How Persona 5 lets down s gay players

Contents:

• PERSONA 4: GOLN MOD RTOR GAY ROMANCE OPTN
• IS PERSONA 4‘S KANJI GAY OR NOT?
• PERSONA 4 IS SO GAY
• HOW PERSONA 5 LETS DOWN S GAY PLAYERS

PERSONA 4: GOLN MOD RTOR GAY ROMANCE OPTN

By clearly raisg the ia the player's md that Kanji is gay and then rejectg that ia, Persona 4 sends the msage that homosexualy is shameful and should not be 's start wh Kanji.

Here, I hoped, I would get a plex portrayal of a gay character, one who has sadly but unrstandably reprsed his sexualy rponse to societal prsure, who felt that he uld not be accepted as a tough guy if people knew he was also gay.

IS PERSONA 4‘S KANJI GAY OR NOT?

By clearly raisg the ia the player's md that Kanji is gay and then rejectg that ia, Persona 4 sends the msage that homosexualy is shameful and should not be accepted. Yose's attus about Kanji are problematic, and so is the game's way of handlg the story progrs, we're perdilly remd that, had he been gay, Kanji would not have been fully accepted by the other members of the vtigatn team, and, fact, some anxiety lgers later on about whether or not Kanji is tly straight. Rather than addrsg Yose's negative perceptns of homosexualy, perhaps wh a character arc which his prejudic are challenged and he be more open-md over time, Persona 4 lets his view of homosexualy as somethg to be feared stand unchallenged and unremarked upon, treatg as normal and acceptable.

By troducg the ia that Kanji is gay and that Naoto is transgenr and then backg away om embracg those characterizatns, Persona 4 reprents a betrayal of s central theme about people learng to accept themselv and each other for who they are, and sends the msage that such sexual orientatns and genr inti are too sry to accept. While Persona 2: Innocent S was ahead of the curve, cludg a gay romance optn all the way back 1999, recent history has been more spotty, wh Persona 5 drawg cricism om LGBT+ groups for the cln of two particularly stereotypil gay characters who pop up ocsnally as a nng gag, to the pot of havg their l rewrten the English release of Persona 5: Royal.

PERSONA 4 IS SO GAY

While had no nfirmed LGBT+ characters, do have one character, Kanji, who’s heavily hted as beg gay or bisexual, but looks like the game uld have gone a step further and clud a gay romance optn – party member Yose – an optn which has been ma available thanks to a mod of the PC versn of Persona 4: Goln, released earlier this year. Persona 5 isn’t outwardly transphobic or homophobic, though one scene the origal release has Ryuji beg pursued by two homosexual men shown as sexual viants. BoardsPersona 4 GolnHont qutn regardg the LGBT reprentatn *spoilers*Dark_Gunner 3 years ago#1I know that Kenji isn't exactly explicly said to be gay, and I know Naoto isn't explicly said to be trans or anythg but I am cur all the years later, if there's anyone actually wh those muni who n weigh on how well the game holds up reprentg those characters through that lens?

It's been years sce I played , and I remember lovg that was clud at all a JRPG at the time but I'm a straight whe du who hontly n't say for sure if was done well or Maker 2: SteveKoopa: ID 6K7-PR2-TWGSmash Ultimate Mas: Sam, Lus, JokerChillGamer 3 years ago#2It don't actually do a good job reprentg trans or gay characters, bee while the begng the game wants players to thk this is what's gog on wh the characters, turns the narrative on s head. I doubt they really give a s*** about queer bag back probably did and do, nsirg they add a gay romance P2 way earlier time jt bee 'd sre them lots of pots wh the fangirls. They probably did and do, nsirg they add a gay romance P2 way earlier time jt bee 'd sre them lots of pots wh the I do thk they're more likely to add thgs like that , for prof of urse they are a pany after all.

They probably did and do, nsirg they add a gay romance P2 way earlier time jt bee 'd sre them lots of pots wh the, Japane culture is way different than Wtern culture.

HOW PERSONA 5 LETS DOWN S GAY PLAYERS

"If you don't like , well that's a you problem"DylanYoshi 3 years ago#8Kanji is left ambiguo as to whether he's gay or not. Her's is a femist msage about how the toxicy of the male-domated police force ma her feel was origally planned to be a gay romance optn but was taken out late to velopment. @DylanYoshi I will say that if Yose remaed a gay love optn I'd prefer they rewre his character some as would have been a textbook example of panrg if they jt ma him gay as his character has 0 moments the ma plot where his sexualy uld be anythg other than straight.

" Jt any ltle breadcmb beg gay uld be apart of who he is as opposed to jt makg him gay for the sake of cludg a gay is tough, like real tough, like tough pl tough tim tough to the power of tough.