'This happens all the time': why a gay uple took their ke se to the supreme urt | US news | The Guardian

colorado gay cake case

The Colorado baker who won a partial Supreme Court victory after refg on relig grounds to make a gay uple’s weddg ke a ago is challengg

Contents:

SUPREME COURT CIS COLORADO GAY WEDDG KE SE: A TIMELE OF EVENTS

A Colorado baker who had won a narrow U.S. Supreme Court victory over his refal to make a weddg ke for a gay uple on Thursday lost his appeal of a lg a separate se that he vlated a state anti-discrimatn law by not makg a ke to celebrate a genr transn. * colorado gay cake case *

Supreme Court victory over his refal to make a weddg ke for a gay uple on Thursday lost his appeal of a lg a separate se that he vlated a state anti-discrimatn law by not makg a ke to celebrate a genr Colorado Court of Appeals agreed wh a trial judge that Masterpiece Cakhop and the bakery's owner, Jack Phillips, vlated Autumn Srda's rights by nyg her service bee of her inty as a transgenr woman. Supreme Court 2017 agreed to hear Phillips’ challenge to the Colorado Civil Rights Commissn's ncln he discrimated agast a gay uple for whom he had refed to make a weddg Supreme Court 2018 led Phillips' favor but on narrow grounds that stopped short of creatg a ee speech exemptn to anti-discrimatn laws, fdg the missn was hostile toward Phillips’ Christian 6-3 nservative majory urt December heard arguments a siar se volvg Alliance Defendg Freedom client Lorie Smh, a Christian web signer who argu she has a right to refe to provi servic for same-sex se is Srda v.

Supreme Court leans toward web signer wh anti-gay marriage stanceColorado baker se of Supreme Court su state over 'persecutn'U. Supreme Court backs Christian baker who rebuffed gay upleOur Standards: The Thomson Rters Tst Raymond reports on the feral judiciary and ligatn. That opn, also wrten by Kennedy, exprsed rpect for those wh relig objectns to gay marriage.

AS SUPREME COURT PREPAR TO LISTEN TO COLORADO GAY RIGHTS SE, BOTH SIS SAY STAK ARE HIGH

“Our society has e to the regnn that gay persons and gay upl nnot be treated as social outsts or as ferr digny and worth, ” he wrote Monday. “At the same time the relig and philosophil objectns to gay marriage are protected views and some stanc protected forms of exprsn, ” Kennedy wrote, addg that the “ntral nsiratn to which Phillips was entled was promised here. “The oute of s like this other circumstanc mt awa further elaboratn the urts, all the ntext of regnizg that the disput mt be rolved wh tolerance, whout undue disrpect to scere relig beliefs, and whout subjectg gay persons to digni when they seek goods and servic an open market, ” the opn stat.

“It’s about the right of gay people to receive equal service.

IN NARROW OPN, SUPREME COURT RUL FOR BAKER IN GAY-RIGHTS CASE

Cisn to take on the se reflected renewed energy among the urt's nservative jtic, whose ranks have recently been bolstered by the addn of Jtice Neil Gorsuch to the high Phillips, the owner of Masterpiece Cakhop Lakewood, Colo., cled to make a ke for the weddg celebratn of two gay men 2012.

COLORADO BAKER RECEIVES DEATH THREATS AND HATE FOR REFUSING TO MAKE GAY WEDDING CAKEPhillips was orred to change s pany polici as well as offer “prehensive staff trag” to employe. SUPREME COURT IS IN SESSION WITH GORSUCH ON BOARD, GAY WEDDING CAKE CASE ON DECK“We are askg the U.

"The laws and the Constutn n, and some stanc mt, protect gay persons and gay upl the exercise of their civil rights, but relig and philosophil objectns to gay marriage are protected views and some stanc protected forms of exprsn, " the Court said s cisn. "While is unexceptnal that Colorado law n protect gay persons acquirg products and servic on the same terms and ndns as are offered to other members of the public, the law mt be applied a manner that is ntral toward relign. "In s cisn, the Supreme Court did not ci whether a bs has the right to refe to serve gay and lbian people Bar Gsburg and Sonia Sotomayor, two of the Court's more liberal jtic, Associated Prs ntributed to this report.

'THIS HAPPENS ALL THE TIME': WHY A GAY UPLE TOOK THEIR KE SE TO THE SUPREME URT

The Colorado baker who won a partial Supreme Court victory after refg on relig grounds to make a gay uple’s weddg ke a ago is challengg a separate lg he vlated the state’s anti-discrimatn law by refg to make a ke celebratg a genr transn. But the hight urt the land is not cidg the big issue the se – whether a bs n refe to serve gay and lbian Supreme Court jtic' limed lg Monday turns on what the urt scribed as anti-relig bias on the Colorado Civil Rights Commissn when led agast baker Jack Phillips.

The se marks the send time five years that the Supreme Court has nonted the issue of a bs owner who says their relign prevents them om creatg works for a gay weddg. ” Those bs, they said, uld announce, “We Do Not Serve Blacks, Gays, or Mlims.

*BEAR-MAGAZINE.COM* COLORADO GAY CAKE CASE

CPR Logo</tle><path d="M12.793 10.853v3.243c-1.021.507-2.798.904-4.73.904C2.71 15 0 12.132 0 7.456 0 2.647 2.776 0 7.33 0c1.155 0 2.332.199 3.02.507l.333-.397h1.888v4.125h-2.487l-.29-1.61c-.288-.154-1.154-.309-1.931-.309-2.377 0-3.887 1.081-3.887 5.14 0 3.882 1.621 5.228 4.309 5.228.622 0 1.488-.133 1.754-.243l.289-1.588h2.465zm8.396 2.051v1.875h-6.708v-1.875h1.178l.177-.176V2.162l-.177-.177h-1.377V.11H21.7c3.998 0 5.62 1.743 5.62 4.522 0 3.067-2.066 4.544-5.909 4.544h-1.843v3.552l.2.176h1.421zm-1.621-5.823H21.3c1.777 0 2.377-.816 2.377-2.449 0-1.588-.622-2.404-2.377-2.404h-1.732V7.08zM43 14.779h-3.532c-.666-.176-1.465-.97-2.554-2.911L35.293 9.11h-1.555v3.618l.2.176h1.266v1.875h-6.552v-1.875h1.177l.178-.176V2.162l-.178-.177h-1.377V.11h7.596c4.065 0 5.642 1.765 5.642 4.39 0 1.875-1.089 3.22-2.799 3.838l1.466 2.25c1.2 1.875 1.666 2.316 2.643 2.316v1.875zm-9.262-7.654h1.844c1.888 0 2.443-.838 2.443-2.449 0-1.588-.533-2.448-2.399-2.448h-1.888v4.897z" fill="#FFF" fill-le="evenodd"></path></svg></a><div class="menu__wrapper--2tnWs menu__slimNav--U2lxe"><ul class="menu__list--xkWvX"><li class="menuItem__slimNav--1H8yi menuItem menuItem__slimNav--0"><a class="menuItem__lk--b-x5W" href=">News</a></li><li class="menuItem__slimNav--1H8yi menuItem menuItem__slimNav--1"><a class="menuItem__lk--b-x5W" href=">Classil</a></li><li class="menuItem__slimNav--1H8yi menuItem menuItem__slimNav--2"><a class="menuItem__lk--b-x5W" href=">Indie 102.3</a></li><li class="menuItem__slimNav--1H8yi menuItem menuItem__slimNav--3"><a class="menuItem__lk--b-x5W" href=">KRCC</a></li></ul></div><div class="listenLive__wrapper--3zuKX"><button type="button" class="listenLive__button--2eSb7"><span class="listenLive__buttonText--2Ii-w">Listen Live</span><span class="listenLive__arrow--1yPgM"></span></button><div class="listenLive__ntent--SIQhS"><ul class="listenLive__streams--1CfRy"><li style="--brand-lor:rgb(239, 101, 48)" class="listenLive__em--2RaXz"><div class="liveStream__wrapper--2pAUi d__liveStream--news"><div style="background-lor:#EEEEEE;height:100%;width:100%"></div></div></li><li style="--brand-lor:rgb(127, 56, 108)" class="listenLive__em--2RaXz"><div class="liveStream__wrapper--2pAUi d__liveStream--classil"><div style="background-lor:#EEEEEE;height:100%;width:100%"></div></div></li><li style="--brand-lor:rgb(41, 103, 149)" class="listenLive__em--2RaXz"><div class="liveStream__wrapper--2pAUi d__liveStream--die"><div style="background-lor:#EEEEEE;height:100%;width:100%"></div></div></li><li style="--brand-lor:rgb(50, 175, 163)" class="listenLive__em--2RaXz"><div class="liveStream__wrapper--2pAUi d__liveStream--krcc"><div style="background-lor:#EEEEEE;height:100%;width:100%"></div></div></li></ul><div class="listenLive__footer--2BJwH"><a class="listenLive__helpButton--2hgdU button__wrapper--1B-uq button__sendary--1LYE1" href="/listen/help/">Need help?</a></div></div></div></div><div class="slimNavigatn__searchDonate--wx3-h"><button type="button" class="searchButton__wrapper--1CDpL"><svg viewBox="0 0 22 23"><path d="M8.198 14.36c1.573 0 2.91-.55 4.011-1.65 1.101-1.102 1.652-2.439 1.652-4.012 0-1.572-.55-2.91-1.652-4.01-1.1-1.101-2.438-1.652-4.01-1.652-1.573 0-2.91.55-4.011 1.652-1.101 1.1-1.652 2.438-1.652 4.01 0 1.573.55 2.91 1.652 4.011 1.1 1.101 2.438 1.652 4.01 1.652zm7.55 0L22 20.614 20.113 22.5l-6.252-6.252v-1.003l-.354-.354c-1.494 1.298-3.264 1.947-5.309 1.947-2.28 0-4.217-.787-5.81-2.36C.797 12.907 0 10.98 0 8.699c0-2.28.796-4.217 2.389-5.81C3.98 1.297 5.918.5 8.199.5c2.28 0 4.207.796 5.78 2.389 1.572 1.592 2.359 3.529 2.359 5.81 0 2.044-.649 3.814-1.947 5.308l.354.354h1.003z" fill="#FFF" fill-le="nonzero"></path></svg></button><a class="donateButton donateButton__wrapper--2y7T1 slimNavDonateButton button__wrapper--1B-uq button__whIn--202k8" href="/donate/"><span class="donateButton__in--k89JC"><svg width="18" height="18" viewBox="0 0 24 24"><path d="M12 4.248c-3.148-5.402-12-3.825-12 2.944 0 4.661 5.571 9.427 12 15.808 6.43-6.381 12-11.147 12-15.808 0-6.792-8.875-8.306-12-2.944z"></path></svg></span>Donate</a></div></div><div class="searchBar__wrapper--XV3nR searchBar__wrapper--XV3nR"><form class="searchBar__form--2zM5c searchBar__form--2zM5c"><div class="text__putWrapper--2Vr-d searchBar__put--eJr-e searchBar__put--eJr-e"><label class="label__label--WqozB text__label--1cjrU" for="s">Search Input</label><put type="text" class="text__put--3wAzN" name="s" placeholr="Search…" value="" error=""/></div><button type="subm" class="searchBar__subm--2W2Gh searchBar__subm--2W2Gh"><svg viewBox="0 0 22 23"><path d="M8.198 14.36c1.573 0 2.91-.55 4.011-1.65 1.101-1.102 1.652-2.439 1.652-4.012 0-1.572-.55-2.91-1.652-4.01-1.1-1.101-2.438-1.652-4.01-1.652-1.573 0-2.91.55-4.011 1.652-1.101 1.1-1.652 2.438-1.652 4.01 0 1.573.55 2.91 1.652 4.011 1.1 1.101 2.438 1.652 4.01 1.652zm7.55 0L22 20.614 20.113 22.5l-6.252-6.252v-1.003l-.354-.354c-1.494 1.298-3.264 1.947-5.309 1.947-2.28 0-4.217-.787-5.81-2.36C.797 12.907 0 10.98 0 8.699c0-2.28.796-4.217 2.389-5.81C3.98 1.297 5.918.5 8.199.5c2.28 0 4.207.796 5.78 2.389 1.572 1.592 2.359 3.529 2.359 5.81 0 2.044-.649 3.814-1.947 5.308l.354.354h1.003z" fill="#FFF" fill-le="nonzero"></path></svg></button></form></div></div><hear class="hear__wrapper--3U2jz"><div class="hear__hear-top--1JFrd"><div class="ntaer__xxl--3SC ntaer__ntaer--a5NXK ntaer__paddg--2mKn5 hear__hear-ntent--3Pil6" id=""><a class="hear__logo--2A4EQ" href="/news/"><div class="logo__primary--2TQr3"><svg class="logo__newsLogo--2f1e6" viewBox="0 0 359 53" versn="1.1"><tle>cpr-logo-news</tle><path class="text" d="M92,43.347 C89.045,44.835 83.906,46 78.317,46 C62.837,46 55,37.588 55,23.87 C55,9.765 63.029,2 76.198,2 C79.538,2 82.941,2.582 84.934,3.488 L85.896,2.323 L91.356,2.323 L91.356,14.423 L84.163,14.423 L83.327,9.7 C82.492,9.248 79.987,8.794 77.739,8.794 C70.866,8.794 66.497,11.964 66.497,23.871 C66.497,35.259 71.186,39.206 78.959,39.206 C80.758,39.206 83.264,38.818 84.035,38.493 L84.869,33.836 L92,33.836 L92,43.347 L92,43.347 Z M116.457,22.433 C121.635,22.433 123.383,20.041 123.383,15.256 C123.383,10.6 121.571,8.208 116.457,8.208 L111.407,8.208 L111.407,22.433 L116.457,22.433 Z M116.133,45 L96.583,45 L96.583,39.505 L100.014,39.505 L100.531,38.987 L100.531,8.013 L100.014,7.495 L96,7.495 L96,2 L117.622,2 C129.274,2 134,7.108 134,15.256 C134,24.244 127.98,28.576 116.78,28.576 L111.407,28.576 L111.407,38.986 L111.99,39.505 L116.133,39.505 L116.133,45 Z M157.582,22.562 C163.033,22.562 164.636,20.105 164.636,15.385 C164.636,10.729 163.097,8.208 157.711,8.208 L152.261,8.208 L152.261,22.562 L157.582,22.562 Z M168.805,45 C166.88,44.482 164.572,42.154 161.429,36.464 L156.749,28.382 L152.261,28.382 L152.261,38.987 L152.838,39.503 L156.493,39.503 L156.493,45 L137.577,45 L137.577,39.503 L140.975,39.503 L141.488,38.987 L141.488,8.013 L140.975,7.495 L137,7.495 L137,2 L158.93,2 C170.664,2 175.215,7.172 175.215,14.867 C175.215,20.364 172.073,24.308 167.137,26.118 L171.37,32.713 C174.831,38.21 176.177,39.503 179,39.503 L179,45 L168.805,45 Z M244,7.495 L240.655,7.495 L240.076,8.013 L240.076,45 L230.683,45 L211.253,14.673 L210.674,14.673 L210.674,38.987 L211.189,39.503 L215.243,39.503 L215.243,45 L198.579,45 L198.579,39.503 L201.989,39.503 L202.503,38.987 L202.503,8.013 L201.988,7.495 L198,7.495 L198,2 L214.02,2 L231.39,29.223 L231.969,29.223 L231.969,8.013 L231.454,7.495 L227.466,7.495 L227.466,2 L244,2 L244,7.495 Z M255.568,25.366 L267.225,25.366 L267.225,24.198 C267.225,20.305 265.754,18.424 261.717,18.424 C257.555,18.424 255.888,20.564 255.568,25.366 L255.568,25.366 Z M274.078,43.793 C271.195,45.221 267.096,46 263.19,46 C251.34,46 245,39.576 245,29.13 C245,18.164 251.469,12 261.14,12 C271.388,12 276,17.514 276,26.274 C276,27.378 276,29.259 275.871,30.556 L255.441,30.556 C255.441,36.201 257.939,38.668 264.535,38.668 C267.931,38.668 271.772,37.888 273.823,36.98 L274.078,43.793 L274.078,43.793 Z M333,18.397 L331.137,18.397 L322.918,45 L312.902,45 L306.546,24.238 L305.968,24.238 L299.547,45 L289.594,45 L281.376,18.397 L279,18.397 L279,13 L295.95,13 L295.95,18.397 L292.741,18.397 L292.161,19.223 L296.209,34.842 L296.787,34.842 L302.885,14.714 L312.196,14.714 L318.424,34.842 L319.002,34.842 L322.918,19.222 L322.34,18.397 L318.745,18.397 L318.745,13 L333,13 L333,18.397 Z M357.295,20.046 C355.968,19.526 352.115,18.942 349.652,18.942 C345.989,18.942 344.915,19.85 344.915,22.122 C344.915,26.015 359,24.393 359,35.228 C359,41.781 354.515,46 344.978,46 C341.568,46 337.968,45.545 335.631,44.701 L336.2,37.695 C337.905,38.408 341.822,39.057 343.968,39.057 C347.948,39.057 349.02,38.213 349.02,35.812 C349.02,31.076 335,33.347 335,22.706 C335,16.217 339.295,12 348.579,12 C351.674,12 355.336,12.389 357.547,13.103 L357.295,20.046 Z" id="Shape" fill="#231F20"></path><path d="M32.573,0.472 L32.573,30.252 L20.993,30.27 C20.993,30.27 18.219,36.274 22.069,42.744 C25.922,49.216 35.155,49.877 35.155,49.877 L35.155,49.877 L33.705,53 C33.705,53 29.465,52.868 17.52,51.702 C5.58,50.537 0.048,39.541 0.051,32.292 C0.051,25.62568 0.0078336,4.325104 0.000926976,0.959676288 L0,0.51 L32.573,0.472 Z M24.04,18.6109912 C22.38,18.607 21.028,19.965 21.0299978,21.64 C21.028,23.31 22.376,24.668 24.0299978,24.6660022 C24.8319719,24.6649516 25.600458,24.34433 26.1653758,23.7750955 C26.7302936,23.205861 27.0450563,22.4349566 27.04006,21.633 C27.04006,19.971 25.695,18.608 24.04,18.6109912 Z" id="Combed-Shape" fill="#F16522"></path></svg></div></a></div></div><div class="hear__hear-bottom--1Ik3H"><div class="ntaer__xxl--3SC ntaer__ntaer--a5NXK ntaer__paddg--2mKn5 hear__hear-ntent--3Pil6" id=""><div class="menu__wrapper--2tnWs menu__hear--3hepL"><ul class="menu__list--xkWvX"><li class="menuItem__hear--1S8Gp menuItem menuItem__hear--0"><a class="menuItem__lk--b-x5W" href="/ronavis/">COVID-19</a></li><li class="menuItem__hear--1S8Gp menuItem menuItem__hear--1"><a class="menuItem__lk--b-x5W" href=">Polics</a></li><li class="menuItem__hear--1S8Gp menuItem menuItem__hear--2"><a class="menuItem__lk--b-x5W" href=">Money</a></li><li class="menuItem__hear--1S8Gp menuItem menuItem__hear--3"><a class="menuItem__lk--b-x5W" href=">Arts</a></li><li class="menuItem__hear--1S8Gp menuItem menuItem__hear--4"><a class="menuItem__lk--b-x5W" href=">Environment</a></li><li class="menuItem__hear--1S8Gp menuItem menuItem__hear--5"><a class="menuItem__lk--b-x5W" href=">Newsletter</a></li><li class="menuItem__hear--1S8Gp menuItem menuItem__hear--6"><a class="menuItem__lk--b-x5W" href="/support/">Support CPR</a></li></ul></div></div></div></hear><ma class="body__wrapper--2rRv1" role="ma" id="ntent" name="ntent"><div class="ntaer__xxl--3SC ntaer__ntaer--a5NXK ntaer__paddg--2mKn5 ntentHear__wrapper--3TaZb" id=""><hear class="ntentHear__hear--2thJR"><div class="ntentHear__ntentWhAsi--1bMeE"><h1 class="headg__step-up-three--4WDO6 headg__serif-headg--2CEp1 headg__headg--hUYqy ntentHear__headg--1JU3M"><span>As Supreme Court prepar to listen to Colorado gay rights se, both sis say stak are high</span></h1><div class="ntentHear__meta--3u-EJ"><div class="ntentByl__wrapper--WMhDK"><div class="ntentByl__avatar--3OA0F"><span class="image__wrapper--i55tn image__apsectRat--BncNO image__lazyload--1CqFg" style="paddg-bottom:100%"><img class="image__placeholr--1CF-F" src=" alt=""/><img alt="" class="image__img--3bF" src=" srcSet=" 214w, 107w, 800w, 400w" siz="400px"/></span></div><span class="ntentByl__byl--vmmBH"><span>By </span><a href=">The Associated Prs</a></span></div><span> · Dec. 3, 2022, 2:06 pm</span></div></div><asi class="ntentHear__hearSibar--2H_R9"><div class="socialList__wrapper--TEzWE"><span class="socialList__shareText--SbGXQ">Share: </span><ul class="socialList__list--35H_F"><li class="socialItem__wrapper--3fIBW"><a class="socialItem__lk--2J30T engagement__share--facebook" href=" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><svg viewBox="0 0 12 20" tabx="-1"><tle>Facebook</tle><path d="M8.4 3.5c-.4 0-.8.4-.8 1.1v2.2h3.9v3.3h-4v9.8H3.8v-9.7H.5V6.9h3.3V5c0-2.8 2-4.9 4.6-4.9h3.1v3.4H8.4z"></path></svg></a></li><li class="socialItem__wrapper--3fIBW"><a class="socialItem__lk--2J30T engagement__share--twter" href=" target="_blank" rel="noopener"><svg viewBox="0 0 23 20" tabx="-1"><tle>Twter .

TOP