON GAY RIGHTS

The prottor's signs here ncerned plaly public matters such as the moral nduct of the US and s cizens, the fate of the natn, homosexualy the ary, and sndals volvg the Catholic clergy. DISSENT: ALITO dissentsThe prottors engaged a personal attack on Snyr's memory through signs implyg he was a homosexual, a Catholic, and doomed to hell for the �ss.